Lucas, Spurgeon LeRoy (promoter, deceased) Washington DC, Roe v. Wade lawyer
By Meredith Raney
Published August 26, 2012

Spurgeon Leroy Lucas, Esq. with his client Patricia Baird-Windle, owner of Aware Woman abortion clinic.
Born: 11/27/1941
Died: 11/3/2003
Spurgeon LeRoy Lucas, Esq. (a.k.a. Roy Lucas, Esq. DC #153957) is the architect of the "right to privacy" legal argument used to win the Roe v. Wade decision that legalized abortion in the U.S.
Spurgeon LeRoy Lucas is a member of the District of Columbia Bar Association, # 153967. Prior to his death, he was the pro hac vice (out of state) lawyer for the abortion industry in four federal lawsuits in Florida. They are:
- Raney v Aware Woman et al, 97-1197-CIV-ORL-19B
- Ocala Women’s Center et al v City of Ocala et al, 98-371-CIV-OC-10C
- Aware Woman et al v Raney et al, 99-05-CIV-ORL-19C
- Manhattan Magnolia Corp et al v Unterburger et al, 99-8164-CIV-HURLEY
“Suing web sites, seeking injunctions against the utterance of certain words and requiring disclaimers on protesters’ signs may test the First Amendment, but Lucas says that even though his approach would limit protester’s activities, he is not out to curb free speech.” – Meredith Raney, forerunner.com/fyi, 3/17/1999
Related Articles
- Roy Lucas: Architect of Roe v. Wade, North Carolina Law Review
- William Phillip Egherman: Abortion Related Investigations
- Abortion Clinic Owner Seeks Protection In Suit
- Matter of choice
- Lawyer brings quest to Florida, 3/17/1999
- Doctor seeks court injunction to protect privacy
- Judge rules police must protect abortion clinic, 4/28/1999
- Clinic owner sues abortion protesters
- Federal judge discontinues clinic's lawsuit, 12/23/1999
- Abortion doctors' suit thrown out, 12/24/1999
- Attorney error causes dismissal of abortion case
- Clinic owner indicted for extortion, 6/15/2000
- Where is Roy Lucas?
- Abortionist denies extortion charges
- FBI videotape allowed in Pendergraft case
- About Extortion or Abortion? 10/9/2000
- Judge gives psych evaluation thumbs-down
- Extortion trial start postponed
- Pendergraft trial begins, 1/3/2001
- Testimony Begins in Pendergraft Trial
- Cretul testifies at Federal trial
- Attorney challenges Cretul's testimony
- Judge recesses Pendergraft trial
- Local attorney testifies at Pendergraft trial
- FBI agents testify during Pendergraft trial
- Lies are revealed at Pendergraft trial
- Pendergraft takes the stand
- Pendergraft saw possible 'conspiracy'
- Pendergraft trial starts closing arguments
- Pendergraft lawyer charges racial overtones
- Pendergraft sentenced to 46 months, 5/25/2001
- Pendergraft serves 46 month sentence
- Roy Lucas, Roe v. Wade Lawyer, Dies at 61
- State of Florida suspends abortionist James Pendergraft, 8/19/2006
- That Swiss Hermit strikes again!
- A Call to War
- Victims of Choice
- Mauren Tyke - Victim of Choice, 5/31/1983
- Maureen Tyke - Victim of Choice - Autopsy Report
- Maureen Tyke - Victim of Choice - Certificate of Death
- Maureen Tyke - Clinic's patient dies 4 days after abortion
- Kirsten's Story - Victim of Choice, 5/24/1986
- Women's Rights Fuels Director Of Abortion Clinic, 5/28/1989
- Trish and Todd, Two Victims Who Got Away
- Tyke Memorial Service
- Joanna and Morgan, Two Victims Who Got Away
- A Letter from Our Mailbox
- Abortion clinic must relocate next summer
- City of Melbourne, Florida
- Operation Rescue Mission, 1/8/1998
- City of Melbourne, Florida: Prayer Proclamation
- One Red Line, 1/25/1998
- Fourth Aware Woman patient in 10 months taken to emergency room
- Egherman takes one of his victims to the emergency room himself
- State starts inquiry into clinic's work, 2/11/1998
- Clinic at center of anti-abortion movement besieged by complaints
- AHCA Letter, 2/26/1998
- AHCA Letter, 3/12/1998
- Pro-lifers to expose Aware Woman's maternal safety record
- Strange box causes scare at clinic, 6/7/1998
- Abortions down in Brevard, up in Florida
- Activists put women's clinic under scrutiny
- Why is the Brevard County abortion rate 52% less than the Florida average?
- Roy Lucas: Architect of Roe v. Wade, North Carolina Law Review
- AHCA Letter, 7/27/1998
- AHCA says perforated uterus is a "common complication" of abortion
- Abortionist sues Planned Parenthood
- William Phillip Egherman: Abortion Related Investigations
- Brevard tempting to terrorists?
- Clinic files second harassment lawsuit, 3/3/1999
- DOT to buy Aware Woman clinic site, 6/5/1999
- Clinic owner sues abortion protesters
- Jay's Killer* Mailbox
- Longtime clinic owner bows out
- Pioneer ran Brevard women's clinic for 22 years
- Key warrior for abortion rights gives up clinics
- Women's clinic moves to Suntree, 8/15/1999
- A radical bows out, 8/29/1999
- Another case against Melbourne pro-lifer dismissed
- Federal judge discontinues clinic's lawsuit, 12/23/1999
- Abortion doctors' suit thrown out, 12/24/1999
- Open season declared on pro-choice moms
- Abortion clinic's low profile contrasts with past conflicts
- Were abortions safer before they were legal?
- Attorney error causes dismissal of abortion case
- Clinic has support despite losing lease
- Ensure that abortion is available in Brevard, 6/12/2000
- Brevard needs to support operation of women's clinic
- Abortion clinic gave only one side, 6/14/2000
- Is Patricia Windle shaking down her former patients?
- Where is Roy Lucas?
- Girl says mom tried to force her into abortion, 8/2/2000
- Woman's clinic moves to north of Cocoa, 8/23/2000
- About Extortion or Abortion? 10/9/2000
- Forced Abortion Case Goes to US Supreme Court
- Targets of Hatred: Book Reviews
- Rendezvous at Roach Motel: Confronting the Rhetoric of Abortion
- PRI Weekly Briefing: About FACE
- Forced Abortions Now Felonies
- US Court of Appeals: Victim of forced abortion can remain anonymous
- US Supreme Court asked to review abortion policy
- Expose Evil, Tell the Truth
- Roy Lucas, Roe v. Wade Lawyer, Dies at 61
- Pat Windle calls me a highly-funded, sexually-repressed voyeur
- Chapter 1 - Abortion: The Religion of Witchcraft and Child Sacrifice
- Windle, Patricia Baird (owner, retired, watchlist) - Melbourne
- Victims of Choice
- Mauren Tyke - Victim of Choice, 5/31/1983
- Maureen Tyke - Victim of Choice - Autopsy Report
- Maureen Tyke - Victim of Choice - Certificate of Death
- Maureen Tyke - Clinic's patient dies 4 days after abortion
- Kirsten's Story - Victim of Choice, 5/24/1986
- Women's Rights Fuels Director Of Abortion Clinic, 5/28/1989
- Trish and Todd, Two Victims Who Got Away
- Tyke Memorial Service
- Joanna and Morgan, Two Victims Who Got Away
- A Letter from Our Mailbox
- Abortion clinic must relocate next summer
- City of Melbourne, Florida
- Operation Rescue Mission, 1/8/1998
- City of Melbourne, Florida: Prayer Proclamation
- One Red Line, 1/25/1998
- Fourth Aware Woman patient in 10 months taken to emergency room
- Egherman takes one of his victims to the emergency room himself
- State starts inquiry into clinic's work, 2/11/1998
- Clinic at center of anti-abortion movement besieged by complaints
- AHCA Letter, 2/26/1998
- AHCA Letter, 3/12/1998
- Pro-lifers to expose Aware Woman's maternal safety record
- Strange box causes scare at clinic, 6/7/1998
- Abortions down in Brevard, up in Florida
- Activists put women's clinic under scrutiny
- Why is the Brevard County abortion rate 52% less than the Florida average?
- Roy Lucas: Architect of Roe v. Wade, North Carolina Law Review
- AHCA Letter, 7/27/1998
- AHCA says perforated uterus is a "common complication" of abortion
- Abortionist sues Planned Parenthood
- William Phillip Egherman: Abortion Related Investigations
- Brevard tempting to terrorists?
- Clinic files second harassment lawsuit, 3/3/1999
- DOT to buy Aware Woman clinic site, 6/5/1999
- Clinic owner sues abortion protesters
- Jay's Killer* Mailbox
- Longtime clinic owner bows out
- Pioneer ran Brevard women's clinic for 22 years
- Key warrior for abortion rights gives up clinics
- Women's clinic moves to Suntree, 8/15/1999
- A radical bows out, 8/29/1999
- Another case against Melbourne pro-lifer dismissed
- Federal judge discontinues clinic's lawsuit, 12/23/1999
- Abortion doctors' suit thrown out, 12/24/1999
- Open season declared on pro-choice moms
- Abortion clinic's low profile contrasts with past conflicts
- Were abortions safer before they were legal?
- Attorney error causes dismissal of abortion case
- Clinic has support despite losing lease
- Ensure that abortion is available in Brevard, 6/12/2000
- Brevard needs to support operation of women's clinic
- Abortion clinic gave only one side, 6/14/2000
- Is Patricia Windle shaking down her former patients?
- Where is Roy Lucas?
- Girl says mom tried to force her into abortion, 8/2/2000
- Woman's clinic moves to north of Cocoa, 8/23/2000
- About Extortion or Abortion? 10/9/2000
- Forced Abortion Case Goes to US Supreme Court
- Targets of Hatred: Book Reviews
- Rendezvous at Roach Motel: Confronting the Rhetoric of Abortion
- PRI Weekly Briefing: About FACE
- Forced Abortions Now Felonies
- US Court of Appeals: Victim of forced abortion can remain anonymous
- US Supreme Court asked to review abortion policy
- Expose Evil, Tell the Truth
- Roy Lucas, Roe v. Wade Lawyer, Dies at 61
- Pat Windle calls me a highly-funded, sexually-repressed voyeur
- Chapter 1 - Abortion: The Religion of Witchcraft and Child Sacrifice
- Windle, Edward (owner, retired, watchlist) – Melbourne
- Man/woman couple circled with slash through them
- “CLINTON/GORE 96” bumper sticker
- Fish with feet and “DARWIN” inside
- “IN GODDESS WE TRUST” bumper sticker
- “SAVE THE MANATEE” license plate (cost = $17 a year extra. See the CHOOSE LIFE license plate.)
- “MOTHERHOOD BY CHOICE NOT CHANCE” bumper sticker.
- On top of bumper, not visible: “MY GODDESS GAVE BIRTH TO YOUR GOD”
- Trish and Todd are two.
- Joanna and Morgan are two more.
- Victims of Choice
- Mauren Tyke - Victim of Choice, 5/31/1983
- Maureen Tyke - Victim of Choice - Autopsy Report
- Maureen Tyke - Victim of Choice - Certificate of Death
- Maureen Tyke - Clinic's patient dies 4 days after abortion
- Kirsten's Story - Victim of Choice, 5/24/1986
- Women's Rights Fuels Director Of Abortion Clinic, 5/28/1989
- Trish and Todd, Two Victims Who Got Away
- Tyke Memorial Service
- Joanna and Morgan, Two Victims Who Got Away
- A Letter from Our Mailbox
- Abortion clinic must relocate next summer
- City of Melbourne, Florida
- Operation Rescue Mission, 1/8/1998
- City of Melbourne, Florida: Prayer Proclamation
- One Red Line, 1/25/1998
- Fourth Aware Woman patient in 10 months taken to emergency room
- Egherman takes one of his victims to the emergency room himself
- State starts inquiry into clinic's work, 2/11/1998
- Clinic at center of anti-abortion movement besieged by complaints
- AHCA Letter, 2/26/1998
- AHCA Letter, 3/12/1998
- Pro-lifers to expose Aware Woman's maternal safety record
- Strange box causes scare at clinic, 6/7/1998
- Abortions down in Brevard, up in Florida
- Activists put women's clinic under scrutiny
- Why is the Brevard County abortion rate 52% less than the Florida average?
- Roy Lucas: Architect of Roe v. Wade, North Carolina Law Review
- AHCA Letter, 7/27/1998
- AHCA says perforated uterus is a "common complication" of abortion
- Abortionist sues Planned Parenthood
- William Phillip Egherman: Abortion Related Investigations
- Brevard tempting to terrorists?
- Clinic files second harassment lawsuit, 3/3/1999
- DOT to buy Aware Woman clinic site, 6/5/1999
- Clinic owner sues abortion protesters
- Jay's Killer* Mailbox
- Longtime clinic owner bows out
- Pioneer ran Brevard women's clinic for 22 years
- Key warrior for abortion rights gives up clinics
- Women's clinic moves to Suntree, 8/15/1999
- A radical bows out, 8/29/1999
- Another case against Melbourne pro-lifer dismissed
- Federal judge discontinues clinic's lawsuit, 12/23/1999
- Abortion doctors' suit thrown out, 12/24/1999
- Open season declared on pro-choice moms
- Abortion clinic's low profile contrasts with past conflicts
- Were abortions safer before they were legal?
- Attorney error causes dismissal of abortion case
- Ensure that abortion is available in Brevard, 6/12/2000
- Brevard needs to support operation of women's clinic
- Abortion clinic gave only one side, 6/14/2000
- Is Patricia Windle shaking down her former patients?
- Where is Roy Lucas?
- Girl says mom tried to force her into abortion, 8/2/2000
- Forced Abortion Case Goes to US Supreme Court
- Targets of Hatred: Book Reviews
- Rendezvous at Roach Motel: Confronting the Rhetoric of Abortion
- PRI Weekly Briefing: About FACE
- Forced Abortions Now Felonies
- US Court of Appeals: Victim of forced abortion can remain anonymous
- US Supreme Court asked to review abortion policy
- Expose Evil, Tell the Truth
- Roy Lucas, Roe v. Wade Lawyer, Dies at 61
- Request for a published interview
- Abortionist James Pendergraft (extortion)
- Abortionist Walker Whaley (conspiracy to manufacture synthetic cocaine)
- Abortionist Randall Whitney (aggravated battery)
- Abortionist Zvi Harry Perper (racketeering, drug trafficking)
- Nauert, Jodell Lynne (owner) Clearwater, St. Petersburg, Tampa
- Does Charlie Daniels know he is sharing the bill with an abortionist?
- Disabled Veteran Injured at Pro-life Awareness Campaign
- Does Charlie Daniels know he is sharing the bill with an abortionist?
- Nauert, George Michael (verified, deceased, owner) - Palm Harbor
- Disabled Veteran Injured at Pro-life Awareness Campaign
- Theodor Lehrer Faces Three Charges, 5/18/1988
- Woman: Abortion Performed Against Will, 5/28/1988
- Lehrer Investigation Ends, 8/26/1989
- Nonrenewal of Privileges at Shands HealthCare in Gainesville, in 2000
- Denial of Privileges by Shands Lake Shore in 2001
- Consent Agreement between Dr. Quintana and the State of Florida Department of Health Board of Medicine in 2004
- Practitioner of partial birth abortion
- Practitioner of forced abortion
- Fourth Aware Woman patient in 10 months taken to emergency room
- Egherman takes one of his victims to the emergency room himself
- State starts inquiry into clinic's work, 2/11/1998
- Clinic at center of anti-abortion movement besieged by complaints
- AHCA Letter, 2/26/1998
- AHCA Letter, 3/12/1998
- Pro-lifers to expose Aware Woman's maternal safety record
- Why is the Brevard County abortion rate 52% less than the Florida average?
- AHCA Letter, 7/27/1998
- AHCA says perforated uterus is a "common complication" of abortion
- Abortionist sues Planned Parenthood
- William Phillip Egherman: Abortion Related Investigations
- Open season declared on pro-choice moms
- Forced Abortion Case Goes to US Supreme Court
- PRI Weekly Briefing: About FACE
- Forced Abortions Now Felonies
- US Court of Appeals: Victim of forced abortion can remain anonymous
- US Supreme Court asked to review abortion policy
- Abortion Clinic 911 Emergency Calls (1 of 4)
- Abortion Clinic 911 Emergency Calls (3 of 4)
- Request for a published interview
- The Hammer of God – The Florida Pro-life Network
- Doctor says he didn't sell any sample drugs, 8/7/1985
- 5 doctors plead guilty in drug case
- St. Petersburg doctors disciplined, 6/6/1987
- Abortionist accused of negligence in fetus' death, 11/22/1987
- Orlando Abortion Center Worker Quits - Salvation Testimony
- Justifiable Homicide?
- Dr. George Tiller and Defensive Action
The following lists will always be incomplete and need updating due to the transient nature of the abortion industry. And that is why we need constant help. If you see any inaccuracies here or are able to give input, please email us. Our desire is that the individuals listed here will know the love of God, repent of the sin of child murder and become followers of Christ as so many before them have done.
- A Killer Template
- Florida's Abortion Industry
- Killer: A Definition
- Applegate, Gerald Brian (verified) – Doral
- Arcelin, Gostal (watch list) – Boca Raton
- Azima, Ali Asghar (owner, verified) – North Fort Myers
- Baill, I' Cori (verified, promoter) – Orlando, Lakeland
- Barquet, Luis (deceased) - Miami
- Bazile, Frantz (owner, verified) – Miami
- Benjamin, Michael J. (owner, verified) – Miami
- Betancourt, Fernando Ricardo (verified) – Ft. Myers, Sarasota, Tampa
- Bodman, Uzy (verified) Hialeah, Miramar, Plantation
- Braithwaite, Sylvester Reynold (owner, verified) – North Miami Beach
- Britton, John Bayard (verified, deceased) – Fernandina Beach
- Broadnax, Gary B (retired, watchlist) – Augusta, GA
- Brown, David Steven (verified) – Hialeah, Miramar
- Bundy, Ralph Lawson (verified) – Daytona, Orlando
- Buonopane, Edward Joseph (verified) – Davie
- Cohan, Carol (promoter) – Miami
- Davy, Kristin (owner) - Gainesville
- DeHaan, Quentin C (verified) – Clearwater, Tampa
- Dresden, Gary (verified, owner) – Clearwater, Tampa
- Dresden, Scott Charles (verified) – Delray Beach
- Egherman, William Phillip (deceased) - Gainesville
- Elneser, Rafael M (verified) - Miami
- Estes, Christopher Michael (verified, promoter, instructor) – Miami
- Fanarjian, Nicole Joy (verified) – Sarasota
- Felski, Emil F. (verified) - Orlando
- Florida Abortionists
- Friefeld, Richard Stuart (verified) – North Miami
- Gengelbach, James Gordon (verified, watchlist) – Lakeland, Jacksonville, Tampa, Altamonte Springs, Gainesville
- Gil, Magaly (owner) – Miami
- Gonzalez, Belkis (owner) – Hialeah
- Graber, Benjamin (verified) – Coral Springs
- Guerrero (Dye), Candace M. (owner) – Fort Pierce
- Idtensohn, Susan Rodman (Planned Parenthood CEO, retired) – Orlando
- Jones, Malcolm Wells (verified) – Clearwater, Tampa, Lakeland
- Kachinas, Matthew Jay (verified, suspended) – Venice
- Keene, William Philip (verified) – St. Petersburg, Pensacola
- Kelly, Patrick Joseph (verified, owner) – Jacksonville
- Lehrer, Theodor (verified) – Fort Lauderdale
- Livingston, Robert Michael (watchlist, permanently suspended) – Vero Beach
- Lucas, Spurgeon LeRoy (promoter, deceased) Washington DC, Roe v. Wade lawyer
- Lupi, Carla Shyrl (verified, promoter, instructor) – Miami
- Maurer, Susan (owner) – Miami
- McCree, Douglas Gene (verified) – Naples
- Miller Jr., Herman (verified) - Jacksonville
- Miller, Lawrence Whitefield (retired, watchlist) - Jacksonville
- Morris, Merri Beth (verified) - Tampa, Ocala
- Nauert, George Michael (verified, deceased, owner) - Palm Harbor
- Nauert, Jodell Lynne (owner) Clearwater, St. Petersburg, Tampa
- Nisbet, Kieron (worker, watchlist) - Hialeah
- Norris, Paul Michael (verified, promoter, instructor) – Miami
- Osborne, Robelto (revoked, watchlist) – Miami
- Patel, Rupa Dilipkumar (verified) - Tampa, Orlando
- Peguero, Felicita (owner) – Miami
- Peguero, Maria (owner) – Miami
- Pendergraft, James Scott (owner, verified) – Orlando, Ocala, Tampa, Fort Lauderdale
- Perper, Zvi Harry (verified) – Delray Beach
- Poy-Wing, Celina (owner, verified) – Plantation
- Prabhakaran, Sujatha (verified) – St. Petersburg
- Quintana, Jose Raul (verified) – Tampa, Orlando
- Raum, Mary Elwin Pugh (verified) – Gainesville
- Ravi, Himagiri G. (verified) – Lakeland
- Reis, Mona S (owner, promoter) – West Palm Beach
- Renelique, Pierre Jean-Jacques (watchlist, revoked) - Hialeah
- Rodriguez, Frank (verified) – West Palm Beach
- Rodriguez, Jose (former owner, watchlist) – Miami
- Rosenthal, Evelina Mira (owner) – Miami
- Rosenthal, Vladimir (verified, owner) – Miami
- Roth, Harvey Craig (verified) – Boca Raton
- Sanchez Jr., Joe (deceased) – Lakeland
- Senises, Siomara (owner) – Miami
- Sibley, Paul Leslie (verified, deceased) – Gainesville
- Snydle, Frank Emil (null and void, deceased) – Winter Haven
- Sobieski, Tammy (owner) – Orlando, Daytona
- Spagnolo-Hye, Scott Evan (verified, watchlist) – Orlando, Tampa, Ocala
- Spence, Mark R (verified) – Hialeah
- Stockman, Cynthia D. (owner) – Fort Lauderdale
- Stockman, Richard T. (owner) – Fort Lauderdale
- Van Scriver, Kimberly Pauline (verified) – Jacksonville
- Vergara, Natali (owner, administrator) – Hialeah, Miramar
- Waterman II, Philip F. (verified) – Naples, Fort Myers
- Watson, Edward Ray (verified) – Miami
- Weinstein, Joan (owner) – Fort Lauderdale
- Whaley, Walker L. (verified, deceased) – Jacksonville, Gainesville
- Whitney, Randall Brooks (verified) – Orlando
- Windle, Edward (owner, retired, watchlist) – Melbourne
- Windle, Patricia Baird (owner, retired, watchlist) - Melbourne
- Wolf, Lewis Sidney (verified, revoked) - St. Petersburg, Tampa, Melbourne
- Behind the Scenes (part 1) The Corporation Search
- Behind the Scenes (part 2) Internet Searches
- Behind the Scenes (part 3) Call the Abortion Center for Information
Here are two articles demonstrating the effectiveness of residential picketing:
- Pro-life Residential Pickets
- Residential Picketing: Questions and Concerns
The following is an article by Rusty Thomas about maintaining a right spirit that should be read by everyone involved in pro-life street activism:
- Pro-Life Pitfalls
Buonopane, Edward Joseph (verified) – Davie
By Jay Rogers
Published July 10, 2011Killing Place:
Women’s Awareness
5700 Griffin Rd, Ste 130
Davie, FL 33314Home:
(old address)4100 NW 74th Street
Pompano Beach, FL 33073
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapHome:
(current)
8156 Pine Circle
Tamarac, FL 33321
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapYOB: c. 1951
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Plantation General HospitalDisciplinary action on file.
Florida Abortionists
By Jay Rogers
Published July 10, 2011
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map- A Killer Template
- Florida's Abortion Industry
- Killer: A Definition
- Why We List Abortionists
- Applegate, Gerald Brian (verified) – Doral
- Arcelin, Gostal (watch list) – Boca Raton
- Azima, Ali Asghar (owner, verified) – North Fort Myers
- Baill, I' Cori (verified, promoter) – Orlando, Lakeland
- Barquet, Luis (deceased) - Miami
- Bazile, Frantz (owner, verified) – Miami
- Benjamin, Michael J. (owner, verified) – Miami
- Betancourt, Fernando Ricardo (verified) – Ft. Myers, Sarasota, Tampa
- Bodman, Uzy (verified) Hialeah, Miramar, Plantation
- Braithwaite, Sylvester Reynold (owner, verified) – North Miami Beach
- Britton, John Bayard (verified, deceased) – Fernandina Beach
- Broadnax, Gary B (retired, watchlist) – Augusta, GA
- Brown, David Steven (verified) – Hialeah, Miramar
- Bundy, Ralph Lawson (verified) – Daytona, Orlando
- Buonopane, Edward Joseph (verified) – Davie
- Cohan, Carol (promoter) – Miami
- Davy, Kristin (owner) - Gainesville
- DeHaan, Quentin C (verified) – Clearwater, Tampa
- Dresden, Gary (verified, owner) – Clearwater, Tampa
- Dresden, Scott Charles (verified) – Delray Beach
- Egherman, William Phillip (deceased) - Gainesville
- Elneser, Rafael M (verified) - Miami
- Estes, Christopher Michael (verified, promoter, instructor) – Miami
- Fanarjian, Nicole Joy (verified) – Sarasota
- Felski, Emil F. (verified) - Orlando
- Friefeld, Richard Stuart (verified) – North Miami
- Gengelbach, James Gordon (verified, watchlist) – Lakeland, Jacksonville, Tampa, Altamonte Springs, Gainesville
- Gil, Magaly (owner) – Miami
- Gonzalez, Belkis (owner) – Hialeah
- Graber, Benjamin (verified) – Coral Springs
- Guerrero (Dye), Candace M. (owner) – Fort Pierce
- Idtensohn, Susan Rodman (Planned Parenthood CEO, retired) – Orlando
- Jones, Malcolm Wells (verified) – Clearwater, Tampa, Lakeland
- Kachinas, Matthew Jay (verified, suspended) – Venice
- Keene, William Philip (verified) – St. Petersburg, Pensacola
- Kelly, Patrick Joseph (verified, owner) – Jacksonville
- Lehrer, Theodor (verified) – Fort Lauderdale
- Livingston, Robert Michael (watchlist, permanently suspended) – Vero Beach
- Lucas, Spurgeon LeRoy (promoter, deceased) Washington DC, Roe v. Wade lawyer
- Lupi, Carla Shyrl (verified, promoter, instructor) – Miami
- Maurer, Susan (owner) – Miami
- McCree, Douglas Gene (verified) – Naples
- Miller Jr., Herman (verified) - Jacksonville
- Miller, Lawrence Whitefield (retired, watchlist) - Jacksonville
- Morris, Merri Beth (verified) - Tampa, Ocala
- Nauert, George Michael (verified, deceased, owner) - Palm Harbor
- Nauert, Jodell Lynne (owner) Clearwater, St. Petersburg, Tampa
- Nisbet, Kieron (worker, watchlist) - Hialeah
- Norris, Paul Michael (verified, promoter, instructor) – Miami
- Osborne, Robelto (revoked, watchlist) – Miami
- Patel, Rupa Dilipkumar (verified) - Tampa, Orlando
- Peguero, Felicita (owner) – Miami
- Peguero, Maria (owner) – Miami
- Pendergraft, James Scott (owner, verified) – Orlando, Ocala, Tampa, Fort Lauderdale
- Perper, Zvi Harry (verified) – Delray Beach
- Poy-Wing, Celina (owner, verified) – Plantation
- Prabhakaran, Sujatha (verified) – St. Petersburg
- Quintana, Jose Raul (verified) – Tampa, Orlando
- Raum, Mary Elwin Pugh (verified) – Gainesville
- Ravi, Himagiri G. (verified) – Lakeland
- Reis, Mona S (owner, promoter) – West Palm Beach
- Renelique, Pierre Jean-Jacques (watchlist, revoked) - Hialeah
- Rodriguez, Frank (verified) – West Palm Beach
- Rodriguez, Jose (former owner, watchlist) – Miami
- Rosenthal, Evelina Mira (owner) – Miami
- Rosenthal, Vladimir (verified, owner) – Miami
- Roth, Harvey Craig (verified) – Boca Raton
- Sanchez Jr., Joe (deceased) – Lakeland
- Senises, Siomara (owner) – Miami
- Sibley, Paul Leslie (verified, deceased) – Gainesville
- Snydle, Frank Emil (null and void, deceased) – Winter Haven
- Sobieski, Tammy (owner) – Orlando, Daytona
- Spagnolo-Hye, Scott Evan (verified, watchlist) – Orlando, Tampa, Ocala
- Spence, Mark R (verified) – Hialeah
- Stockman, Cynthia D. (owner) – Fort Lauderdale
- Stockman, Richard T. (owner) – Fort Lauderdale
- Van Scriver, Kimberly Pauline (verified) – Jacksonville
- Vergara, Natali (owner, administrator) – Hialeah, Miramar
- Waterman II, Philip F. (verified) – Naples, Fort Myers
- Watson, Edward Ray (verified) – Miami
- Weinstein, Joan (owner) – Fort Lauderdale
- Whaley, Walker L. (verified, deceased) – Jacksonville, Gainesville
- Whitney, Randall Brooks (verified) – Orlando
- Windle, Edward (owner, retired, watchlist) – Melbourne
- Windle, Patricia Baird (owner, retired, watchlist) - Melbourne
- Wolf, Lewis Sidney (verified, revoked) - St. Petersburg, Tampa, Melbourne
- Women's Rights Fuels Director Of Abortion Clinic, 5/28/1989
- Abortion Clinic 911 Emergency Calls (3 of 4)
- Orlando Abortionist Randall Whitney arrested for aggravated battery
- Abortionist Randall Whitney Arrested … Again!
- Abortionist Randall Whitney injures yet another woman
- Civil lawsuit case against James Pendergraft, 7/24/2011
- Final judgment in civil lawsuit against James Pendergraft: $36.7 million
- Residential Pickets - OSA Orlando Recap (Part 3)
- Florida DOH recommends suspension of abortionist Randall Whitney's license
- Orlando Abortionist Pendergraft suspended for fifth time
- Is Kermit Gosnell an outlier?
- Abortionist James Pendergraft's $36.7 Million Judgment
- Abortions down in Brevard, up in Florida
- Clinic worker violates FACE - report made to FBI
- Longtime clinic owner bows out
- Central East - Melbourne - WomanCare of Melbourne (closed!)*
- Women's clinic moves to Suntree, 8/15/1999
- Pro-life activists get wet welcome
- Pro-lifers ordered out of eatery
- Ralph Bundy, The Abortion Clinic Doctor
- Clinic owner violates FACE, 11/6/1999
- Letter to FBI - 12/4/99
- More FACE violations by Brevard County Sheriff's Deputies
- Taxpayers pay for security fence at abortion clinic
- Abortion clinic's low profile contrasts with past conflicts
- Keep pro-lifers away at any cost!
- 911 Call to WomanCare Abortion Clinic in Melbourne, Florida
- WomanCare kicked out of plaza, 6/6/2000
- Clinic has support despite losing lease
- Ensure that abortion is available in Brevard, 6/12/2000
- Brevard needs to support operation of women's clinic
- Abortion clinic gave only one side, 6/14/2000
- Grandma should be charged with FACE
- Woman's clinic moves to north of Cocoa, 8/23/2000
- Marketing the abortion industry
- Action limits abortion options
- Residential Pickets - OSA Orlando Recap (Part 3)
- Pro-life Residential Pickets
- Residential Pickets - OSA Orlando Recap (Part 3)
- Abortion Clinic Loses Bid To Open, 9/20/1995
- Abortion Plan Gets Close But Loses Again, 11/10/1995
- Doctor May Take City To Court Over Abortion Center
- Abortion Doctor Sues Over Office
- Lawyer: Orlando Protected From Lawsuit In Clinic Case
- Judge Hears Abortion Doctor's Zoning Dispute, 1/6/1996
- Doctor Seeking Abortion Office Gets Hearing
- Doctor Wins Round In Fight Over Abortion
- Abortion Practice Blocked, 3/12/1996
- Orlando To Allow Abortion Facility, 3/15/1996
- Abortion Doctor Accepting Patients In Orlando
- Doctor In Orlando Can Do 2nd-trimester Abortions, 4/19/1996
- Doctor To City: Let's End Fight
- Abortion Doctor Says Settle Suit Or Lose Millions
- Abortion Doctor May Get $325,000
- City Okays $325,000 For Abortion Doctor
- Who Stands To Profit?
- Operation Rescue Mission, 1/8/1998
- Ocala Resists Abortion Clinic, 3/1/1998
- Abortion Clinic To Open Next Week In Ocala
- Doctor Who Sued Orlando Opening Abortion Clinic
- Abortion Clinic Owner Seeks Protection In Suit
- Physician sues city, county, 12/11/1998
- Matter of choice
- Lawyer brings quest to Florida, 3/17/1999
- Doctor seeks court injunction to protect privacy
- Owner Of Abortion Clinic Not Bothered By Protests
- Judge rules police must protect abortion clinic, 4/28/1999
- Judge: Off-duty Police Can Guard Clinics
- Police security prices up
- The Specialist, 6/1/1999
- Another case against Melbourne pro-lifer dismissed
- Federal judge discontinues clinic's lawsuit, 12/23/1999
- Abortion doctors' suit thrown out, 12/24/1999
- Honoring "Little Mary" and Other Disposable Babies
- Clinic owner indicted for extortion, 6/15/2000
- Orlando Abortion Doctor Indicted
- Where is Roy Lucas?
- Abortionist denies extortion charges
- James Pendergraft: "I Am Not A Criminal"
- FBI videotape allowed in Pendergraft case
- About Extortion or Abortion? 10/9/2000
- Judge gives psych evaluation thumbs-down
- Extortion Case Delayed, 12/12/2000
- Extortion trial start postponed
- Pendergraft trial begins, 1/3/2001
- Testimony Begins in Pendergraft Trial
- Prosecutor: Abortion Doctor Tried To Get Payoff
- Cretul testifies at Federal trial
- Jury Hears Taped Pitch To Make Deal
- Attorney challenges Cretul's testimony
- Commissioner Testifies
- Judge recesses Pendergraft trial
- Jurors Watch Abortion Doctor Video
- Local attorney testifies at Pendergraft trial
- FBI agents testify during Pendergraft trial
- Defense attorney: FBI probe of abortion doctor was 'attempted entrapment'
- Judge says testimony irrelevant
- Spielvogel takes stand in Pendegraft trial
- Co-defendant Takes Blame In Abortion Clinic Case
- Lies are revealed at Pendergraft trial
- Abortionist: Adviser Misled Me
- Pendergraft takes the stand
- Clinic Needed Protection, Doctor Says
- Pendergraft saw possible 'conspiracy'
- Doctor Defends Payments To Adviser
- Pendergraft trial starts closing arguments
- Pendergraft lawyer charges racial overtones
- Pendergraft extortion trial jury returns, 2/1/2001
- Verdict Won't Close Clinics, Doctor Vows
- Jury convicts Pendergraft, Spielvogel, 2/2/2001
- Pendergraft sentenced to 46 months, 5/25/2001
- Pendergraft's Appeal Alleges Racism
- Pendergraft denied appeal bond, 6/21/2001
- Pendergraft serves 46 month sentence
- Letter From Imprisoned Abortionist James Pendergraft, 8/13/2001
- Doctor Is Let Out Of Prison, For Time Being, 2/28/2002
- Conviction Of Florida Abortionist Is Overturned, 7/17/2002
- Roy Lucas, Roe v. Wade Lawyer, Dies at 61
- Pendergraft Pleads Not Guilty To Last Count Of Extortion, 5/12/2004
- Pendergraft Admits To Deception For Associate
- Abortion Clinic 911 Emergency Calls - Baby Rowan
- Board won't discipline doctor, 4/9/2006
- State bars abortions at 2 clinics in Orlando, 8/17/2006
- Action limits abortion options
- State of Florida suspends abortionist James Pendergraft, 8/19/2006
- Abortionist Pendergraft: Restore license
- Three abortion clinics can open, 8/25/2006
- State refuses to restore abortionist Pendergraft's medical license, 12/1/2007
- Late abortion results in fine, suspension, 12/1/2007
- Abortion Clinic 911 Calls - Baby Rowan (Revisited)
- 22 Weeks premiere in Orlando
- 22 Weeks Premiere: Baby born alive after failed abortion!
- Late-term Abortionist Pendergraft loses license suspension appeal, 7/4/2009
- Can a pro-life video save unborn children?
- Orlando Abortionist Randall Whitney arrested for aggravated battery
- Suspended abortionist James Pendergraft suspended again, 8/11/2010
- Report: Central Florida abortionist receives fourth suspension, 8/11/2010
- Abortionist Randall Whitney Arrested … Again!
- Abortionist Pendergraft offers handprints and footprints of murdered babies
- Abortionist Zvi Harry Perper charged with racketeering and drug trafficking
- Central East - Orlando - EPOC Clinic
- Pro-life Residential Pickets
- Civil lawsuit case against James Pendergraft, 7/24/2011
- Final judgment in civil lawsuit against James Pendergraft: $36.7 million
- Residential Pickets - OSA Orlando Recap (Part 3)
- Fire-bombed Pensacola abortion mill linked to abortionist charged with murder
- Florida DOH recommends revocation of abortionist Pendergraft’s medical license
- Late Term Abortion: Can This Be Legal?
- The Tangled Legal History of James Pendergraft
- Florida DOH recommends suspension of abortionist Randall Whitney's license
- Orlando abortion clinic security officer arrested, accused of rape
- Orlando Abortionist Pendergraft suspended for fifth time
- Is Kermit Gosnell an outlier?
- Abortionist James Pendergraft's $36.7 Million Judgment
- Ralph Bundy, The Abortion Clinic Doctor
- Residential Pickets - OSA Orlando Recap (Part 3)
- Abortion doctor and protesters stand their ground at Fort Myers clinic
- Anti-abortion activists sue Sheriff McDougall over clinic protests
- Attorney asks for special prosecutor to investigate Sheriff McDougall
- A Killing Place Template
- Florida's Abortion Industry
- Central East - Altamonte Springs - All Women's Health Center of Orlando
- Central East - Daytona Beach - WomanCare of Daytona Beach
- Central East - Melbourne - Aware Woman Center for Choice (closed!)*
- Central East - Melbourne - WomanCare of Melbourne (closed!)*
- Central East - Orlando - EPOC Clinic
- Central East - Orlando - Orlando Women's Center
- Central East - Orlando - Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando
- Central East - Orlando - Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando Eastside
- Central East - Orlando - WomanCare of Orlando
- Central West - Clearwater - Bread & Roses Woman's Health
- Central West - Clearwater - Women's ObGyn Center of Countryside
- Central West - Lakeland - Lakeland Women's Health Center
- Central West - Saint Petersburg - All Women's Health Center
- Central West - Saint Petersburg - Planned Parenthood: Pinellas Health Center
- Central West - Saint Petersburg - St. Petersburg Woman's Health Center
- Central West - Tampa - All Women's Health Center of North Tampa
- Central West - Tampa - All Women's Health Center of Tampa
- Central West - Tampa - Planned Parenthood: Tampa Health Center
- Central West - Tampa - Tampa Woman's Health Center
- Central West - Tampa - Women's Center of Hyde Park
- Central West - Winter Haven - Planned Parenthood: Winter Haven Health Center
- North East - Gainesville - All Women's Health Center of Gainesville
- North East - Gainesville - Bread & Roses Women's Health
- North East - Jacksonville - A Woman's Choice of Jacksonville
- North East - Jacksonville - All Women's Health Center of Jacksonville
- North East - Jacksonville - Florida Women's Center
- North East - Jacksonville - Planned Parenthood of North Florida, Inc.
- North East - Ocala - Ocala Women's Center
- North West - Pensacola - American Family Planning Pensacola
- North West - Pensacola - AMS of Pensacola
- North West - Tallahassee - North Florida Women's Health
- South East - Boca Raton - Planned Parenthood: Boca Raton Health Center
- South East - Boca Raton - Robert M. Livingston, MD*
- South East - Coral Gables - Top-Gyn Ladies Center
- South East - Davie - Women's Awareness*
- South East - Fort Lauderdale - All Women's Medical Center
- South East - Fort Lauderdale - East Cypress Women's Center
- South East - Fort Lauderdale - Fort Lauderdale Women's Center
- South East - Fort Lauderdale - Today's Women Medical Center*
- South East - Fort Pierce - A Woman's World Medical Center
- South East - Hialeah - A Gyn Diagnostic Center
- South East - Hialeah - A Woman's Choice
- South East - Hialeah - A Woman's Option
- South East - Hialeah - Alba Medical Center
- South East - Hialeah - Hialeah Women's Center
- South East - Hollywood - A Woman's Center of Hollywood
- South East - Lake Worth - Planned Parenthood: Lake Worth Health Center
- South East - Miami - A Choice For Women
- South East - Miami - A Eve's Clinic
- South East - Miami - A Woman's Care
- South East - Miami - Advance Woman's Care Center
- South East - Miami - Advanced Gyn Clinic*
- South East - Miami - All Women's Healthcare of Dade*
- South East - Miami - Blue Coral Women's Care
- South East - Miami - BSS International Inc - Michael Benjamin, MD
- South East - Miami - Eve of Kendall
- South East - Miami - Millennium Women Center
- South East - Miami - New World Medical Choice*
- South East - Miami - Planned Parenthood: Jean Shehan Health Center*
- South East - Miami - Today's Women Medical Center
- South East - Miami - University of Miami*
- South East - Miramar - Miramar Woman Center
- South East - North Miami Beach - Women & Teens Healthcare*
- South East - Pembroke Pines - Planned Parenthood: Pembroke Pines Health Center
- South East - Plantation - Aastra Women's Center
- South East - Plantation - All Women's OB-Gyn Group*
- South East - West Palm Beach - Presidential Women's Center
- South West - Fort Myers - Fort Myers Women's Health Center
- South West - Fort Myers - Planned Parenthood: Fort Myers Health Center
- South West - Fort Myers - Southwest Florida Women's Clinic
- South West - Naples - Planned Parenthood: Naples Center
- South West - Port Charlotte - Southwest Florida Women's Clinic*
- South West - Sarasota - All Women's Health Center of Sarasota
- South West - Sarasota - Planned Parenthood of Southwest and Central Florida
- South West - Sarasota - Premiere Institute for Women's Health (closed!)* * No AHCA license was found at this address. All abortions clinics that do outpatient surgery are required to be licensed by the Florida Agency for Healthcare Administration AHCA. Not all abortion clinics are surgical outpatient facilities. Some do referrals to surgical centers. Some do chemical abortions (that is, by pill).
Whitney, Randall Brooks (verified) – Orlando
By Jay Rogers
Published July 10, 2011Killing Places:
Orlando Women’s Center
1103 Lucerne Terrace
Orlando, FL 32806-1016EPOC Clinic
609 Virginia Drive
Orlando, FL 32803-1893Ocala Women’s Center
108 NW Pine Ave
Ocala, FL 34475-6619Office:
Family Planning Inc
580 Mulberry Street
Daytona Beach 32114Home:
820 Indigo Court
Port Orange, FL 32129
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Whitney arrives at work at Orlando Women’s Center to kill babies with a smile on his face. This photo was taken the day after a plaintiff won a $36.7 million lawsuit against OWC due to a botched abortion by Whitney.
Born: July 13, 1933
Randall Whitney is a circuit rider abortionist for James Pendergraft’s Women’s Center mills in Orlando and Ocala specializing in 2nd trimester abortions. His medical license is currently being reviewed by the Florida Board of Medicine for a 2010 incident in which he was charged with battery for slapping a woman on a table while he was injecting her with valium prior to an abortion procedure.
Whitney has testified to the Florida Department of Health and also during a civil lawsuit hearing that babies are sometimes born alive and left to die in James Pendergraft’s abortion clinics where he works. In 2001, a patient of Whitney’s delivered a child who lived with massive birth defects after a botched abortion. As a result, James Pendergraft and Orlando Women’s Center was hit with a $36.7 million judgment. Whitney is also the subject of two malpractice lawsuits that are ongoing. Whitney served another suspension in the 1980s for a malpractice incident. After that time, he began doing abortions more or less full-time.
Abortionist Randall Whitney charges for 2nd trimester abortions based on the BPD (Bi-Parietal Diameter measured by ultrasound). BPD is the diameter of the baby’s skull measured temple to temple. Whitney gives prices for abortion of babies with BPDs up to 54 mm (2 inches).
A Second Clinic in Melbourne – NOT!
By Meredith Raney
In the mid-1990s, Randall Whitney tried to open a second abortion clinic in Melbourne in competition with Aware Woman. When pro-lifers discovered this, they leafleted the 5-story river-front office building where Whitney had signed a lease telling all the tenants that Whitney was an abortionist. Discovering that Whitney had lied about the nature of his business, and being very pro-life themselves, the building owners canceled his lease.
The fact that pro-lifers discovered Whitney’s plans is not surprising. What is unusual is that the news was actually “leaked” to the pro-lifers by Aware Woman’s founder and owner, Patricia Windle. After firing Whitney, Windle made sure Whitney would be met with the opposition of the pro-life community with her carefully timed “leak.”
All of Aware Woman’s volunteer “escorts” quit when they discovered that Patricia Windle’s motivation was to curtail a rival abortion clinic — not to “help women” as she often claims. After all, wouldn’t two abortion clinics “help women” twice as much as one? The volunteer escorts thought so, but Patricia Windle knew it would just hurt her profits. Her actions show her priorities – profits first, “helping women” second.
After 15 years of coming to Melbourne twice a week to kill unborn children, Randall Whitney quit coming to Melbourne. He still kills unborn children in his office in Daytona Beach, 90 miles north of Melbourne.
February 2006 – Prolife activists were alert by email that Whitney claiming that he was violent, disobeying medical laws, and causing young boys to be disfigured after routine circumcisions.
I found your site on this Dr. Randall Whitney. I just thought I would give you some more info on this maniac. I have 2 friends of mine that have worked for him. I know that this man throws 1st trimester babies down the toilet. I know he delivers second term babies and snaps their necks with a tourniquet, or lets them suffocate. He does not flip the baby around. He fully delivers them and then kills them. He skins most of the second term babies while whistling and then puts them in jars and stores them in the secret upstairs that authorities or health departments do not know about or inspect. This man last year in April circumsized a baby about 14 months old and this baby needed to have a blood transfusion to survive. Another little boy was completely disformed from the circumsizion. I am in the process of finding these mothers. He was sedating a woman for an abortion and he did something to her and she went after him with a syringe. Thew cops were called. They said he was a maniac. This was a few months ago. Just some info I thought I would share.Yes I do live in Florida. I have 2 friends that worked for this guy. One of them is in therapy. I think I talked both of them into filing a report. This guy has a file a mile long. It is amazing he still has a license. He must keep getting through some sort of loop hole. I know my friends said he has this great attorney that he pays the big bucks to. This attorney all I know is that he is from Tallahasse. YES THIS IS ALL TRUE! I can get these girls to prove it in time. But, he has a desk girl named Tina. She covers for him quite often so I am told. I promise you what I have said is complete truth. I am trying to get his license removed as we speak. I have been spending hours on the phone everyday for the past few weeks. The Florida department of medical licensing is aware of this. They just need the report from my friends through the police to get in there. These girls have seen this man kill many babies. They have told me things that have made me queezy about this man.
And later…
My friends which are very afraid of this man for some reason are telling the absolute truth. One night about 2 weeks ago, one of the girls called up my house and my husband answered. She said, I can’t sleep anymore because of this, I have to tell someone. She continued to tell this- One night in May 2005 a girl that she had befriended (given drugs to induce labor on her 21wk fetus) went into labor and called my friends cell phone. My friend told her to meet her at the clinic and she would page the doctor. The doctor did not get there in time and my friend ended up delivering the baby. She was going to take it to the hospital. The doctor came in then and took her and the baby into another room, leaving the partly sedated 16 year old mother on the table. He told her to be qquiet and that she wouldn’t be taking the baby anywhere. At that point he put a tourniquet around the babies neck and snapped it. My friend walked out and never went back. This is just one of many stories that I have heard. She said this guy is absolutely insane. He is crazy. She said he is not welcome at the local daytona beach Halifax hospital. She said many other doctors don’t want anything to do with him. She said he seriously has a problem. My friend, I am slowly trying to get her to come forth as well as my other friend. I dont know why they are scared. They are afraid of him. I know these girls are telling the truth. I know I can get them to come out speak. I know that there are others as well. I just have to find them. By law he is supposed to keep all 1st trimester babies for 30 days and dispose of them properly (as sick as it sounds) and he is not doing that, nor has he ever. It may not be illigal to skin fetuses and put them in jars. But, why hide them then? Look, you may or may not believe this, but I m going to get his license taken away. For the two little boys that he butchered. For the lady on September 24 1999 that he tore her cervix, left a sponge in her and the head of a fetus. For the babies that I know he is killing on a daily basis. I will not stop. I am sure there are many others. I am trying to see if I can get one of the desk girls to help with files. There might be a way. I dont know at this point. I KNOW that he is cheating his taxes majorly this year. He was talking openly about while my friend was standing there. He is not legit. I know that there are many like him. This guy has an extra evil to him. This guy does not EVER abort a second term baby by the law. I am sure many do not follow it. I KNOW that abortion will be over turned but, never soon enough.
A former employee of Randall Whitney wrote in 2006 the following:
I’m not scared of him, but as you can imagine, I sincerely don’t feel like reliving the absurdity I encountered while working at Family Planning. However, the immorality he has displayed is unacceptable. I feel as a human being I should say something to someone in a higher position.
I’ll refer to him as RBW, because his entire name literally makes me sick. RBW has sooo many complaints filed against him, I highly doubt he’d assume it was myself, or my friend who was employed there. I’ve never seen a doctor so unbelievably apathetic. As a pre-med student this obviously bothered me; but, I suppose I learned the way not to practice. His bedside manner (or lack there of) was disgusting, the way he spoke to patients when they would cry on the abortion table telling them it “didn’t hurt”, and telling girls they were fat, or “whores”. He’d announce in the ‘operating room’ if someone had an STD, violating HIPPA regulations. I’m not sure if you were aware he used to perform circumcision procedures and he’d mutilate over half of the males’ genitals that were brought in. If we had 6 patients 4 (that we knew of) would go to the hospital.
I must let you know I’m pro-choice, and that’s all I’d like to discuss on that matter. I don’t want to go public by any means, sir. I’d like to bring this to a surface, the investigations on FPC will be enough to shut it down, trust in that. The pro-life activists around here will tear him to shreds I’m sure, I’d rather never see the man again in my life. I have nothing but a strong hatred for him, and I want no contact with him.
He still uses cold soak as a sanitizer, can you believe that? He skins 2nd trimester fetus’ and puts them in formaldehyde until they’re nothing more than bones, and then he puts them into zip lock freezer bags. For what purpose I’m uncertain.
September 2006 – Whitney closes down his own clinic, Family Planning Center, in Daytona Beach, rather than comply with state regulators. Whitney goes back to doing abortions on-the-road.
March 27, 2010 – Whitney arrested for aggravated battery, a 2nd degree felony, against a customer of Orlando Women’s Center.
September 22, 2010 – Abortionist Randall Whitney Arrested … Again!
Randall Whitney – 7/22/2011

PORT ORANGE, FL – In this photo, Randall Whitney’s wife came out to talk to Pastor Mark Holick, one of OSA’s evangelists. Residential pickets are peaceful, missions of mercy to those who are caught in a web of deception and blood-guiltiness.
Later that evening, pro-life evangelist Mark Hall of Messengers of Hope, brought Randall Whitney to one of Operation Save America’s nightly rallies. OSA director Flip Benham says this of Randall Whitney:
I heard abortionist Randall Whitney’s testimony to the jury this past week in Orlando as he made the statement that he saw the babies wiggling around in toilets. It was jaw dropping for me to hear and witness the matter of fact way in which he described it. Chet Gallagher, who attended abortionist Pendergraft’s trial with me, said he saw juror number six in horror and tears as she listened to the testimony.
Note this well. I have been privileged to share the Gospel of Christ with Randall Whitney on more than one occasion. He attended our last rally session on Friday night, though most of you were unaware of his presence. He came as a guest of Mark Hall who has been sharing Christ with Randall for many years. Rusty preached that night and I know that God spoke to Randall’s heart. Please keep Randall Whitney and his wife in your prayers.
Related Articles
Sobieski, Tammy (owner) – Orlando, Daytona
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
WomanCare of Daytona Beach
1360 Mason Avenue
Daytona Beach, FL 32117WomanCare of Orlando
10244 E Colonial Dr. Ste 102
Orlando, FL 32817Tamara Lynne Sobieski is the also the former owner, with husband Everett Sobieski, of the now defunct WomanCare abortion mills in Melbourne, Cocoa and West Palm Beach.
Home:
1113 E University Ave
Deland, FL 32724Related Articles
Residential Pickets – OSA Orlando Recap
By Jay Rogers
DELAND, FL – After a residential picket of the WomanCare abortion chain owner Tammy Sobieski, on July 20th 2011, I was thrown for a loop – actually several loops.
I am familiar with Tammy because she took over the abortion mill in Melbourne, where I lived for seven years, after the Aware Woman abortion mill owners Ted and Pat Windle retired. Tammy relocated that clinic to two places was later forced to close both her Melbourne and Cocoa locations due to a lease non-renewal. Another clinic in Fort Lauderdale closed around that time where she also lost her lease. This abortion chain is now only Orlando and Daytona.
I was searching for Tammy’s information late one night last week and I came across this mug shot of her.

Tammy Sobieski was arrested on July 26th, 2011 — less than a week after the residential picket. I always enjoy it when the abortionists are the ones being arrested and put on trial. That’s a nice switch from Operation Rescue days. The charge was “contempt of court,” which in this case was the failure to show up in court for a deposition at the Orange county court house in Orlando.
I consider Tammy’s arrest one of the “aftershocks” to the spiritual earthquake that was the Operation Save America event here in Orlando.
“Peace Frog” a/k/a “Abortion Stories”
This sticker on abortion mill owner Tammy Sobieski’s car is a “Peace Frog” and was a popular symbol in the 1960s. One thing one of my friends from Melbourne remembered about Tammy over ten years ago is that she always drove a car with a “big green frog sticker.” This new model also has a frog decal – except this one is rainbow colored.

“Peace Frog” is also a song by The Doors in which singer Jim Morrison begins almost every line with the word “blood.” Although the song was written by Doors guitarist Robbie Krieger, who came up with the guitar riff, the lyrics were based on two of Jim Morrison’s poems. One poem, “Abortion Stories,” is where the bloody images come from.
The other poem, is “Ghost Song,” which has the line, “Indians scattered on dawn’s highway/ Bleeding ghosts crowd the young child’s fragile eggshell mind.” This is in a longer form on the album, An American Prayer. The line refers to Morrison’s infamous dead Indian story in which he claims he was possessed by an Indian spirit after witnessing a highway accident as a child. This became the basis for the opening vignette in the Oliver Stone film, The Doors. I relate this here to show what happens when a gifted person, such as the late Jim Morrison, becomes obsessed with death. This obsession can often lead to self-destructive behavior, addictions and even untimely death, as was the case with Morrison.
The song was almost going to be called “Abortion Stories,” but was changed to “Peace Frog” most likely because the controversy. Abortion was illegal in most states when Morrison wrote his “Abortion Stories” poem, so ironically it could be thought of as anti-abortion.
Morrison wrote the song because of all the women claiming to be carrying his children. Patricia Kennely, his Wiccan wife, was carrying his child, but aborted the baby because neither of them wanted children nor thought they could care for a baby at the time despite Morrison’s millions he earned as one of the top rock stars in the world.
The peace frog symbol was originally just supposed to mean “peace.” The title of The Doors’ song is meant to be ironic seeming to refer to the violence of anti-war demonstrations and other examples of police brutality – even though the original imagery was about abortion.
As Proverbs 8:36 says,
“But he who sins against me wrongs his own soul; All those who hate me love death.”
Psalm 106:34-39 contains a list of the charges the Lord had against Israel, for which He was turning them over to death and destruction.
They did not destroy the peoples as the Lord had commanded them, but they mingled with the nations and adopted their customs. They worshiped their idols, which became a snare to them. They sacrificed their sons and their daughters to false gods. They shed innocent blood, the blood of their sons and daughters, whom they sacrificed to the idols of Canaan, and the land was desecrated by their blood. They defiled themselves by what they did; by their deeds they prostituted themselves.
So why is Tammy Sobieski obsessed with keeping these peace frog stickers on her cars?
Throughout the Bible, frogs are associated with unclean spirits and curses:
“But if you refuse to let them go, behold, I will plague all your country with frogs. The Nile shall swarm with frogs that shall come up into your house and into your bedroom and on your bed and into the houses of your servants and your people, and into your ovens and your kneading bowls. The frogs shall come up on you and on your people and on all your servants.” And the Lord said to Moses, “Say to Aaron, ‘Stretch out your hand with your staff over the rivers, over the canals and over the pools, and make frogs come up on the land of Egypt!’” So Aaron stretched out his hand over the waters of Egypt, and the frogs came up and covered the land of Egypt (Exodus 8:2-14).
Their land swarmed with frogs, even in the chambers of their kings (Psalm 105:30).
And I saw, coming out of the mouth of the dragon and out of the mouth of the beast and out of the mouth of the false prophet, three unclean spirits like frogs (Revelation 16:13).
I don’t know if the “Abortion Stories” connection is conscious on her part. I tend to think that it must have crossed her mind at some point in the last 10 years especially being a child of the 1970s when The Doors reached the peak of their popularity.
Is it possible that she has never heard the lyrics to the song? Is it possible she doesn’t know about the abortion connection? Is it possible that there is a deeper spiritual dynamic at work here?
You be the judge.
Here are the complete lyrics and the song.
There’s blood in the streets it’s up to my ankles,
Blood in the streets it’s up to my knee;
Blood in the streets, the town of Chicago.
Blood on the rise, it’s following me.
Just about the break of day.She came, then she drove away,
Sunlight in her hair.Blood on the streets runs a river of sadness.
Blood in the streets, it’s up to my thigh.
The river runs down the legs of the city;
The women are crying red rivers of weeping.She came in town and then she went away,
Sunlight in her hair.Indians scattered on dawn’s highway.
Bleeding ghosts crowd the young childs fragile eggshell mind.Blood in the streets of the town of New Haven;
Blood stains the roofs and the palm trees of Venice.
Blood in my love in the terrible summer;
Bloody red sun of fantastic L.A.
Blood screams her brain as they chop off her fingers.
Blood will be born in the birth of a nation;
Blood is the rose of mysterious union.There’s blood in the streets it’s up to my ankles,
Blood in the streets it’s up to my knee;
Blood in the streets, the town of Chicago.
Blood on the rise, it’s following me.Spagnolo-Hye, Scott Evan (verified, watchlist) – Orlando, Tampa, Ocala
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
Orlando Women’s Center
1103 Lucerne Terrace
Orlando, FL 32806-1016EPOC Clinic
609 Virginia Drive
Orlando, FL 32803Women’s Center of Hyde Park
502 South Magnolia Avenue
Tampa, FL 33606Ocala Women’s Center
108 NW Pine Ave
Ocala, FL 34475-6619Home:
4815 Sawgrass Lake Circle
Leesburg, FL 34748(Lives at this address, which is his parents’ home.)
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapThis practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: New York
(Circuit rider for James Pendergraft.)
Listed as a board member:
New Directions Of Central Florida LLC
Lady Lake, FL 32158
352-347-6272New Directions Of Central Florida LLC is in the following categories: Alcoholism Information and Treatment Centers, Drug Abuse and Addiction Information and Treatment
Minutes from a meeting on Friday, November 14, 2008
(See page 11.)Dr. Spagnolo-Hye was present with Dr. Pomm. Dr. Jaffe was required to appear before the Board to discuss his reasons for leaving training program, participation in an impairment program in New York and medical condition. Action Taken: After interviewing the applicant and Dr. Pomm, Dr. Burns moved to conditionally approve the applicant for licensure with the following conditions: During the remainder of his training, the training program must provide quarterly reports to the Board If the applicant moonlights, he must provide a practice plan to the Board for approval. Dr. Escher seconded the motion, which passed unanimously.
Pro-life picket of abortionist Scott Spagnolo-Hye’s residence on 3/19/2011
LEESBURG, FL – Scott Spagnolo-Hye, a much younger killer, has talked to some of the sidewalk ministry team at Orlando Women’s Center about quitting too. A residential picket’s purpose is to encourage abortionists to repent and receive God’s forgiveness or simply to quit.
See a photo album of the residential picket in front of Scott Hye’s neighborhood.
Scott Spagnolo-Hye – 7/20/2011
LEESBURG, FL – This was a continuation of an awareness campaign for abortionist Scott Hye, one of several residential pickets of an abortionist who performs late-term induced delivery abortions. The awareness campaign is to let his neighbors know that this abortionist kills babies up to 24-weeks of gestation that might survive outside the womb if they were delivered by c-section.
Scott Spagnolo-Hye – 5/8/2012
By John Barros
I have been speaking to Scott Hye for about two years. I have prayed with him shared God’s Word with him. I have even stood in front of his house. I have continued to pray and talk to him. He has said he hated doing abortions, but after so long I wondered. Then today he promised that he is going to quit and said he would meet with me to discuss where he stands with God and repentance. Won’t you pray with me?
Related Articles
Idtensohn, Susan Rodman (Planned Parenthood CEO, retired) – Orlando
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Place:
Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando
726 South Tampa Avenue
Orlando, FL 32805Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando
11500 University Blvd
Orlando, FL 32817Home:
8 South Street
Titusville, FL 32796DOB: 07/23/1943

Orlando Woman Fills Trade Post
Idtensohn Brings International Experience To Job
June 26, 1992 | By Jerry Jackson Of The Sentinel Staff
The state Commerce Department this week hired an Orlando businesswoman to head the Division of International Trade and Development in Tallahassee. Susan R. Idtensohn, 46, replaces veteran director Tom Slattery, who is transferring to the division’s office in Brussels, Belgium. Idtensohn is the former executive director of a management training institute in Singapore, an island nation south of Malaysia.
A legacy of care, controversy
As president of Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando, Sue Idtensohn is a tireless champion for women’s health issues.
July 13, 2005 | By Jean Patteson, Sentinel Staff Writer
Even those who love her the most call Sue Idtensohn blunt, stubborn, relentless. But they mean it in the nicest way. Idtensohn — wife, mother and president/CEO of Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando — is, by all accounts, a determined woman … Idtensohn is a tall woman with a head of close-cropped blond curls, a brisk manner and a hearty laugh.
Planned Personhood
The Orlando Weekly | By Billy Manes
Idtensohn says there’s been a necessary sea change in the way that Planned Parenthood presents itself. After years of trying to distance the organization from the “A” word … it’s now an imperative that the group owns it.“I think we’re at a real watershed here,” she says. “I think that these kinds of issues are going to pop up. The opposition is really good at messaging, just like Republicans. And we react; we are not proactive.” She points sheepishly at a recent rebranding exercise in which the new tagline for Planned Parenthood is “We’re here,” only half-jokingly adding that it should read, “We’re #$%^&.”
Pro-life picket of Planned Parenthood CEO Susan Idtensohn’s residence – 7/18/2011
TITUSVILLE, FL – This was the first residential picket footage of Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando CEO Susan Idtensohn’s neighborhood on Monday, July 18th, 2011. Idtensohn is the outspoken director of an abortion mill in the heart of the African American community near downtown Orlando. She lives in a lovely, spacious house about 45 minutes away on the Indian River Lagoon overlooking the Kennedy Space Center launch pad.
One police officer knocked on Sue’s door and talked to a neighbor. They left almost immediately after that without talking to us. A reporter for Florida Today came by and wrote a fairly balanced piece on the picket.
In the Florida Today report, Pastor Mark Holick said, “We are here to let the neighborhood and the town know” about Idtensohn’s position with Planned Parenthood, Holick said, discussing the Titusville protest. He said he wants people to “pray for her,” in hopes that she repents.
Idtensohn objected to the picketer’s method of free speech calling it, “confrontational and inflammatory…. We believe in people’s ability to make decisions and have choices.”
We pray that Susan one day will understand the irony of her statement. Susan believes in the “choice” to kill a baby through all nine months of pregnancy for any reason, but does not believe in the right to life for unborn children or the right of Christians to proclaim the Gospel peacefully on public property.
Pro-life picket of Planned Parenthood CEO Susan Idtensohn’s residence – 10/29/2011
TITUSVILLE, FL (FR) – This was the second residential picket of Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando CEO Susan Idtensohn’s neighborhood on Saturday, October 29th, 2011. Idtensohn is the outspoken director of an abortion mill in the heart of the black community near downtown Orlando. She lives in a lovely, spacious house about 45 minutes away on the Indian River Lagoon overlooking the Kennedy Space Center launch pad.
The first Awareness Campaign in Idtensohn’s community was on July 19th 2011.
Peaceful pickets of abortionist’s neighborhoods follow the law and provide a good model of concerned citizens using their first amendment rights to speech, press, assembly, religion and petition.
The highlight of this most recent awareness campaign and picket was the dialog and debate between long-time Melbourne-area pro-life evangelist Frank Campana and a neighbor who spouted every pro-abort cliché in the book. While Campana’s response was boisterous, this contender ironically caused the biggest disturbance to the neighborhood in contrast to the peaceful singing, picketing and praying of 33 Christians on this beautiful fall afternoon from 4 to 6 pm.
The effect of an Awareness Campaign is always to divide the community with strong reactions on either side.
We also met a Jewish Rabbi and his wife who stopped his car and thanked us for what we were doing. His wife took pictures of the procession as Lisa Campana spoke with them.
John Barros and Amber Carroll went door to door and talked to Sue’s neighbors. One of her neighbors who lives directly across the street said that they are Christians and had lived there for many years. They had no idea that Sue kill babies for a living. They said that the Idtensohns seemed like such “nice” people. This happens at every neighborhood awareness event. It is always touching to me to see the hurt looks on Christians’ faces when they realize their neighbor is a baby killer. We tell them to pray for their conversion and true repentance. We ask them to share the love of Jesus.
We heard last summer that Idtensohn was selling her home and planned to move out of state. Some might ask: If she is moving in the near future, was it still an effective picket?
Here is a clip from an article in Orlando Weekly from 2006 that answers that question.
PPGO’s capital campaign continues, with the count currently at $1.9 million — and none of that money has come through federal funding. The funds will be used to open a much-needed facility in Brevard County. After that, it’s on to Osceola and Seminole.
Yes, Planned Parenthood of Orlando, even after Idtensohn’s departure, has plans to open up abortion “super centers” on the Space Coast and throughout central Florida. We also know abortionist James Pendergraft would like to open late term killing places in Cocoa, Florida and elsewhere. But dedicated, gentle Christians will be coming to their communities and preaching the Word of God — that child murder is an abomination that brings a curse on our land.
Of course, articles in the pro-abortion media featuring Sue Idtensohn as a “family planning advocate” never mention the word “abortion.” The lasting legacy for Sue Idtensohn will be that people will remember them not as crusaders for women’s rights, but as child murderers.
Every abortionist, clinic owner and worker in central Florida will have a legacy written in the blood of the innocents. Eventually, no one will desire that legacy, either due to the gift of repentance or simply the shame that comes through having their bloody deeds of darkness exposed. This will come as Christians obey the Ephesians 5:11 mandate: “Have nothing to do with the unfruitful deeds of darkness, but rather expose them.”
Gengelbach, James Gordon (verified, watchlist) – Lakeland, Jacksonville, Tampa, Altamonte Springs, Gainesville
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
Lakeland Women’s Health Center
4444 South Florida Avenue
Lakeland, FL 33813-2159All Women’s Health Center-Orlando
431 Maitland Avenue
Altamonte Spgs, FL 32701-5418All Women’s Health Center of North Tampa
14498 University Cove
Tampa, FL 33613All Women’s Health Center of Jacksonville
4331 University Boulevard South
Jacksonville, FL 32216-4909All Women’s Health Center of Gainesville
1135 N.W. 23 Ave, Suite N
Gainesville, FL 32609(Circuit rider abortionist for Gary Dresden.)
Home address:
7016 Cascades Court
Lakeland, FL 33813
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapYOB: c. 1944
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Louisiana, Tennessee, Texas
Florida Limited Liability Company: Gengelbach Interests, LLC
James Gordon Gengelbach – 7/18/2011
LAKELAND, FL – This was the first residential picket footage of abortionist James Gordon Gengelbach’s neighborhood on Monday, July 18th, 2011. Gengelbach is a “circuit rider” abortionist for Gary Dresden, who runs the All Women’s Health Center abortion mills.
James Gengelbach lives in Lakeland in Polk county Florida. Here the police were called, but were professional, smiling and friendly. One even asked us when the picketers were coming back. He said, “Come back every week!” (I won’t say which one he was! You can guess!) There were three cruisers who came and then finally left.
At the end of the video, you can see Gengelbach himself, who drove off and saw the picketers who had blanketed his neighborhood with the truth about abortion and calling him to repentance.
Felski, Emil F. (verified) - Orlando
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando
726 South Tampa Avenue
Orlando, FL 32805Office:
1120 State Road 436 #1000
Casselberry, FL 32707-6183(Felski performs also abortions in his office according to his phone receptionist.)
Home:
812 Brightwater Circle
Maitland, FL 32751
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapEmil Felski left to right: At work in his Casselberry office; in the Planned Parenthood Orlando parking lot; in the 1989 film Parenthood. (Click to enlarge.)
YOB: May 1944
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Florida Hospital, Altamonte Springs
South Seminole Hospital, Longwood
Winter Park Memorial Hospital, Winter ParkThis practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Missouri, Texas
Emil Felski is an Orlando area area abortionist who has worked at EPOC clinic and Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando.
Church: Northland (a notorious seeker-friendly church.)
Sanctuary Ministries Report
By Patte Smith, May 17, 2008
Emil Felski has been a notorious abortionist in Central Florida for many, many years. He was seen attending Northland week after week. When I asked him what he was getting out of the sermons Felski flipped me the finger. Let us pray that pastors begin once again to preach the sinfulness of man and the eternal consequences of their sin. Instead of avoiding the bloody offense of the Cross let us pray that these churchmen would come under the conviction of the Holy Spirit and be faithful to their calling to be clear in the necessity of a genuine repentance so that the way of salvation would not be shrouded in modern therapeutic quackery.
Parenthood
Emil Felski also plays a character in Steve Martin’s 1989 movie, Parenthood, which was directed by Ron Howard and filmed in Orlando.
The plot of the film has a couple, Steve Martin and Mary Steenburgen, first considering having an abortion, but deciding to keep the baby. The doctor who delivers the baby is Emil Felski. Parenthood was filmed in Orlando and Felski played the part of the doctor.
Emil Felski: “That´s great! You´re doin´ great. One more push, and the baby will be here. Bear down. Push. We´re almost there, Mom. Come on. Push. That´s it. Great. You´re doin´ great. You´re doin´ fine. Here we go now. I can see the head. Push. Here comes the baby. Good. Here it is. It´s a girl! Good! Congratulations, Mom.”
Felski Condemns Another Killer
Here is an even more ironic story concerning a woman who worked in Felski’s office who was brutally murdered. The murderer asked for the death penalty and Felski said to WESH-TV news reporters: “He wants to have the death penalty. We agree with his choice.”
http://www.wesh.com/news/15893147/detail.html
Man Asks Judge For Death Penalty
WESH, April 15, 2008
CASSELBERRY, FL – A man has confessed that he hogtied, beat and stabbed a woman to death, and he said it is time he pays for it — possibly with his life.
David Russ is asking the judge to consider the death penalty for him and hold back evidence that might earn him mercy. The victim, Madeleine Leinen, 58, was part of the family at the doctor’s office where she worked.
“The patients love her. Months later they would come in only to find out it was her who had been killed,” Dr. Emil Felski said.
Russ was eventually arrested in Texas. He pleaded guilty instead of going to trial.
“I stood in front of you for these charges and pleaded guilty. I was found competent. I’m here vulnerable as should be the case,” Russ said.Still facing the possibility of death, Russ is asking the judge for no jury and no witnesses to say he shouldn’t be put to death.
“I don’t want my family or the victim’s family to be dragged in here to put on mitigation which actually might succeed. I’ve struggled with drug addiction. I was abused as a child,” Russ said.
“Just seems like a ploy so he won’t have to face Madeleine’s family, his own family,” Felski said. “He didn’t give Madeleine a choice. Madeleine wanted to live. Madeleine enjoyed life. She wasn’t given any choices.”
Felski and Leinen’s family don’t want Russ to be labeled a man so willing to face the music, that he catches a break.
“He wants to have the death penalty. We agree with his choice,” Felski said.
The judge has set another hearing to let the attorneys lay out what they would say in a penalty hearing.
Emil Felski – 7/16/2011
MAITLAND, FL – Emil Felski is an Orlando area area abortionist who has worked for James Pendergraft. He now works for Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando. In the beginning of this video, you can see him walking to work from his maroon SUV. In one of the images, he is holding what appears to be a glock.
A few years ago, pro-life evangelist Patte Smith told us that Felski had been attending Joel Hunter’s Northland Church in nearby Maitland Florida.
Emil Felski has been a notorious abortionist in Central Florida for many, many years. He was seen attending Northland week after week. When I asked him what he was getting out of the sermons Felski flipped me the finger. Let us pray that pastors begin once again to preach the sinfulness of man and the eternal consequences of their sin. Instead of avoiding the bloody offense of the cross let us pray that these churchmen would come under the conviction of the Holy Spirit and be faithful to their calling to be clear in the necessity of a genuine repentance so that the way of salvation would not be shrouded in modern therapeutic quackery.
Local pro-lifers decided a few months back that it was beyond time that Felski’s trade as a baby killer be exposed to all his patients at his Ob-Gyn practice. Since then an awareness campaign at his “legitimate” practice has occurred at least once a month. July 16th, 2011 was the first time a residential picket was held at the gates of Felski’s community. The neighbors here were more contentious than at any other residential picket I’ve witnessed. The reaction was mixed with some very concerned about an abortionist in their neighborhood and some upset we were showing graphic signs of aborted babies in front of their lovely gated community. There were three police cruisers who stayed most of the time but left before the end. I could tell they were concerned about us not stepping over the property line, but they were very reasonable. The Gospel was preached and several of Felski’s neighbors stayed and watched. A few talked to us for a long time.
Pendergraft, James Scott (owner, verified) – Orlando, Ocala, Tampa, Fort Lauderdale
By Editorial Staff
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
Orlando Women’s Center
1103 Lucerne Terrace
Orlando, FL 32806-1016EPOC Clinic
609 Virginia Drive
Orlando, FL 32803Women’s Center of Hyde Park
502 South Magnolia Avenue
Tampa, FL 33606Ocala Women’s Center
108 NW Pine Ave
Ocala, FL 34475-6619Fort Lauderdale Women’s Center
2001 West Oakland Park Boulevard
Oakland Park, FL 33311-1521Home:
77 Interlaken Rd
Orlando, FL 32804(Lives at girlfriend’s home owned by Sangeeta Pati.)
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapHome:
James Pendergraft
Denise Williams President at LateTermAbortion.net LLC
7904 Anne Ct
Clinton, MD 20735
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapThis practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Georgia, North Carolina, Virginia.
James Scott Pendergraft IV

Abortionist Pendergraft worked at Aware Woman abortion clinic in the early 1990s when he lived in the Tampa area.
In 1996, residents of Orlando awoke to the news that a new “doctor” was coming to town. This abortionist proudly proclaimed that he was going to fill a niche left open by other facilities in the area. His specialty would be late-term abortions.
Although a violation of state law, Pendergraft has advertised that he performs abortions up to 28 weeks in five abortion clinics in Florida. In a television interview, Pendergraft openly admitted performing late-term abortions on babies as old as 24 weeks or older if he deems it “necessary.” And the late-term abortion business is lucrative. Pendergraft makes no qualms about bragging that he makes “$2000 an hour.”
His plan is simple. Set up late-term abortion clinics in areas of the state that are easily accessible to women in Georgia and Alabama where late-term abortion is practically illegal.
See: The Tangled Legal History of James Pendergraft: A time-line of the troubled abortionist’s court cases.
After a string of criminal and civil cases, Pendergraft was finally sued for $36.7 million in July 2011. One of the jurors in Pendergraft’s lawsuit trial revealed that Pendergraft’s baby momma, Denise Williams, is hiding 64 percent of the assets generated by his late term abortion empire. The anonymous juror wrote:
Pendergraft in fact has upwards of 8 LLC’s he funnels money thru. The umbrella company for his 5 clinics, Wilson Management, he put 64% controlling interest in his girlfriend’s name and the other 36% is in his. He & his girlfriend refused to divulge the umbrella company’s finances as authorized by discovery rules, chosing to instead be charged with contempt. All of the jurors’ greatest hope is the plaintiff can recover the money awarded. Unfortunately, we all realize it most likely will be a long hard road fraught with appeals. But that is out of our hands. My disgust with the whole scheme got to me emotionally and I was pushing for $50m, $100m whatever I thought could crush him (in my outrage obviously I wanted this guy bankrupt & his clinics closed).
James Scott Pendergraft – 7/17/2011
ORLANDO, FL – This was our first residential picket of abortionist James Scott Pendergraft’s neighborhood on Sunday, July 17th 2011. We found out providentially Sunday night that a lawsuit trial against Pendergraft was commencing the very next morning. Pendergraft was sued for $36.7 million by a woman whose baby was born alive after a botched abortion. The child is now 10-years-old and has massive birth defects.
Scott Pendergraft lives in a beautiful home located on a long, lazy, winding road with a well-shaded park directly across from his driveway. It provided a perfect place for us to live out the Gospel in the streets. As we proclaimed the truth about abortion and about the Gospel, neighbors of Mr. Pendergraft stopped by and spoke with us.
Our intent in visiting Pendergraft’s neighborhood was to bring the gospel of Jesus Christ to his doorstep. Upon knocking at the door, hoping to talk to the abortionist, Dr. Sangeeta Pati answered and claimed that Pendergraft no longer lived at that address. That was news to her neighbors who shared with us that he does indeed live there. Sangeeta Pati and abortionist Pendergraft have had a long time relationship. The neighbors told us that on some days he parks blocks away and rides his motorcycle to the house so people will not know that he is there. One of the families in the neighborhood had been praying for a solid Christian family to move into that house. When they found out who moved in, they were extremely distressed.
Gentle Christians distributed information throughout the area informing the neighbors of Pendergraft’s presence in their community. The intent of the leaflets was to ask the neighbors of Pendergraft to adopt him in prayer. We are very encouraged that abortionist Scott Pendergraft is surrounded by Christians who are praying for him to repent and trust in Christ as Lord.
Related Articles
Bundy, Ralph Lawson (verified) – Daytona, Orlando
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
WomanCare of Daytona Beach
1360 Mason Avenue
Daytona Beach, FL 32117WomanCare of Orlando
10244 E Colonial Dr. Ste 102
Orlando, FL 32817Home:
15 Surfside Drive
Ormond Beach, FL 32176
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapFounder:
Abaco Forum, LLC
15 Surfside Drive
Ormond Beach, FL 32176YOB: 1940 (Source: Volusia County traffic citation website. Entered medical school in 1963).
Related Articles
Ralph Bundy – Being an abortionist and friendship
Abortionist Ralph Bundy, medical director of The Women’s Health Center Inc. in Orlando and Daytona Beach, had his face on the cover of the May 1990, Florida Magazine, labeling him: “The Abortion Doctor.”
In an interview with the Orlando Sentinel 09/17/1991, he said he lost a friend because of the story,
I did lose one really good friend that I’d had for 20 years. She sent me a couple of books, and the message – both from the books and from her was that I was going to burn in hell.… She pretty much blew me off.
He had told reporters that he does not tell many of his friends that he does abortions. He tells them only that he works in a clinic.I don’t hit people over the head with it. I don’t go to a party and say, ‘Boy, I did a tough abortion today.’
Ralph Bundy, The Abortion Clinic Doctor
By Kate Santich of the Sentinel Staff, September 15, 1991
Most doctors who perform abortions don’t say so publicly. Fewer still consent to media interviews. And it is nothing short of extraordinary for one to lend his face to the cover of a magazine labeling him: ‘‘The Abortion Doctor,’‘ as the Florida magazine headline read on May 13, 1990.But Dr. Ralph Bundy says he has no regrets. He is, in fact, as outspoken as ever. ‘‘People think this is just about abortion, but it’s not. It’s the whole morality-control thing: You can’t watch The Last Temptation of Christ, the video-rental store is being told which movies it can stock, and they’re trying to dictate to Wal-Mart the magazines it can sell.
At The Eye Of The Storm: The Abortion Doctor
By Barbara Stewart of The Sentinel Staff, May 13, 1990
Dr. Ralph Bundy does abortions. That is his entire medical practice – 75 abortions a week, 15,000 during his five years as doctor for The Women’s Health Center Inc. in Orlando and Daytona Beach. He has not tired of his work. Each abortion is similar but also different – in the tilt of the uterus, in the tension of the woman’s muscles, in the degree of the woman’s fear or sadness or utter relief. For some women, he says, having an abortion is like getting a haircut. For a few, it creates strong guilt or sadness.
Ralph Bundy fined $5,000
Ralph Bundy was fined $5,000 and told to perform 50 hours of community service for failing to maintain the proper licenses for operating a laboratory at WomenCare of Orlando. One of the facility’s certifications was revoked in January 2005, and its state license expired in October 2006. A state inspector found patient cases as late as December 2006 that included lab tests from the unlicensed facility.
Letter to tenants near abortionist Bundy
December 16, 2009
1360 Mason Ave.
Daytona Beach, FL 32115To Whom it may concern,
We are writing to introduce ourselves to you. We are not only Christian mothers, law abiding citizens and have been residents here for many years, but we are also co-founders of Hope, Help & LIFE, Inc., which is a pro life ministry that offers other options to unexpected pregnancies rather than abortion.
We’ve recently been made aware that your new neighbor in Suite “A”, in the front building, is the abortionist, Dr. Ralph Bundy who moved last month from the “Women’s Health Center” formerly located at 1225 Eighth Street, Daytona Beach.
We know you as established and well respected doctors and medical staff for many years in this community working to improve life. We are not sure if you are aware this type of practice of the taking of life is being done at your doorsteps.
We will continue to hold peaceful prayer vigils in front of this abortion facility just as has been done for many years at the former Eighth Street location. We feel that we must take a stand for life and speak for those who cannot speak for themselves. Even though abortion is legal, it does not change the fact that it is the killing of innocent human babies from the most sacred of places—their mother’s wombs.
We assure you that we mean no harm to anyone. We stand peacefully in prayer for the abortionist and the facility workers as we also diligently pray for the ladies that go into the facility and ultimately, for the unborn to be given a chance to live. We pray always for the end of abortion in our great nation.
We will begin our prayer vigils at your address on the public sidewalk under the nice shade trees there at 1360 Mason Ave. beginning on December 23rd. We will not obstruct traffic or litter in anyway. We hope to draw attention to the truth of what is being done in Suite A and we hope to offer other options to the women going inside. It is a ministry that we are called to do.
Thank you and God bless you and your upstanding practices. If you care to join us, you are most welcomed.
We are enclosing an article on our ministry of Hope, Help & LIFE., Inc. to explain more of our stand to defend life.
Thank you,
Barbara Beute, President of Hope, Help & LIFE, Inc.
Renee Stump, Vice President of Hope, Help & LIFE, Inc.
Below are other members of our community that also stand for life.
Tomoka Christian Church Pastors:
Joe Putting, Senior Pastor
Ed Marshall, Associate PastorTomoka Christian Church Members:
Jessica Gorgas
Forrest Stump
Doug Kennedy
Victoria Kennedy
Cliff Fraine
Barbara Fraine
Amy Anderson
Don Mongeon
Ben Shawiak
Stacy ShawiakHHL Ministry Partners
Dr. Bree Littleton, Hope Help & LIFE, Inc., Treasurer
Charlene Corns, Hope Help & LIFE, Inc., Abortion Recovery LeaderVolusia County Right to Life Members:
Mary Schwarz, Epiphany Right to Life Committee
Carole Rice, Our Lady of Lourdes, Respect Life CoordinatorOthers in the Community
Chrystal Lampe, Bound 4 LIFE Daytona Beach
Diana Toomalatai, Alpha Pregnancy Care Director
Bruce Arthur Lampe
Cheryl Ann LampeRalph Bundy – 7/21/2011

ORMOND BEACH, FL – A central Florida pro-life awareness team traveled almost two hours north to Ormond Beach in support of a prayer group who has for many years stood at Bundy’s abortion mill in Daytona Beach and have prayed for his salvation.
Brown, David Steven (verified) – Hialeah, Miramar
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
A Women’s Choice
6406 NW 186th St
Hialeah, FL 33015A Gyn Diagnostic Ctr
267 E 49th St
Hialeah, FL 33013Hialeah Women’s Center
952 East 25 St
Hialeah, FL 33013Miramar Woman Center
6161 Miramar Pkwy
Miramar, FL 33023Office:
David Brown MD & Associates
2627 NE 203rd Street
Suite #109
Aventura, FL 33180YOB: c. 1961
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Parkway Regional Medical Center, North Miami Beach
This killer is a possible trainer of killers. This practitioner currently holds faculty appointments at the following medical/health related institutions of higher learning:
Associate Clinical Professor, Nova Southeastern, Davie
Associate Clinical Professor, University of Miami School of Medicine, Miami
Active member of 500 Role Models Academy – a high school in Dade County.
Speaks: Spanish, Italian, Hebrew, Creole, French.
Religion: Jewish.
Criminal record
David Steven Brown appears to be that special category of full-time circuit rider abortionist even while attempting to maintain the façade of a respected community member. He advertises for his Miramar Killing Center, “Same Day Abortion Services, Terminations Up to 22 Weeks, All Procedures Provided Sonograms & Anesthesia With Termination.” This killer is a possible trainer of killers as an associate professor at two schools of medicine.
David Steven Brown participated in a crime in which Keiron Nisbet, posing as a medical doctor, worked under the guise of “David Brown.” Two Miami clinics lost their license and its owners were arrested in a second case involving the same unlicensed doctor allegedly performing abortions. Police said that Best Care killing place owners Jose Rodriguez and Magaly Gil brought an unlicensed abortionist Kieron Nisbet to a Hialeah clinic “for the purpose of showing her a licensed doctor by the name of David Brown.” Nisbet was instructed by Rodriguez and Gil to say that Brown performed the abortions at their clinic, police said. Although Nisbet fled the country, Brown was not charged with any crime.
After Abortionist Flees the Country Clinic Owners Arrested
Covenant News, July 20, 2005
A Miami clinic lost its license and its owners were arrested in the second case involving the same unlicensed doctor allegedly performing abortions. Police said that Best Care abortion clinic owners Jose Rodriguez and Magaly Gil brought an unlicensed abortionist, Kieron Nisbet, to a Hialeah clinic “for the purpose of showing her a licensed doctor by the name of “David Brown.” Nisbet was instructed by Rodriguez and Gil to say David Brown performed the abortions at their clinic, police said.
TALLAHASSEE – Police have arrested the owners of a Miami abortion clinic on charges of allowing an unlicensed doctor and unlicensed nurse to perform abortions.
Jose Rodriguez, 52, and Magaly Gil, 56, both of Miami, were arrested and released on $5,000 bond after detectives concluded that they knew Kieron Nisbet was not licensed to practice medicine in Florida. Nisbet is alleged to have performed abortions in November at their clinic, Best Care Women’s Center, 8380 SW Eighth St.
Police said they believe Nisbet also illegally performed abortions at a Hialeah clinic, A Women’s Care II, during the same time and has fled to Trinidad to escape an arrest warrant they obtained for him in April.
State officials are trying to revoke the license of A Women’s Care II, but the clinic is fighting the charges before an administrative judge. Rodriguez and Gil voluntarily relinquished the abortion clinic license on Monday, state officials said, after the joint investigation between the Miami-Dade Police Department and the Florida Department of Health.
A former employee of Best Care Women’s Center told police in a sworn statement that Rodriguez and Gil ordered her to deny Nisbet’s involvement in the clinic if questioned by police, the police report said. The pair went so far as to bring the employee to a Hialeah clinic “for the purpose of showing her a licensed doctor by the name of David Brown,” and she was instructed to say Brown performed the abortions at their clinic, police said.
In March, a Best Care employee was arrested and charged with allowing the unlicensed practice of nursing, after investigators identified two patients who were administered sonograms, received medicine and were sedated by Nisbet and an unlicensed nurse. The Agency for Health Care Administration, which regulates abortion clinics, also lists Gil as the administrator for another clinic, the Millennium Women Center in Miami.
Reached at the Millennium clinic, Gil would not confirm the arrest but she said that the Best Care clinic closed two months ago. Gil also said that she no longer has a business relationship with Rodriguez.
Original source: http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/living/health/12165203.htm
Broadnax, Gary B (retired, watchlist) – Augusta, GA
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
Savannah Medical Clinic
120 E 34th Street
Savannah, GA 31401-8102Planned Parenthood
1289 Broad St
Augusta, GA 30901YOB: c. 1948
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Georgia
Accomplices: Alan M Pollack and Pat Davis
The Florida Department of Health lists Gary Broadnax’s medical license as “retired.” Broadnax is a killer who plied his bloody trade at All Women’s Health Center of Orlando, but is no longer licensed in the state of Florida.
Gary Broadnax is a board member of Hillcrest Medical Associates, Inc. a Raleigh, North Carolina corporation whose corporation status in the state of Florida is inactive.
Hillcrest Board member Alan M Pollack also sits on the board of National Women’s Health Organization of Central Florida, Inc., a Florida corporation that was part of National Women’s Health Organization (NWHO), an abortion clinic chain that, according to their website, suspended operations in seven states by the end of 2010.
National Women’s Health Organization of Central Florida was located at 2208 Hillcrest Drive, Orlando, Florida 32803. Pat Davis served as administrator and Alan M Pollack is best known for serving as part of the legal team on the Supreme Court case National Organization for Women, Inc. v. Scheidler, 510 U.S. 249 (1994)
Read more: http://supreme.vlex.com/vid/national-organization-for-women-scheidler-19963107
Braithwaite, Sylvester Reynold (owner, verified) – North Miami Beach
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011KILLING PLACES:
Women and Teens Healthcare
16876 NE 19th Avenue
North Miami Beach, FL 33162Reach for the Stars Foundation, Inc.
16876 NE 19th Ave
Miami , FL 33162Home:
3101 S Ocean Drive 2201 & 2302
Hollywood, FL 33019
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapYOB: c. 1957
1. CorporationWiki Map
2. CorporationWiki Map
3. CorporationWiki Map
4. CorporationWiki Map
5. CorporationWiki Map
6. CorporationWiki Map
7. CorporationWiki Map
Sylvester Braithwaite offers to kill your child in a “caring and comfortable atmosphere.”Originally from Barbados and trained in Canada, Sylvester Braithwaite sits on the board of The Spiritual Assembly of the Baha’is of Hollywood, Florida.
Brathwaite is a proverbial wolf in sheep’s clothing. His website markets Woman and Teens Healthcare as a compassionate killing center. The death mill’s website is replete with bright faced, smiling teenagers surrounded by a field of flowers.
Braithwaite’s blog offers articles such as, Students need information about ‘Plan B’ and proclaims that their killing center “proudly” offers to murder your child in a “caring and comfortable atmosphere.”

The abortionist’s book, Teen Spirit, has the ad-line: “A Spiritual Approach to Sexuality & Your Teen.”
Teen Spirit: The Ultimate Family Manual
Sylvester Braithwaite’s book, Teen Spirit: The Ultimate Family Manual is listed on Amazon.com under the teenage book subcategory: “Christianity – Christian Life – Family Relationships.”
The book’s ad-line is “A Spiritual Approach to Sexuality & Your Teen.” Braithwaite goes to great lengths to portray his child killing business as happy, family-oriented, spiritual and even “Christian.”
Reach for the Stars Foundation
Braithwaite is a modern day false prophet of Baal. He is the founder of the Reach for the Stars Foundation, a tax-exempt charitable foundation with the stated purpose to provide abstinence based sex education.
The Reach for the Stars website again features smiling teens and purports to be a compassionate, caring organization focused on “helping young people to reduce their sexual risk taking, but also create opportunities for youth and their families to learn about normal sexual development, explore values and sexual decision making and promote healthy, positive attitudes about sexuality.” These are admirable goals. However, the reality is that Braithwaite’s end solution where his non-profit abstinence and contraception outreach fails, is child killing for profit.
The income of the tax-exempt organization, which was founded by three Braithwaite family officers – Sylvester, Carla and Justin – is customarily under $25,000 a year. Despite this, Reach for the Stars files the long 1090 form. Sylvester Braithwaite also disclosed that he received $6,705 in 2006 for “program services” from the organization. The donor list was not itemized.
Welcome to Our Center
Women & Teens Healthcare provides exceptional reproductive health care in a caring and comfortable atmosphere. Our gynecologist proudly offers diverse medical services that includes surgical abortions, medical or pill abortion, IUDs, pap smears, rapid testing & treating of all STDs, pre-natal or antenatal care and free pregnancy tests.
About Our Center
We invite you to visit our gynecology office where Dr. Sylvester Braithwaite, an OBGYN and sexual health educator, has been serving men and women for over 30 years. We will take exceptional care of you in a relaxed and loving atmosphere with the highest standards and confidentiality. We speak English, Spanish, French and Creole and offer a comprehensive array of gynecology services.
About Sylvester Braithwaite
Dr. Sylvester Braithwaite is a Board Certified, Canadian trained Obstetrician Gynecologist with over 25 years experience in adolescent health care in Canada, West Indies, Europe and the US. He is also a professional speaker and author of the book Teen Spirit, which includes 55 strategies to help parents talk to their teens about sexuality.
He is on the Miami Dade School Board’s Speakers Bureau where he is involved in HIV/AIDS presentations and has served on the board of several community organization including, Miami Dade Alliance for Career Education, Alert Health formerly called Hep-C Alert, Adolescent Pregnancy Prevention and Parenting Council, the Women Emergency Network and the National Heritage Foundation.
Dr. Braithwaite’s mission is to provide accessible, available, and affordable medical care and to disseminate accurate research based information about both abstinence and contraception. His major objective is to prevent unintended pregnancies and sexually transmitted diseases especially HIV/AIDS. Dr. Braithwaite’s basic message is “education now, babies later, STD’s HIV/AIDS never.”
For more information on Dr. Sylvester Braithwaite can be found on LinkedIn & Reach for the STARS Foundation.org.
Bodman, Uzy (verified) Hialeah, Miramar, Plantation
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places
Aastra Women’s Center
10 Southwest 44th Avenue
Plantation, FL 33317-3758A Gyn Diagnostic Center
267 East 49th Street
Hialeah, FL 33013-1854Miramar Women’s Center
6161 Miramar Parkway
Miramar, FL 33023-3939Home:
3305 NE 40th St
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308YOB: May 1941
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions: Broward General Medical Center, Fort Lauderdale; Plantation General Hospital, Plantation.
Nationality: Israeli
Languages: Hebrew, Italian, Spanish
Betancourt, Fernando Ricardo (verified) – Ft. Myers, Sarasota, Tampa
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
All Women’s Health Center of Orlando
431 Maitland Avenue
Altamonte Springs, FL 32701All Women’s Health Center of North Tampa
14498 University Cove
Tampa, FL 33613Countryside Women’s ObGyn Center
28960 US Highway 19 N #110
Clearwater, FL 33761All Women’s Health Center
4131 Central Avenue
Saint Petersburg, FL 33713All Women’s Health Center of Sarasota
2700 South Tamiami Trail, Suite 5
Sarasota, FL 34239Women’s Health Center of Ft. Myers
3900 Broadway
Fort Myers, FL 33901Office:
Southwest Florida Regional Medical Center
13681 Doctors Way
Fort Myers, FLHome:
YOB: April 1954
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Lee Memorial Hospital & Lee Memorial Hospital Health Park, Ft Myers
Circuit rider for Gary Dresden, owner of All Women’s Health Centers
Patients rate Abortionist Betancourt
VITALS Comments
Sep 8, 2011 – DOCTOR SIN MODALES NI EDUCACIN
Hace unos das tuve la terrible decisin de un aborto, y acud a esta clnica, la enfermera q me atendi por telfono al hacer mi appoinment fue muy amable y me sent confiada al elegir este lugar. Cuando llegue me atendi otra nurse, pero esta fue rude y poco amable, pens que tal vez tena un da malo, espere me turno, y al entrar a hacerme el ultrasonido, el doctor Betancourt entro sin presentarse, muy fro, muy grosero, sin decir una sola palabra, creo uno como persona tiene derecho a ser tratado como tal, y a veces uno tiene que tomar decisiones muy fuertes, pero no quiere decir que seamos malas personas, esto ha sido muy duro para mi, y con ese trato me hicieron sentir peor que un asesino, en todo momento el doctor no tuvo un gesto de amabilidad y creo que uno como paciente y el con la profesin que tiene, no es para que trate a la gente as. Ojal y haya alguien que regularice el trato doctor-paciente en clnicas y se mejore este sistema, yo no quiero ni volver al follow up, para chequearme…mujeres no acudas a esta clnica.
Jul 23, 2011 – THIS “DOCTOR” IS A JOKE.
I feel extreme pity for anyone who happens to have Dr Betancourt as their MD. I wish I would have read these accurate reviews before going through with this procedure. I just had to google his name after my appointment to make sure he is even a legit doctor. Extremely rude. Extremely ignorant. Callous. Arrogant. He came into the room, didn’t introduce himself, & had an expression of pure disgust on his face. I don’t even think he looked at my face one time while speaking. I was obviously very nervous & my only question before the abortion was “is it common for patients to leave here still pregnant?” and his response was “Yep. If you move at all. And since you chose the IV sedation you’ll probably move without knowing it, so if you hear me yelling at you, then you better stop moving”. Luckily the nurse was in the room for the procedure, and she was very kind. I have no idea how any of the clinic staff can stand to be around that man. I seriously hope he reads these reviews on him and realizes what an awful “doctor” he is. If I had to guess, I’d say he is anti-abortion & chose this practice to torture any woman who defends her right of choice. Utterly shocked and disgusted that this man has a license to practice.
Jul 19, 2011 – COLD
I went to the clinic for an abortion. Yes the procedure is frowned upon and an extremely hard decision but I had no other choice. Dr. Betancourt was very quiet, not friendly in the least bit, wasn’t very informing, tried to “scare” me with the things he told me, and very cold. The best word I can think of to describe Betancourt is cruel. He asked for any questions and my main question was the risks, “I’ll get to that,” was his response, “don’t move, otherwise I’ll cut through your uterus.” I asked if that was common, “it is if you move, it will happen,” was his response. As nervous as I already was this had made it twenty times worse. Throughout the procedure he did not say one word, the nurse was more sympathetic to me, held my hand. After it was done he ripped untensil out of me and as he was walking out “I hope i didn’t hurt you too much,” with a smirk on his face. I wish I would have done research on this doctor before I saw him. I would never wish this kind of treatment on anyone, espcially under the circumstances.
Mar 2, 2011 – DR. BETANCOURT = COLD, HEARTLESS, MEAN
Never in all my life have a met someone (especially a doctor) who was this mean. He refused to look at me or even talk to me. When he did speak to me, it was because he was yelling at me to relax. He has ZERO bedside manners. I just don’t understand how a doctor can be so mean to a patient, and a PAYING customer. During the procedure, he and the nurse carried on their own conversation as if I wasn’t even in the room. He should not be practicing. He is so cold and hateful and being in an exam room with him is horrible. Something I will never forget. I hope many people see the reviews on this man and go to another doctor. Please stay as far away from him as you can.
Oct 9, 2010 – SHOULD NOT BR PRACTICING
I was referred for an abortion to Betancourt’s Sarasota location. His staff was moderately concerned and sympathetic considering the nature of the clinic. I understand it is easy to become desensitized after working in this field for many years. However, Betancourt has NO bedside manner. He never introduced himself, did not make eye contact and barked commands, “Untie this…untie this!”(refering to the strings on my pants. “Move down, move down” He was harsh, disconnected, and if one believe’s in a soul, soul-less. I began sobbing on the table during the procedure only to hear, “TILT your butt down, keep it down!” “Move down!”. I wasn’t expecting a parade for the event, but a subtle touch of humanity goes a long way. I’m not livestock, I’m a person.
Mar 21, 2008 – DR. BETANCOURT IS A COLD HEARTED PERSON AND SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED TO PRACTICE
I had a procedure done by fernando betancourt, he did not speak 1word to me, one of his nurses checked my blood to see if I was rh-to determine whether I needed an extra shot before having an abortion, they told me it was negative, I literally had to argue with the staff b/c I knew I was rh-, after re-checking my blood (she had my blood all over her fingers and no gloves) they said “oh your right, its going to be another $50) having an abortion is a horrible decision to make, he doesn’t even speak to the patients, at my checkup he said “your bladder isn’t full like they said it should be” he was obviously very anger and walked out of the room. I’m young i was scared and actually had some complications but wasn’t given the opportunity to talk about them. He is a very angry and cold person and obviously has done this procudure one too many times and by looking at him you just can tell that he’s not a good person. Most of his staff is the same way. They first want you to pay, then in and out. Before you have it done, they say there is a recovery room that you are welcome to stay in as long as you need. As soon as I had it done, I was still very out of it and I asked for the recovery room b/c i wanted to make sure everything was okay, instead they pretty much pushed me back to the exit and grabbed my husband. I am sure that if you did the research on this dr. you will find tons of things wrong so if your trying to make a decision i would first say don’t have an abortion but if your goign to see someone who actually gives and ounce of care to you
Read more: http://www.vitals.com/doctor/profile/1649476300/reviews/1649476300#ixzz2Be5xkVkn
Benjamin, Michael J. (owner, verified) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011KILLING PLACE:
Michael Benjamin, MD
7777 N. University Drive
Suite 102
Miami, FL 33321Home:
15713 SW 80th Lane
Miami, FL 33193
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapYOB: c.1941 (Source: FL DOH – est. entered medical school in 1963)
Benjamin holds staff privileges at the following hospitals:
Northwest Medical Center, Margate; Coral Springs Medical Center, Coral Springs
Benjamin is one of two abortionists in Florida, along with Robert Livingston, who has named his killing center after himself. He advertizes that he murders children in a private gynecological setting.
Dr. Michael Benjamin Suspended: Failed to report the pregnancy of a 12 year old
Florida health regulators voted on Saturday to indefinitely suspend the medical license of a Tamarac obstetrician who did not report as possible child abuse a 12-year-old girl who was six months pregnant. But he will challenge the ruling.
The Florida Department of Health filed a professional disciplinary case against Benjamin, saying the law requires doctors to automatically report suspicious cases of sex involving children under 16. No criminal charges were filed against him.
Dr. Michael Benjamin told state officials he believed the girl’s story that she got pregnant from consensual sex with a classmate who lived nearby. He said he didn’t think he needed to report it.
The unidentified girl came to Benjamin for an abortion in November 2009 with her mother and the adult boyfriend, according to the state complaint against him. They lived in the Gainesville area and found Benjamin’s name through an abortion hotline.
The girl’s mother insisted she did not know of her daughter’s condition until the girl was 24 weeks pregnant and had not taken her for prenatal care, state records show.
Benjamin told state investigators he was satisfied that there was no child abuse after talking to the girl and her mother for 30 minutes. But the state complaint notes that Benjamin’s notes in the case state he only talked to the girl and her mother for six to eight minutes before the abortion.
The girl’s pregnancy was not reported until months later by her pediatrician. Gainesville area detectives later linked the pregnancy to the mother’s boyfriend. Authorities later convicted the boyfriend of the girl’s mother in the pre-teen’s pregnancy and he is now servicing a 15-year sentence for sexual battery.
Statutory rape is the crime of having sexual relations with a person younger than the age of consent specified by statue, or who is mentally incapable of consent as defined by law. Often, the offender must be several years older than the victim, rather than the same age or younger. The perpetrator’s claim of ignorance of the victim’s age is generally not regarded as sufficient reason to spare him from prosecution. Laws vary by state. In Florida, the age of consent is usually 18, but can be one or two years younger if the partners are close to each other in age.
Benjamin and state officials had proposed that the case could be settled if he paid an $8,000 fine, accepted a reprimand and take remedial courses, according to the docket in his case. However, the Florida Board of Medicine, which oversees doctors, rejected the deal. The Board voted to suspend Benjamin’s license until he undergoes an assessment and come back before the board for another review.
Benjamin will also be fined $10,000 and will have to perform community service as well as take courses.
Michael Spicer, attorney for Benjamin said the doctor will contest the ruling by taking the case to a state administrative judge, allowing him to keep practicing while the case is pending.
Florida Abortion Ban to be Reviewed by Federal Judge
In 2000, Michael Benjamin was named as a plaintiff along with A Choice for Women, Edward R. Watson, M.D., and Presidential Women’s Center, supporting a legal challenge to the state of Florida’s law banning partial birth abortion– a procedure in which a viable baby is killed by delivering the body feet first and puncturing the skull while the head of the child is still in the birth canal. The lawsuit is a good case example of the hysterical screeds offered by abortionists who claim that any limit on abortion, including even what most would agree are clear cases of infanticide late in pregnancy, would somehow put women’s lives in danger in the so-called “hard cases.”
CRLP Press, May 30, 2000
The Center for Reproductive Law and Policy (CRLP), which represents abortion providers in Florida, will present arguments before U.S. District Judge Joan A. Lenard on why Florida’s “partial-birth abortion” ban, signed into law last Thursday by Governor Bush, is detrimental to women’s health and should therefore be blocked from enforcement. CRLP filed for an emergency order to block the ban from taking effect on Friday. It was denied by sitting federal judge Ursula Ungaro-Benages, who ordered both parties-CRLP and the state-to attend the Wednesday hearing to determine whether the ban would continue to be enforced.
CRLP asserts that the language in the law is so broad that it would prohibit abortion early in pregnancy – beginning as early as 11 weeks of pregnancy — and subject doctors to criminal prosecution for providing the safest medical care. Additionally, the ban fails to contain adequate exceptions to protect women’s life and health. U.S. District Judge Donald L. Graham struck down a similar Florida law in 1998, criticizing its inadequate protection for the health and life of the woman. The penalties against physicians are harsher in the current law in comparison to the 1998 version, having been increased from third to second degree felony charges, subject to $10,000 fines and up to fifteen years in prison.
Currently the U.S. Supreme Court is considering the constitutionality of Nebraska’s “partial-birth abortion” ban. CRLP represents Dr. Carhart, the physician who challenged the Nebraska law. At stake is the ability of states to restrict abortion before fetal viability without regard for women’s health and safety. The Supreme Court decision, which is expected by early July, will determine whether Florida’s ban is constitutional.
Testimony of Michael J. Benjamin
Benjamin touts his professionalism in profiting from child killing while at the same time revealing his low opinion of the clientele. In a testimony from 1989, he claims that women who kill their children are “out of control.”
House Health care Committee, Full Committee Meeting September 14 and 15, 1989, Florida House of Representatives.
I think it is basically a personality type who generally has her life out of control and unfortunately nowadays there are no shortage of people in general whose lives are out of control. They drift, they tend to live for the moment in terms not only of their sexual practices but in terms of their economic lives and they are people in general who don’t think beyond the moment, who don’t plan for tomorrow, and who really will take life as it comes and deal with the rest later. It is a personality type is what I am saying rather than any race or socioeconomic group or things of that sort…. There is certainly a very high incidence amongst teenagers and I believe the reason for that is that teenagers generally don’t think of consequences of their actions or ignorant as to contraceptive practices or deny the possibility of pregnancy…
Bazile, Frantz (owner, verified) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011KILLING PLACE:
Advanced GYN Clinic
6464 N Miami Ave
Miami, FL 33150-4520Home:
19100 SW 24th St
Miramar, FL 33029
View Florida Abortionists in a larger mapYOB: c. 1952 (Born in Brussels and began undergraduate school at age 17 in 1969)
Miami: The legalized back-alley abortion capital
By Jill Stanek, World Net Daily, August 09, 2006
Readers may have read news stories two weeks ago [July 2006] of workers at a Hialeah, Fla., abortion mill allegedly killing a newborn baby. Hialeah is next to Miami. That was merely the tip of the slice-and-dice-berg.
Frantz Bazile was the responsible abortionist (two words that harmonize only when denoting culpability). Bazile’s rap sheet actually goes back to 1991, when he was found guilty of gross negligence in Illinois and placed on professional probation. While aborting a 17-year-old, Bazile had accidentally removed part of her placenta first, causing the girl to hemorrhage. He made matters worse by lacerating her vagina and cervix when trying to stop the bleeding.
Bazile finally called an ambulance. At the hospital the girl received emergency blood transfusions and underwent an emergency cesarean section, delivering a live baby who died. Not only did Bazile muck up the abortion, he failed to assess the baby’s age, which was determined to be “late second trimester.”
After being put on probation, Bazile flew the coop and landed on the beach, finding employment at A Gyn Diagnostic Center, the aforementioned Hialeah abortion mill. Abortion mills do not require references….
Bazile never reported to Florida authorities he had been placed on professional probation in Illinois. In 2005, a pro-lifer caught this and reported Bazile to the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration. AHCA responded that the statute of limitations had expired. Oh, well.
An abortion gone bad opens up an unseemly world of low-end medicine
http://www.miaminewtimes.com/2006-10-26/news/in-the-bag/
Miami New Times, Joanne Green, Thursday, Oct 26 2006Barquet, Luis (deceased) - Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Here’s an abortionist who long ago retired and if he has since expired, he is now a believer in Jesus Christ according to Philippians 2:10-12. Luis Barquet provides us with a powerful piece of history of how Floridians reacted to a hack abortionist shortly after Roe v. Wade was imposed on us by five executioners in black robes. Compare their admirable and zealous militancy to the apathy of the postmodernist church of the 21st century. Sadly, it is apparent that a malaise has overtaken us.
Another Back Alley Butcher Gone LegitLuis Barquet was an abortionist in Cuba before fleeing to Miami in the late 1950s or early 1960s. He was arrested for illegal abortion in Miami in 1961. In 1962 a study by the International Association of Chiefs of Police called him “a butcher” and noted that he “made a fortune” performing illegal abortions “in back rooms and motels.” Barquet was ordered to leave the U.S. in 1963 ,but returned days later. He was indicted for bribery in New York in 1965, but remained a fugitive until his 1966 arrest in Florida.
Barquet successfully challenged Florida’s abortion laws in 1972 and set up a legal abortion clinic. He was arrested in 1976 on grounds that his abortion facility constituted a public nuisance. Barquet’s son reopened the facility, retaining Dr. Eduardo F. Elias, while Barquet was in jail.
Marina DeChapellLearn about the woman who later died at Barquet’s “safe and legal” killing center.
Marina DeChapell died following pulmonary arrest during an abortion by Elias at Barquet’s clinic. The facility allegedly lacked emergency equipment. Barquet was serving a one-year sentence for an unspecified crime at the time of the death.
Source: Miami Herald, 8-18-78Baill, I' Cori (verified, promoter) – Orlando, Lakeland
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Office:
The Menopause Center
2702 North Orange Ave
Suite # A
Orlando, FL 32804Planned Parenthood of Southwest and Central Florida
(Does abortion referrals only.)
2250 East Edgewood Drive
Lakeland, FL, 33803Secondary locations:
(The following Planned Parenthood locations do abortion referrals only.)
Planned Parenthood
2121 W. Pensacola Street
Tallahassee, FL 32304Planned Parenthood
914 NW 13th Street
Gainesville, FL 32601Planned Parenthood
2370-1 South 3rd Street
Jacksonville Beach, FL 32250Planned Parenthood
3850 Beach Blvd.
Jacksonville, FL 32207YOB: c. 1960
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Massachusetts, Missouri, Maryland
I’ Cori Baill is president and founder of The Menopause Center in Orlando and Medical Director of Planned Parenthood Southwest and Central Florida.
She is an outspoken child-killing advocate. She writes numerous editorials in support of child murder. The Planned Parenthood center in Lakeland where she is listed as “medical director” refers to four other locations. She apparently deals mainly with menopausal women and needs to have her pro-abortion activism exposed to her pro-life patients.
She is a signer of the Abortion Providers Declaration of Rights.
Her pro-murder rhetoric is a good case example of the political craftiness common among the prophets of Baal who still hold sway over our modern King Ahabs and Queen Jezebels. A short quote from the following article reveals a common rhetorical tactic.
A Woman’s Age A Factor In Her Abortion Decision
By Cori Baill, Special to the Sentinel, July 19, 1998No one thinks abortion is a good thing. Far better would be that every child is a wanted child and unintended pregnancy did not occur. Study after study has shown that broad sex education, including abstinence and alternatives to sexual intercourse, as well as access to effective contraception, are the most effective ways to reduce the number of abortions.
Society should not risk the lives of nearly half the population, especially those children under 15 years of age and the women, mostly mothers already over 40, who utilize abortion services for unintended pregnancies at the highest rate. I envy no one this difficult decision. I am glad I can teach many to avoid it, but biology is not easily or neatly constrained.
On the contrary, “study after study” in fact shows the opposite of what Baill (Baal?) says is true. This is a common deceptive argument. If we simply increase the money for sex education and make chemical abortifacients available to all, there will be fewer unwanted pregnancies and therefore fewer surgical abortions. It seems to make perfect, logical sense, doesn’t it?
What the prophets of Baal do not explain is how Planned Parenthood has built a multi-billion dollar empire by selling these lies. The goal of “Murder Incorporated,” which is increasingly funded by your tax dollars, is to increase promiscuity among teenage girls at a lower and lower age. With available birth control or not, many of these girls will become pregnant and will seek the services of Planned Parenthood in order to murder their child.
In fact, since the widespread availability of chemical birth control in the 1960s, teenage promiscuity and pregnancy has skyrockted. While Planned Parenthood claims to want to reduce the number of abortion, in reality they want to corner the murder-for-profit market.
Baill wrote the following article in support of George Tiller’s late term abortion practice. George Tiller was a late-term abortionist in Wichita, Kansas, who by almost anyone’s estimation was one of the greatest mass murderers in American history. Like most of Tiller’s defenders, Baill erroneously claims that the majority of Tiller’s victims were the “hard cases” stemming from “horrendous circumstances.” On the contrary, it has been documented that many if not most of these children would have survived if they had simply been delivered by c-section.
Murdered Kansas doctor inspired patients, colleagues
By I’ Cori Baill, Special to the Sentinel, Opinion, June 07, 2009Dr. George Tiller’s murder a week ago while serving as an usher in his hometown church in Wichita, Kan., left many, myself included, shocked and bereaved. A few days later, a comforting e-mail reached my desk. A Florida woman shared with me her grateful recollections of Dr. Tiller, who had cared for her in his clinic. The e-mail relayed a moving story attesting to the care the woman had received at a most difficult time.
But Dr. Tiller’s legacy extends beyond patient care. I doubt there is an obstetrician/gynecologist practicing in the U.S. who is not familiar with Dr. Tiller’s clinic, and many of us have referred to him over the years. I was a third-year resident in Baltimore in 1988. A poor, frightened, pregnant girl came to the resident clinic. Because her exam did not match her calculated due date, she was sent for an ultrasound, and like the patient who e-mailed me, she received the terrible news that a lethal anomaly was present. Her infant developed a normal body but no brain. I reviewed with my young patient her treatment options, including late-term abortion. She was early into her last trimester of pregnancy and wanted termination as soon as possible. Third-trimester abortion was not available at our hospital.
I called Dr. Tiller in Wichita and explained the situation, adding that our patient was unlikely to be able to pay for his services upfront, having only Maryland Medicaid. He said, “If you can get her here, I’ll take care of her.” We passed the hat, our attending physician supplemented the somewhat meager resident contribution, and we put her on a plane with a copy of her ultrasound report.
Shortly after my graduation, Dr. Tiller was shot by protesters. He was injured in both arms, but fortunately had on a bullet-proof vest. I wrote to him to wish him a speedy recovery and thanked him again for the care he had extended to my resident clinic patient. I expressed my admiration and appreciation of the work he did. I didn’t expect it, but he wrote me back. He said that he didn’t deserve admiration. What kept him going, he explained, was the bravery, relief and appreciation of the women he had the privilege to care for.
“They deserve your admiration,” he wrote, “not me.” He deeply respected his patients and extended compassion for the often horrendous circumstances and complications surrounding their pregnancies. That was why, despite having been shot and continually threatened and harassed, he continued to practice as soon as he recovered.
Azima, Ali Asghar (owner, verified) – North Fort Myers
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011KILLING PLACE:
Southwest Florida Women’s Clinic
710 Pondella Rd Ste 12
North Fort Myers, FL 33903
Phone: 239-995-1111Other address:
Venice Women’s Health Ctr Inc
21178 Olean Blvd Ste C
Port Charlotte, FL 33952YOB: December 1933 (Entered six year program at Teheran University in 1955.)
Dr. Ali Azima in his office at the Southwest Florida Women's Clinic in North Fort Myers. Azima, who is a Muslim, says protesters are trying impose their religious beliefs on him and as such are violating his constitutional rights
Sheriff Aids Anti-Abortion Protesters, Condemns Doctor
Feminist Wire | Daily Newsbriefs, January 20, 1998
Lee County Sheriff John McDougall of Florida denied assistance to an abortion doctor whose clinics were being ambushed by protesters, stating instead that he would “assist the protesters.” Dr. Ali Azima had sent a letter to McDougall concerning a prayer vigil and other incidents that were being held outside his clinics. McDougall responded that he would uphold his duty to protect all citizens, “even a baby killer like yourself,” and went on to add that his office would “do everything within our power to assist the protesters who wish to protect the misguided mothers who come to your clinic of death.”
Abortion doctor and protesters stand their ground at Fort Myers clinic
Naples Daily News – Monday, June 14, 1999
Azima’s clinic serves as the site of a local battleground on which the war on abortion is fought almost daily, a war marked not by big battles but with small skirmishes. For the better part of two decades, a small brigade of protesters has stood guard outside the clinic on days abortions are performed. But in recent weeks, this quiet war has made itself heard – one protester and Azima have filed battery charges against each other, and a Fort Myers man was arrested for allegedly attempting to run over protesters with his car two weeks ago.
The battles show no signs of ceasing – both sides say they don’t plan to quit their respective practices.Related Articles
Arcelin, Gostal (watch list) – Boca Raton
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Killing Places:
Central East – Melbourne – Aware Woman Center for Choice (closed!)*
Current office:
Women’s Health Partners, LLC,
6853 SW 18TH St., #301
Boca Raton, FL 33433-7056
Phone: (561) 368-3775
Fax: (561) 368-1143Other address:
5000 West Boynton Beach Boulevard, # 200
Boynton Beach, FL, 33436
Phone: (561) 734-5710
Fax:(561) 734-9118DOB: 2/12/1967 (Entered Georgetown University in 1989.)
Hospital Privileges: West Boca Medical Center; Boca Raton Community Hospital; Boca Raton Outpatient Surgery & Laser Center, A Healths, Boca Raton.
Has several malpractice lawsuits filed against him.
Has several traffic tickets in Palm Beach County. (Need volunteer who will pull the lawsuit files and tickets. Email me.)
http://www.facebook.com/gostal
Dr. Gostal Arcelin resigned in a letter to Christians For Life, a pro-life group in Melbourne, Florida, that organized a peaceful, one-day, 12-person picketing excursion.
Abortionist Gostal Arcelin quits
Gostal Arcelin, a resident at the University of Florida Health Science Center in Jacksonville and abortionist at Aware Woman Center for Choice in Melbourne, FL, announced that he will stop performing abortions at Melbourne’s only abortion clinic as of April 1, 1996.
The announcement was made in a March 15, 1996 letter to Christians For Life, a Melbourne pro-life group that held an informational picket on March 14, 1996, at the University Medical Center in Jacksonville where Dr. Arcelin works and in his neighborhood in Neptune Beach, FL, a suburb of Jacksonville.
“We pray that Dr. Arcelin will now commit to using his God-given talents only for healing and never for killing for the rest of his young career,” said Meredith Raney, a spokesman for Christians For Life.
The entire text of the letter follows:
Raymond Unterburger
Christians For Life
P.O. Box 2022
Melbourne, FL 32902Dear Mr. Unterburger,
I will no longer provide medical services at the Aware Woman Center for Choice as of April 1, 1996. Please inform your associates. Understand that I am proud of being able to provide reproductive services for women of all ages, and that my activities were known amongst my colleagues, friends, and neighbors.
Please be aware that Aware Woman Center for Choice clinic and other physicians may elect to pursue anonymity for security purposes. Again, I must emphasize that as of April 1, 1996, I will stop coming to Melbourne for reproductive health services.
Sincerely,
(signature)
Gostal Arcelin, M. D.
cc: Robert J. Thompson, MD, Prof. And Associate Chairman, OB/GYN Dept
Linda M. Robertson, MD, Associate Professor, Chief of Staff, UMC
Aware Woman Center for Choice
Meredith Raney, Women’s Legal Action Coalition
Affidavit of Defendant Patricia Baird-WindleAbortion clinic owner claims that Dr. Gostal Arcelin resigned due to “harassment.”
Florida abortionist calls it quits
Jacksonville FL – AP, March 17, 1996He’s only 28 years old and wants to live a long life. Abortionist (Ret.) Gostal Arcelin was disturbed by citizens picketing outside his Neptune Beach home and decided to cease from his practice of driving to Melbourne to commit abortions. The Ob-Gyn resident at University Medical Center faxed a one-page letter to Christians for Life in Melbourne with the good news. A University spokeswoman “said he told her he was quitting the Melbourne work because he was concerned for his safety.”
Aware Woman can’t find another doctor to replace Dr. Gostal Arcelin and three other residents from the University of Florida Hospital in Jacksonville who had been coming on Saturday. Dr. Arcelin resigned in a letter to Christians For Life effective April 1, 1996 after only one day of picketing at his hospital and neighborhood. Christians For Life, a pro-life group in Melbourne, Florida organized a peaceful, one-day, 12-person picketing excursion that triggered all of this.
Applegate, Gerald Brian (verified) – Doral
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011KILLING PLACE:
A Eve’s Clinic and Referral Service
3900 Northwest 79th Avenue #575
Miami, FL 33166Home:
2101 Brickell Ave, Apt 2806
Miami, FL 33129
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: June 1956
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Pan American Hospital, Miami
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Pennsylvania, Ohio, New York
Young mother’s death brings lawsuit
Tuesday, December 18, 2001
By Torsten Ove, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Staff WriterAbortionist committed 10 incidents of malpractice
The family of a Cranberry woman who died after surgery at UPMC Passavant Hospital following a miscarriage has filed a wrongful death suit against the doctor who performed the procedure, saying he improperly started the operation in his North Hills office and was unprepared for the emergency that resulted.
The suit also charges that the doctor, Gerald Applegate, has a history of hospital suspensions and malpractice lawsuits and was under suspension by Magee-Womens Hospital at the time of the operation. In addition, it says Applegate lied about his previous lawsuits when he applied for staff privileges at Passavant, and that Passavant knew about Applegate’s problems and allowed him to stay on the staff.
The suit was filed yesterday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court by David K. Speicher, whose wife, Julie, died at Passavant on Feb. 27, 2000, after Applegate’s second attempt to remove the fetus. Also named as defendants are Passavant, Magee and UPMC Health System.
Applegate, a prominent abortion doctor with offices on Perry Highway in Wexford, could not be reached for comment. A UPMC spokesman said officials could not comment on pending litigation.
Julie Speicher, who had two children with David, was expecting their third in June 2000. But when she went to the doctor for her monthly checkup on Feb. 24, 2000, the fetus was dead. Applegate decided to perform the removal procedure, called an evacuation, in his office. When complications arose and Speicher stopped breathing, Applegate called 911. Paramedics inserted a breathing tube and took her to Passavant.
On Feb. 25, Applegate tried to evacuate the fetus again. But Speicher’s condition deteriorated and the next day she died. The Allegheny County coroner’s office classified the death as “therapeutic misadventure.” She was 32 and left behind her husband, their son, Adam, 6, and daughter, Alyssa, 4.
The suit says Applegate should have begun the operation in a hospital because he and his staff were unable to deal with an emergency in the office. The doctor had no nurse anesthetist, did not monitor Speicher’s vital signs, did no blood testing and, when Speicher stopped breathing, didn’t know how to intubate her because he’d never done it, according to the suit. The doctor also did not perform a procedure called osmotic dilation to soften the cervix, which the suit said is a mandatory precaution in second trimester evacuations.
Applegate, who still has staff privileges at Passavant and Magee, had been under a three-month suspension by Magee at the time of the procedure, according to the suit, because of failure to respond to pages to deliver babies. He didn’t tell Speicher about the suspension, however, and used a Magee consent form for the procedure. Because Magee operated the obstetrics unit at Passavant, according to the suit, Applegate’s suspension at Magee meant he should have been prevented from using the Passavant facility.
According to the suit, he also used his own equipment at Passavant, a violation of hospital policy. The suit alleges that Applegate lied on his original 1993 application for privileges at Passavant by claiming he had no lawsuits against him when he actually had five. He was kept on junior active status for three years instead of one because he had 43 violations for failure to complete hospital charts on time, the suit says. In all, Applegate has had nine medical malpractice lawsuits brought against him in 10 years and has changed insurance carriers three times, according to the suit, but Passavant did not suspend him.
References: Torsten Ove. “Young Mother’s Death Brings Lawsuit.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, December 18, 2001; “Abortion Practitioner Sued for Killing Woman After Miscarriage.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, December 18, 2001; Steven Ertelt’s Pro-Life Infonet at http://www.prolifeinfo.org/infonet.html, December 19, 2001.
A Killer Template
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Key:
“Watch list” means that the abortionist quit killing babies or retired.
“Suspected” is an suspected past abortionist for whom we don’t have current information.
“Verified” is an active killer.
“Promoter” is neither a killing place owner or killer, but one who works in or promotes the abortion industry.
Other codes are self-explanatory: retired, deceased, suspended, revoked, etc.
Date of birth (DOB) can be substituted with an approximate year of birth (YOB). The latest possible date of birth can be deduced from the FL Department of Health website by looking at the earliest entry date of the killer to a medical school, which can be assumed by subtracting 21 from this date.
Template:
Last name, first name, middle name (key code) – city or cities
Medical license address
Other addresses
DOB or YOB (c.):
Staff privileges at hospitals:
Other state licensures:
Disciplinary records, lawsuits, criminal records:
Accomplices and connections to other abortion clinics; abortionists
CorporationWiki map — Link to the large map under the killer’s name at www.corporationwiki.com.
Facebook page url
Photos
News stories with sources (web urls, publications)
Other notes of interest and importance
Disclaimer:
(Post at the bottom of each Killer page.) All information on this page is gleaned from information that is public record and freely available elsewhere on the Internet. This information has been compiled as a public service. The administrators of this website claim no responsibility for its content.
Florida's Killing Places
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011
View Florida Abortion Clinics in a larger mapSouth East - Miami - Advance Woman's Care Center
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Advance Woman’s Care Center, 2742 SW 8th St # 20, Miami, FL 33135-4635
Killers:
Spence, Mark R (verified) – Hialeah
View Florida Abortion Clinics in a larger mapFacility/Provider Type: Abortion Clinic
Administrator: ARMEIRA CEDENO
Owner: ADVANCE WOMAN’S CARE CENTER, INC.
Owner Since: 5/16/1994
Profit Status: For-Profit
Licensed Beds: Not Available
AHCA Number (File Number): 13940024
AHCA Region: 11
License Number: 766
Current License Effective: 6/2/2011
License Expires: 6/1/2013
License Status: ACTIVE
Authorized Procedures : First TrimesterFlorida Profit Corporation:
ADVANCE WOMAN’S CARE CENTER, INC.
Registered Agent Name & Address
CEDENO, ARMEIRA
9674 NW 10TH AVENUE
LOTO C322
MIAMI FL 33135 USOfficer/Director Detail
Name & AddressTitle PD
GOWDY, DAYANA
18794 NW 80TH AVE
MIAMI FLTitle V
CEDENO, ARMEIRA
9674 N.W. 10TH. AVE.
MIAMI FL 33150Title T
GOWDY, DAYANA
18794 NW 80 AVE
MIAMI FL 33015Title S
CEDENO, ARMEIRA
9674 N.W. 10TH. AVE.
MIAMI FL 33150-PSouth East - North Miami Beach - Women & Teens Healthcare*
By Jay Rogers
Published July 9, 2011Women & Teens Healthcare, 16876 Northeast 19th Avenue, North Miami Beach, FL 33162
Killer:
Braithwaite, Sylvester Reynold (owner, verified) – North Miami Beach
* No AHCA license at this address
View Florida Abortion Clinics in a larger mapFlorida Profit Corporation:
WOMEN & TEENS COMMUNITY HEALTHCARE CENTER, INC.
Registered Agent Name & Address
BRAITHWAITE, SYLVESTER
16876 N.E. 19TH AVE.
N MIAMI BEACH FL 33162Officer/Director Detail
Name & AddressTitle PCEO
BRAITHWAITE, SYLVESTER DR
16876 N.E. 19TH AVE.
NO. MIAMI BEACH FL 33162 USTitle DIR
BRAITHWAITE, BRIAN
16876 N.E. 19TH AVENUE
NORTH MIAMI BEACH FL 33162 US
Amazing Grace: The History and Theology of Calvinism (DVD)Download the Free Study Guide!
Just what is Calvinism?
Does this teaching make man a deterministic robot and God the author of sin? What about free will? If the church accepts Calvinism, won’t evangelism be stifled, perhaps even extinguished? How can we balance God’s sovereignty and man’s responsibility? What are the differences between historic Calvinism and hyper-Calvinism? Why did men like Augustine, Luther, Calvin, Spurgeon, Whitefield, Edwards and a host of renowned Protestant evangelists embrace the teaching of predestination and election and deny free will theology?
This is the first video documentary that answers these and other related questions. Hosted by Eric Holmberg, this fascinating three-part, four-hour presentation is detailed enough so as to not gloss over the controversy. At the same time, it is broken up into ten “Sunday-school-sized” sections to make the rich content manageable and accessible for the average viewer.
Running Time: 257 minutes
$19.95 — ORDER NOW!
(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)Click here for more information
God's Law and Society (DVD)Download the Free Study Guide!
God’s Law and Society powerfully presents a comprehensive worldview based upon the ethical system found in the Law of God.
Speakers include: R.J. Rushdoony, George Grant, Howard Phillips, R.C. Sproul Jr., Ken Gentry, Gary DeMar, Jay Grimstead, Steven Schlissel, Andrew Sandlin, Eric Holmberg, and more!
Sixteen Christian leaders and scholars answer some of the most common questions and misconceptions related to this volatile issue:
1. Are we under Law or under Grace?
2. Does the Old Testament Law apply today?
3. Can we legislate morality?
4. What are the biblical foundations of government?
5. Was America founded as a Christian nation?
6. What about the separation of Church and State?
7. Is neutrality a myth?
8. What about non-Christians and the Law of God?
9. Would there be “freedom” in a Christian republic?
10. What would a “Christian America” look like?Perfect for group instruction as well as personal Bible study.
Ten parts, over four hours of instruction!
Running Time: 240 minutes
Watch over 60 on-line video interviews from God’s Law and Society.
$19.95 — ORDER NOW!
(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)Click here for more information
Freedom: The Model of Christian Liberty (DVD)“Give me liberty or give me death!”
Patrick Henry’s famous declaration not only helped launch the War for Independence, it also perfectly summarized the mindset that gave birth to, and sustained, the unprecedented experiment in Christian liberty that was America.
The freedom our Founders envisioned was not freedom from suffering, want, or hard work. Nor was it freedom to indulge every appetite or whim without restraint—that would merely be servitude to a different master. No, the Founders’ passion was to live free before God, unfettered by the chains of autocracy, shackles that slowly but inexorably bind men when the governments they fashion fail to recognize and uphold freedom’s singular, foundational truth: that all men are created in the image of God, and are thereby co-equally endowed with the right to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.”
This presentation is a similar call, not to one but many. By reintroducing the principles of freedom that gave birth to America, it is our prayer that Jesus, the true and only ruler over the nations, will once again be our acknowledged Sovereign, that we may again know and exult in the great truth that “where the Spirit of the LORD is, there is liberty” (2 Cor. 3:17).
Welcome to the Second American Revolution!
This DVD features “Liberty: The Model of Christian Liberty” along with “Dawn’s Early Light: A Brief History of America’s Christian Foundations.” Bonus features include a humorous but instructive collection of campaign ads and Eric Holmberg’s controversial YouTube challenge concerning Mitt Romney’s campaign for president.
$14.95 — ORDER NOW!
(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)Click here for more information
The Four Keys to the Millennium (Book)Foundations in Biblical Eschatology
By Jay Rogers, Larry Waugh, Rodney Stortz, Joseph Meiring. High quality paperback, 167 pages.
All Christians believe that their great God and Savior, Jesus Christ, will one day return. Although we cannot know the exact time of His return, what exactly did Jesus mean when he spoke of the signs of His coming (Mat. 24)? How are we to interpret the prophecies in Isaiah regarding the time when “the earth will be full of the knowledge of the LORD as the waters cover the sea” (Isa. 11:19)? Should we expect a time of great tribulation and apostasy or revival and reformation before the Lord returns? Is the devil bound now, and are the saints reigning with Christ? Did you know that there are four hermeneutical approaches to the book of Daniel and Revelation?
These and many more questions are dealt with by four authors as they present the four views on the millennium. Each view is then critiqued by the other three authors.
$12.95 — ORDER NOW!
(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)Click here for more information
The Beast of Revelation: Identified (DVD)Who is the dreaded beast of Revelation?
Now at last, a plausible candidate for this personification of evil incarnate has been identified (or re-identified). Ken Gentry’s insightful analysis of scripture and history is likely to revolutionize your understanding of the book of Revelation — and even more importantly — amplify and energize your entire Christian worldview!
Historical footage and other graphics are used to illustrate the lecture Dr. Gentry presented at the 1999 Ligonier Conference in Orlando, Florida. It is followed by a one-hour question and answer session addressing the key concerns and objections typically raised in response to his position. This presentation also features an introduction that touches on not only the confusion and controversy surrounding this issue — but just why it may well be one of the most significant issues facing the Church today.
Ideal for group meetings, personal Bible study — for anyone who wants to understand the historical context of John’s famous letter “… to the seven churches which are in Asia.” (Revelation 1:4)
Running Time: 145 minutes
$17.95 — ORDER NOW!
(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)
Reis, Mona S (owner, promoter) – West Palm Beach
By Jay Rogers
Published April 4, 2012
Killing Place:
Presidential Women’s Center
100 Northpoint Parkway
West Palm Beach, Florida 33407
Home:
3816 Embassy Dr
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map

YOB: September 1951
Founder of Presidential Medical Management Co, Inc.
Unquestionably the “Fort Knox” of South Florida abortion clinics, Presidential Women’s Center is one of the longest run abortion clinics in that area and is heavily protected by not only law enforcement, but political powers in Palm Beach County.
Board member of the National Abortion Federation
Incorporated by Bernard Smith, Maureen Paul, Mona S Reis, Susan Dudley, Vicki Breitbart, Vicki Saporta, National Abortion Federation Inc. is located at 310 W 20th St Ste 300 Kansas City, MO 64108. National Abortion Federation Inc. was incorporated on Sunday, April 28, 2002 in the State of Florida and is currently not active. Corporation Service Company represents National Abortion Federation Inc. as their registered agent.
National Abortion Federation
1755 Massachusetts Ave., NW, Suite 600
Washington DC 20036
Officer/Director Detail of Florida Corporation
Chairman
Paul, Maureen MD
1055 Commonwealth Avenue
Boston MA 02215
Vice President
Smith, Bernard MD
1428 N. Farwell Avenue
Milwaukee WI 53202
Secretary
Breitnart, Vicki MSW EDD
26 Bleeker Street
New York, NY 10012
Treasurer
Reis, Mona
1501 Presidential Way, Ste. 19
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
President, CEO
Saporta, Vicki
1755 Massachusetts Ave., NW, Suite 600
Washington DC 20036
Director
Dudley, Susan
1755 Massachusetts Ave., NW, Suite 600
Washington DC 20036
Mona Reis is a vocal promoter of abortion. She is connected politically and within the medical community. She is a native of Miami and graduated from Miami Norland Senior High School. She is a single mother of two. She has been quoted in numerous articles over the years.
Rader’s female backers say they still support him in Senate District 27, despite Benacquisto’s rape revelation

After participating in a press conference in downtown West Palm Beach Thursday afternoon to show her support for state senate candidate Kevin Rader, Tracy Pafford (left) talks with Mona Reis, founder and president of the Presidential Women’s Center. During the press conference Pafford revealed for the first time publicly that she was raped at the age of 14.
Supported Florida state senator Kevin Rader (D) in his attacks on Lizbeth Benacquisto, his Republican opponent, in ads as an “extremist.” First, Rader aired a commercial arguing that Benacquisto’s “extremist” allies would turn women into “criminals” by outlawing abortion in all cases, including after rape or incest. Then Benacquisto struck back with an ad disclosing that she herself was a rape victim – and alleging that Rader had “crossed a line” by “exploiting this crime, suggesting that I wouldn’t stand up for other victims.”
Board of directors of Cancer Center of South Florida Foundation, Inc.
Mona Reis – Director
Mona S. Reis has devoted her life to providing healthcare services to women in an atmosphere of dignity and respect. As a seasoned healthcare professional, Ms. Reis has always been guided by the principle that listening to your patients is key to providing them the highest quality medical care.
Her dedication to helping others led her to found Presidential Women’s Center in 1980 which provides the full range of gynecological care, to include outpatient termination of pregnancy and tubal ligation services. As Founder and C.E.O. of Presidential Women’s Center, Ms. Reis has developed, operated and managed a Center known for its excellence in patient care for over 30 years. Ms. Reis did this by investing in her staff, facilities and services. Staff training, continuing education and developing best practices and procedures are at the core of her healthcare management philosophy.
Ms. Reis is a leader in both advocacy and service in the field of women’s health. Providing exceptional patient care is her passion and the fulfillment of a deep commitment to empowering women through the provision of life-affirming medical care.
Ms. Reis has received the Planned Parenthood Advocacy Award, Executive Women’s Private Sector “Women in Leadership Award”, NOW’s Susan B. Anthony Award, 2005 Choice Generation Award with her daughter, NCJW “Women of Power Award” and the ACLU’s Harriette Glasner 2006 Freedom Award.
Clinic Fire Fans Flames Of Simmering Abortion Debate
July 07, 2005 – By Howard Goodman – Commentary
Mona Reis was in Boston on vacation Monday night, watching Fourth of July fireworks and listening to the Boston Pops, when her cell phone went off.
It was her security-alarm service, telling her a fire alarm had been tripped in the clinic she owns in West Palm Beach.
Another phone call confirmed it was a fire.
Reis called three staff members, who hurried to the scene.
Soon one called her back, in tears.
“She was saying they wouldn’t let her in, and there was smoke everywhere, and she was shaking, and she’d call me back when she learned anything,” Reis said.
Right then, Reis told herself this was no accident.
In its 25 years, the Presidential Women’s Center had been spared the violence that has plagued many clinics around the nation that perform abortions: bombings, vandalism, anthrax threats. Even murder.
But the center’s luck ran out.
On Wednesday, having found evidence of a fire accelerant, police were calling the West Palm fire “suspicious.”
“Now we’re part of the national violence statistics,” Reis said. “We’re `arson.’ And maybe it will turn out to be other things, as we go along.”
So this is what the rockets’ red glare and bombs bursting in air have come to mean to one zealous faction of the anti-abortion movement.
Last year over the Fourth of July weekend, someone threw an explosive through a window at the WomenCare Center in Lake Worth.
The blaze scorched patient records and medical equipment. The building on North Federal Highway is still closed.
Two years ago, over Memorial Day weekend, a Tamarac abortion clinic was torched and vandalized.
It’s no exaggeration to call these incidents “terrorism.” It’s violence intended to scare people so they no longer pursue a certain goal. That’s the very definition of terrorism.
Yet we don’t hear much condemnation from a federal government that’s vowed to fight terror in all its forms.
Since 1993, six doctors and other clinic employees have been shot and killed, according to the National Abortion Federation, an association of abortion providers. A police officer died in a Birmingham, Ala., clinic bombing. Five other abortion workers have been shot and injured.
“I have doctors all over the country who wear bulletproof vests every day,” said a National Abortion Federation security official, who insisted on anonymity out of safety concerns.
Reis absorbed the sense of risk long ago.
“We are very well-versed in security measures,” she told me in an interview two years ago.
She’s seen herself depicted on anti-abortion Web site as Hitler. In her neighborhood, leaflets have circulated identifying her as an abortion provider and giving her home address.
“We’ve had drills, security training, in-service with law enforcement and we’ve been doing this for years. We’ve often had bomb threat and bomb squads,” she said Wednesday.
“Unfortunately, we are experienced in this.”
The smell of burning plastic hung in the air. Windows were shattered. Electricity was off. Yet the staff was answering phones and scheduling appointments at another facility.
“We look forward to having our doors open as expeditiously as possible,” she said.
Though her voice was a little shaky, she said, “They’re not going to stop our resolve.”
It takes a certain cast of mind to set fires or shoot doctors in the name of “pro-life.”
But all through history, extremists have claimed that some higher calling justifies violence.
From John Brown’s attempted insurrection to free the slaves to al-Qaida’s suicide-skyjackings.
Abortion is an issue that brooks little compromise from the anti-abortion or pro-choice forces. The emotions will only get hotter as the battle heats up over a successor to Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor.
I’m afraid it will be a long time before we see the end of this kind of fire and smoke.
Federal Lawsuit Filed Against Florida Sidewalk Counselor
Presidential Women’s Center in West Palm Beach must be feeling the pressure. Mary Susan Pine, a successful sidewalk counselor, has pled for many years with Presidential Women’s Center customers to give life to their children. Mona Reis, the owner of Presidential, finally got someone to attempt to scare off Pine. That someone was your U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder and his south Florida coworkers.
On August 18, 2010, Holder’s office filed a federal civil action (lawsuit) against Pine and, by extension, those “acting in concert” with her. The only law violation alleged was the aged Federal Access to Clinic Entrances Act (F.A.C.E.) passed by Bill Clinton in 1994. The act made it a federal crime to block the entrances to a medical facility, but abortion clinics were the sole beneficiary of the law since they were the only ones being blocked on any regular basis prior to F.A.C.E.’s passage.
Pine is represented by Orlando’s Liberty Counsel. Founder and Chairman of Liberty Counsel Mathew Staver said in an August 24 press release, “This lawsuit by Attorney General Eric Holder is politically motivated and patently frivolous. It is designed to intimidate pro-lifers. We will not allow the Attorney General to push around little people and intimidate them for their pro-life beliefs.”
The fuss, apparently, is a nine-month old incident in which Presidential employees claim that Pine blocked a car for a few minutes. Although Pine denies it, one can assume that the clinic with its 15+ cameras has something on video to convince them they finally got Pine in some kind of law violation.
Hilariously, Holder’s suit alleges that Pine, “unless restrained… will continue to engage in illegal conduct”. Except that Pine has been there for years prior to the so-called “incident” and even nine months since then. Even if the allegations prove true, Holder and his abortion industry allies seek to allege that merely a few minutes delay en route to kill a baby could be grounds for violation of F.A.C.E.
Liberty Counsel says that FACE can only be applied to actual physical force or threat of force based on Cheffer v. Reno, a case already won by Liberty Counsel that was dismissed in district court and further lost on appeal by then U.S. Attorney General Janet Reno. Apparently, Holder’s office thinks this momentary car stoppage worthy of a second attempt – at taxpayer expense, of course. Amazingly, it took six government employees to file a suit barely four pages long.
What does Presidential Women’s Center hope to gain? The suit calls for a $10,000 fine against Pine, but the finger-crossing of Reis and her clinic workers have to be focused on the first request for judgment: “An order prohibiting Defendant, Mary Susan Pine, fro entering any driveway leading into the Presidential Women’s Center parking lot.” A quick glance at the aerial photo of Presidential tells you why. If you can’t stand in the driveway (traffic or not), there’s absolutely no visibility into the clinic’s parking lot. Which means customers of Presidential can’t see Pine or other prolife activists. With the City of Palm Beach already in bed with Presidential in their 2006 noise ordinance (which is basically interpreted as “whisper quietly amongst yourselves or else”), the only thing left to do is to make prolife activists disappear.
In other words: “We’re drowning in debt and if this lady doesn’t stop talking to our customers, we’re not going to have any left.” One wonders why Reis hasn’t put her video online at YouTube to show the world how intrusive Pine’s action was. If we get a copy, we’ll happily do it for her.
Below is the complaint as filed in U.S. District (federal) Court on August 18, 2010. The case is currently filed in the court of Senior Judge Kenneth Ryskamp, a Reagan appointee.
Case 9:10-cv-80971-KLR (Holder v. Pine)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
ERIC H. HOLDER, JR.,
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff,
v.
MARY SUSAN PINE
Defendant
COMPLAINT
Eric H. Holder, Jr., Attorney General of the United States of America (the “United States Attorney General”), by the undersigned attorneys, asserts a civil cause of action under the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act (“FACE”), 18 U.S.C. § 248 (1994), enacted into law May 26, 1994, as follows:
1. In bringing this action, the United States Attorney General has reasonable cause to believe: (1) Defendant, Mary Susan Pine, has committed, and is likely to continue to commit, violations of FACE; and (2) various persons are being, have been, and will continue to be injured by Defendant’s conduct.
JURISDICTION, STANDING, AND VENUE
2. This Court has jurisdiction over this action pursuant to FACE, 18 U.S.C. § 248©(2), and 28 U.S.C. § 1345.
3. The United States Attorney General has standing to bring this action pursuant to FACE, 18 U.S.C. § 248©(2).
4. Venue is proper in this judicial district pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(l) and (b)(2), in that Defendant resides in this judicial district, and all the events giving rise to this complaint occurred in this judicial district.
DEFENDANT
5. Defendant, Mary Susan Pine, is a regular and vocal anti-abortion protester at the Presidential Women’s Center, located at 100 Northpoint Parkway in West Palm Beach, Florida.
6. On information and belief, Defendant resides in West Palm Beach, Florida.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
7. The Presidential Women’s Center provides women’s reproductive healthcare services.
8. Defendant has engaged in anti-abortion protest activity outside the Presidential Women’s Center for several years.
9. Defendant is one of two protesters who typically conducts her protest activity on the south side of Northpoint Parkway, which includes walking back and forth in the Presidential Women’s Center’s driveway.
10. On November 19, 2009, Defendant physically obstructed a car by stepping in front of the car as it was attempting to enter the driveway to the Presidential Women’s Center to access the parking lot.
11. The driver of the approaching car stopped to avoid striking Defendant.
12. Defendant attempted to, and did, interfere with the driver’s access to the Presidential Women’s Center.
CAUSE OF ACTION UNDER 18 U.S.C. § 248
13. The United States incorporates herein the averments of paragraphs 1 through 12 hereof.
14. Defendant’s conduct as described in paragraphs 10 through 12 hereof constitute a physical obstruction which interfered with a person who had been seeking reproductive health services.
15. On information and belief, unless Defendant is restrained by this Court, Defendant will continue to engage in the illegal conduct averred herein.
16. The United States Attorney General is authorized under 18 U.S.C. § 248©(2)(B) to seek and obtain temporary, preliminary, and/or permanent injunctive relief from this Court for Defendant’s violation of FACE.
17. The United States Attorney General is further authorized under 18 U.S.C. § 248©(2)(B)(i) to assess a civil penalty against a respondent no greater than $10,000.00 for a nonviolent physical obstruction.
WHEREFORE, the United States Attorney General respectfully requests judgment in his favor and against Defendant, Mary Susan Pine, in the form of:
A. An Order prohibiting Defendant, Mary Susan Pine, from entering any driveway leading into the Presidential Women’s Center parking lot;
B. An Order prohibiting Defendant, Mary Susan Pine, and her representatives, agents, employees and any others acting in concert or participation with her, from violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act; and
C. A civil penalty assessment in the amount of $10,000.00.
Respectfully submitted,
WIFREDO A. FERRER
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
THOMAS E. PEREZ
Assistant Attorney General
Civil Rights Division
JUDITH C. PRESTON
Acting Chief
Special Litigation Section
JULIE K. ABBATE
Acting Deputy Chief
Special Litigation Section
CATHLEEN TRAINOR
Senior Trial Attorney
United States Department of Justice
Civil Rights Division
Special Litigation Section
950 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
Washington, DC 20530
(202) 616-9009
(202) 514-0212 (fax)
cathleen.trainor@usdoj.gov
VERONICA HARRELL-JAMES
Assistant United States Attorney
99 N.E. 4th Street
Miami, FL 33132
Fla. Bar No. 644791
(305) 961-9327
(305) 530-7139 (fax)
UPDATE: Eric Holder’s Political Prosecution of Pro-Life Educator Thrown Out of Court
Judge suspects conspiracy between Eric Holder’s DOJ and abortion clinic to violate pro-lifers’ First Amendment rights
West Palm Beach, FL – A federal judge has ended Attorney General Eric Holder’s two-year political prosecution of pro-life educator Mary Susan Pine. Holder accused Pine of obstructing the entrance to an abortion clinic, in violation of the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act (“FACE”). Holder sought thousands of dollars in fines against Pine, as well as a permanent injunction banning her from counseling women on the public sidewalk outside the Presidential Women’s Center (“PWC”) abortion clinic, where she has faithfully ministered for over 20 years. Liberty Counsel successfully defended Pine.
In granting summary judgment, Judge Kenneth L. Ryskamp concluded that “the evidence could not lead a rational jury to find that Ms. Pine’s conduct [i.e., having peaceful conversations with clinic visitors on a public sidewalk] constituted a physical obstruction within the meaning of FACE.” He also concluded that the government lacked evidence to prove not just one, but “all three elements of its FACE claim.” Judge Ryskamp chastised Holder for seeking to apply federal law in a clearly unconstitutional manner: “Stretching the terms of FACE to apply to this case … so that a desire to provide people with information about alternatives to abortion constitutes an unlawful motive, would unjustifiably impinge on Ms. Pine’s First Amendment rights.”
The Government’s decision to prosecute Pine despite having no evidence of wrongdoing prompted Judge Ryskamp to suspect a conspiracy at the highest level of the Obama Administration: “The Court is at a loss as to why the Government chose to prosecute this particular case in the first place,” he wrote. “The Court can only wonder whether this action was the product of a concerted effort between the Government and the PWC, which began well before the date of the incident at issue, to quell Ms. Pine’s activities rather than to vindicate the rights of those allegedly aggrieved by Ms. Pine’s conduct.”
Harry Mihet, Senior Litigation Counsel for Liberty Counsel, commented: “This is a tremendous victory not just for Susan Pine, but for the First Amendment and the pro-life movement. Attorney General Holder sought to use federal law as a billy club against pro-lifers, but received instead a clobbering from the very Constitution he had sworn to protect. Freedom-loving Americans everywhere should rejoice.”
DOJ drops case against Florida pro-life sidewalk counselor, pays her $120G
Published April 02, 2012 | FoxNews.com
The Department of Justice has given up its bid to prosecute a pro-life counselor and agreed to pay her $120,000 in a case a judge said never should have been brought.
Mary Susan Pine, who stands outside abortion clinics and advises women not to have the procedure, was accused of blocking a car from entering a Florida abortion clinic in 2009. In December, a judge threw out the case, in which the government sought $10,000 in fines and a permanent injunction barring Pine from counseling women outside the Presidential Women’s Center in West Palm Beach, Fla. The government had been appealing the ruling until it was announced Monday it would no longer pursue the case.
Pine’s lawyer said she was a victim of a politically-driven prosecution.
“It is irresponsible for the U.S. Department of Justice to place politics above principle when deciding to prosecute, and thus attempt to silence, a pro-life sidewalk counselor without any evidence of wrongdoing,” Mathew Staver, founder and chairman of Liberty Counsel, said in a statement. “When the nation’s highest law enforcement officer files suit against any citizen, the suit must be based on the law coupled with compelling evidence. Anything less is an abuse of the high office.”
A spokesperson for the Department of Justice defended prosecution decision as “based on the facts presented during our investigations and the applicable federal laws.” In Pine’s case, “the department made a decision to settle with the defendant rather than continue with costly litigation.”
Florida District Judge Kenneth Ryskamp said in December the case appeared to be part of a “concerted effort” between the government and the Presidential Women’s Center.
“The Court is at a loss as to why the government chose to prosecute this particular case in the first place,” Ryskamp wrote in a summary judgment order against the feds. “The court can only wonder whether this action was the product of a concerted effort between the government and PWC, which began well before the date of the incident at issue, to quell Ms. Pine’s activities rather than to vindicate the rights of those allegedly aggrieved by Ms. Pine’s conduct.”
Under the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances (FACE) federal law, DOJ officials alleged that Pine obstructed a car from entering the Florida abortion clinic on Nov. 19, 2009.
Pine, who could not be reached for comment, had denied obstructing any vehicle from entering the clinic.
Windle, Edward (owner, retired, watchlist) – Melbourne
By Jay Rogers
Published April 3, 2012
Killing Places:
Aware Woman Center for Choice
1564 Dixie Way
Melbourne, FL 32935
Home:
4860 Riverside Road
Palm Shores, FL 32935
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: October 1932
A Radical Bows Out!
Aware Woman was owned by Patricia Baird Windle and Edward W. (Ted) Windle, Jr. pictured on the left.
Read more about the “radical” pro-abortion advocate Patricia Windle.
Aware Woman Center for Choice was the only state-licensed abortion clinic in the 70-mile-long Brevard County, on the east coast of central Florida known as the Space Coast, home of Kennedy Space Center. Aware Woman’s professional staff proudly killed an average of 25 unborn babies each week and occasionally sent a baby’s mother to the hospital in an ambulance.
Related Articles
Windle, Patricia Baird (owner, retired, watchlist) - Melbourne
By Jay Rogers
Published April 3, 2012
Killing Places:
Aware Woman Center for Choice
1564 Dixie Way
Melbourne, FL 32935
Home:
4860 Riverside Road
Palm Shores, FL 32935
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: November 1934
A Radical Bows Out!
Aware Woman was owned by Patricia Baird Windle and Edward W. (Ted) Windle, Jr. pictured on the left.
Read more about the “radical” pro-abortion advocate Patricia Windle.
Aware Woman Center for Choice was the only state-licensed abortion clinic in the 70-mile-long Brevard County, on the east coast of central Florida known as the Space Coast, home of Kennedy Space Center. Aware Woman’s professional staff proudly killed an average of 25 unborn babies each week and occasionally sent a baby’s mother to the hospital in an ambulance.
Related Articles
Snydle, Frank Emil (null and void, deceased) – Winter Haven
By Jay Rogers
Published April 3, 2012

Frank Snydel suffered a heart attack a few years ago and went to his reward. For sure, he no longer kills children and he now is a believing, bowing, confessing and accounting ex-abortionist.
“For it is written, As I live, saith the Lord, every knee shall bow to me, and every tongue shall confess to God. So then every one of us shall give account of himself to God” (Romans 14:11-12 ).
Britton, John Bayard (verified, deceased) – Fernandina Beach
By Jay Rogers
Published April 3, 2012
John Bayard Britton (5/6/1925 – 7/29/1994) was a circuit riding abortionist who killed children at abortion centers all over Florida.
He was at Aware Woman Center for Choice in Melbourne, Florida on May 27, 1983 when he killed the baby of Maureen Lynne Tyke, who also died four days later from the botched abortion. Click on Maureen’s name to read the horrifying autopsy report for yourself.
Britton was in Pensacola, Florida on July 29, 1994 where he was tragically ambushed and murdered by Paul Hill, who was later executed for his crime.
John Britton
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
John Bayard Britton (May 6, 1925 – July 29, 1994)1 was an American physician. He was murdered in Pensacola, Florida by anti-abortion terrorist Paul Jennings Hill. Britton’s death was the second assassination of a Pensacola abortion provider in under a year and a half; he had replaced David Gunn after the latter’s 1993 murder by another anti-abortion terrorist.
Born in Boston, Massachusetts, Britton graduated in 1949 from the University of Virginia School of Medicine, then served in the army in Korea and taught at the Medical College of Georgia. He then became a family physician in Fernandina Beach, Florida, spending much of his time delivering babies.2
After Gunn’s murder, Britton began flying across the state to Pensacola weekly in order to perform abortions at the Pensacola Ladies’ Center. Because he had received harassment and death threats, he wore a homemade bulletproof vest, carried a .357 Magnum,3 and enlisted volunteer bodyguards.1
Britton was notably ambivalent about abortion: he was vocal about his personal opposition to the procedure, and would sometimes turn away women seeking it, telling them to think about the decision and come back in a week if they still wanted an abortion. However, he described anti-abortion protesters as “fanatics.”2
As Britton arrived at the clinic on July 29, 1994, Hill approached and fired on him with a twelve-gauge shotgun, hitting him in the head and killing Britton, aged 69. Hill later stated that he aimed for Dr. Britton’s head because he suspected the doctor was wearing a bulletproof vest.1 Hill also killed Britton’s bodyguard, a retired Air Force lieutenant, James Barrett (aged 74), and wounded Barrett’s wife, June, a retired nurse. The murder resulted in several members of Congress calling for the FBI to infiltrate anti-abortion groups, as it had with the Ku Klux Klan.3
A piece several months earlier in GQ, by Tom Junod, had profiled a number of parties involved in the murder: Dr. Britton, but also Hill and the Barretts.4 Britton and Hill are also interviewed in Tony Kaye’s documentary Lake of Fire, which was released in 2006.5
References
1 McCann, Joseph T. (2006). Terrorism on American soil: a concise history of plots and perpetrators from the famous to the forgotten. Sentient Publications. p. 202.
2 Verhovek, Sam (July 31, 1994). At Center of Abortion Shooting: an Avid Protester and an Uncertain Martyr. The New York Times.
3 Van Biema, David (August 8, 1994). Avenging the Unborn. Time.
4 Junod, Tom (February 1994). The Abortionist. GQ.
5 Pilkington, Ed (October 23, 2007). Right to choose? British director tackles the debate that divides US. The Guardian.
Wolf, Lewis Sidney (verified, revoked) - St. Petersburg, Tampa, Melbourne
By Jay Rogers
Published April 3, 2012
Killing Places:
Aware Woman Center for Choice
1564 Dixie Way
Melbourne, FL 32935
Home:
237 7th Avenue North
St. Petersburg, FL 33701
DOB: July 1939
Lewis Sidney Wolf was disciplined by Florida on July 16, 1991.
Disciplinary Action: Emergency Suspension.
Notes: Emergency suspension of license based on being unable to practice medicine with reasonable skill and safety by reason of illness or use of alcohol, drugs, narcotics, chemicals or any other type of material, or as a result of any mental or physical condition.
Source: Questionable Doctors, 1993 Edition, published by Public Citizen, 2000 P Street NW, Washington, DC 20036
Central East - Melbourne - Aware Woman Center for Choice (closed!)*
By Jay Rogers
Published April 1, 2012
Aware Woman Center for Choice (closed!) 1564 Dixie Way, Melbourne, FL 32935
Killers:
Windle, Edward (owner) – Melbourne
Windle, Patricia Baird (owner) – Melbourne
According to owner Patricia Baird-Windle, Aware Woman had a total of 24 abortionists over the years who each chose to quit rather than be exposed as child killers by pro-life advocates. The known killers appear here in reverse chronological order.
Egherman, William Phillip (verified, deceased) – Gainesville
Ravi, Himagiri G. (verified) – Lakeland
Arcelin, Gostal (watch list) – Boca Raton
Kelly, Patrick Joseph (verified, owner) – Jacksonville
Whitney, Randall Brooks (verified) – Orlando
Arrogante, Carlito B. (verified) – Lake Worth
Coleman, Steven Carter (verified) – Largo
Jones, James Lewis (verified) – Jacksonville
Boone, Scott Allen (verified) – Orlando
Stowe, Jeffrey M. (null and void) – Jacksonville
Wyninger, Carol J. (verified) – Jacksonville
Pendergraft, James Scott (verified, suspended) – Orlando, Ocala, Tampa, Fort Lauderdale
Turner, Robert Charles (null and void) – St. Augustine
Snydle, Frank Emil (null and void, deceased) – Winter Haven
Ruangsomboon, Monthree (verified) – Longwood
Wolf, Lewis Sidney (verified, revoked) – St. Petersburg
Britton, John Bayard (verified, deceased) – Fernandina Beach
Pagan, Jose Antonio (verified) – Palm Harbor
Florida Profit Corporation (Inactive)
AWARE WOMAN CENTER FOR CHOICE, INC.
Registered Agent Name & Address
ANDERSON., J P
932 S HARBOR CITY BLVD
STE 505
MELBOURNE FL 32901 US
Officer/Director Detail
Name & Address
Title P
WINDLE, PATRICIA
1564 DIXIE WAY
MELBOURNE FL 32935
Title VST
WINDLE, RONI L
1564 DIXIE HWY.
MELBOURNE FL 32935
Closed Big Time!

This is the demolition of Aware Woman Center for Choice in 2000. No abortion clinic operates in Brevard County today!
Aware Woman was located in the city limits of Melbourne, Florida. Melbourne is located on the east coast of sunny Florida about 60 miles southeast of Orlando. Another Aware Woman Health Center was in Port St. Lucie, Florida, but closed several years earlier.
The abortion industry in Brevard County, Florida now consists of zero abortion clinics. The last abortion clinic, WomanCare of Melbourne, opened by Tammy Sobieski on August 21, 2000 and later moved to 412 High Point Drive, Cocoa, FL 32926. WomanCare of Cocoa closed August 19, 2005. Even “pro-choice” landlords don’t want abortion clinics in their properties.
A Radical Bows Out!
Aware Woman was owned by Patricia Baird Windle and Edward W. (Ted) Windle, Jr. pictured on the left.
Read more about the “radical” pro-abortion advocate Patricia Windle.
Aware Woman Center for Choice was the only state-licensed abortion clinic in the 70-mile-long Brevard County, on the east coast of central Florida known as the Space Coast, home of Kennedy Space Center. Aware Woman’s professional staff proudly killed an average of 25 unborn babies each week and occasionally sent a baby’s mother to the hospital in an ambulance.
Aware Woman sued by former patient under FACE
A former patient charges Aware Woman with violating the Federal Civil Rights Act, known as F.A.C.E., 18 U.S.C. §248, by preventing her egress from the facility on March 29, 1997 when Aware Woman, and/or their employees, did unlawfully, “interfere with”, “intimidate”, and use “physical obstruction” to restrain her and render impassable her desired egress from said facility.
Aware Woman Unsafe!

Warning signs across the street from Aware Woman’s parking lot
These signs warn new patients about the four previous patients who were taken directly to the emergency room from Aware Woman giving the dates of same.
Aware Woman Worker’s Car
Click image to enlarge.
This car belongs to one of the Aware Woman workers. Bumper sticker text is included here:
Quality Care?
Another example of the Aware Woman style of quality care for women is shown here. What about a germ-free sanitary surgical environment?
Pictured here is Krysty going into work at Aware Woman with her scrubs already on. Scrubs are to be put on in the surgery area to keep from bringing germs in from the outside. Several employees wear scrubs to work every surgery day.
Survivors
Several victims have managed to escape with the help of pro-lifers.
Insurance Claims
The following info on insurance claims paid on behalf of Aware Woman provided by Florida Professional Liability Closed Claims.
Provider Name: Aware Woman Health Center
Profession: Abortion Clinic
| ITEM | CLAIM #1 | CLAIM #2 | |||
| File Number | 8802611 | 8903738 | |||
| Total Indemnity | $5,000 | $91,500 | |||
| Occurance Date | 10-07-87 | 01-09-88 | |||
| Disposition Date | 07-05-88 | 11-14-89 | |||
| County | St. Lucie | St. Lucie |
Related Articles
Killer: A Definition
By Meredith Raney
Published April 1, 2012
killer (kil’ er) adj. – awesome, spectacular, amazing, tremendous.
See also:
Creating Killer Interactive Web Sites – One of the top-selling Web design books ever published.
Whaley, Walker L. (verified, deceased) – Jacksonville, Gainesville
By Jay Rogers
Published March 25, 2012
Killing Places:
All Women’s Health Center of Jacksonville
4331 University Boulevard South
Jacksonville, FL 32216-4909
All Women’s Health Center of Gainesville
1135 NW 23rd Avenue, Ste N,
Gainesville, FL 32609
Home:
13673 Longs Landing Road West
Jacksonville, FL 32225-5423
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map

This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Columbia Jacksonville Surgery Center; Columbia Jacksonville Medical Center
Birth: 12/25/1947
Death: 5/31/2012
Note: Walker Whaley died of a heart attack at age 64.
Convicted For Conspiracy to Manufacture Cocaine
Walker L. Whaley was convicted for conspiring to manufacture cocaine in his basement with his brother Jonathan in 1986: United States of America, Plaintiff-appellee, v. Walker L. Whaley, Defendant-appellant
The Florida Board of Medical Examiners recommended suspension and probation due to Whaley’s 1984 conviction on conspiracy to manufacture cocaine. It ordered his medical license to be suspended for three years or until completion of the federal sentence, whichever was longer, with reinstatement of his license granted only under stipulations. Whaley, his brother, and the brother’s female roommate reportedly were discovered by DEA agents in a drug laboratory in Whaley’s basement.
Malpractice Case
Abortionist Walker L. Whaley attended the birth of Chad Nolan on December 14, 1981. He allowed fetal distress and tachycardia to continue for three hours, administered narcotic drugs, which crossed the placenta to the unborn child, and failed to perform a C-section, resulting in the infant suffering a seizure disorder.
References: DPR Case #0035663; Duval County Circuit Court Case #84-10676; and Florida Times-Union, February 9, 1986.
Estes, Christopher Michael (verified, promoter, instructor) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published March 25, 2012
Killing Place:
Jackson Memorial Hospital
1611 NW 12th Ave
Suite 7007
Miami, Florida 33136
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
A promoter/instructor is an abortionist who recruits or trains abortionists. They occupy a strategic position, for without the instructor, there are no new abortionists.
Obstetrics & Gynecology
Assistant Professor of Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Miami
YOB: January 1976
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
University of Miami Hospital; Jackson Memorial Hospital, Miami
Language: Spanish
Ryan Residency Training Program in Family Planning and Abortion
During the internship year, OB/GYN residents in our program spend two-three days per week over a six week period at the University of Miami Reproductive Health Services Clinic. Co-directed by Drs. Carla Lupi and Paul Norris, UMRHC provides surgical and medical abortions, uterine evacuation for failed pregnancies, and consultation on complicated contraceptive management.
Following a nationally devised curriculum, residents learn surgical procedures and pain management, counseling and communication skills, and principles of public health and evidence based medicine as related to family planning. This well-rated rotation provides first year residents valuable one-on-one didactic interaction with faculty members and full involvement in procedures and patient care.
The program has received its initial funding from the Ryan Residency Training Program in Family Planning and Abortion, a nationally available philanthropic effort designed to insure a solid education in the range of family planning services that obstetrician-gynecologists should master.
We look forward to the addition of Dr. Christopher Estes, a Family Planning Fellowship graduate from Columbia University, to our faculty. His leadership will enable the development of our own fellowship program and participation in multi-centered research. With reproductive health and family planning specifically at the international forefront of women’s health issues, a robust program is a must at our “global” university medical school.
Christopher Estes
10/09/2009
Christopher Estes, MD, MPH, does not tolerate misinformation about reproductive health care. “Whenever I hear a conversation about contraception or abortion, I work my way into it to be sure that the truth is heard.”
Dr. Estes has many chances to step in, both in English and Spanish. He is an ob-gyn who practices at two Miami hospitals and teaches at University of Miami’s medical school. He has taken on myths like “IUDs and abortions make you sterile, birth control pills cause cancer, and women who have abortions are stupid, irresponsible, selfish, or all three.”
He does not get tired of challenging these misconceptions, whether in casual conversation, grand rounds, or a staff meeting. Dr. Estes wants to make reproductive health care as accessible as possible to as many people as possible. He is open about the fact that he provides elective abortions at one of the two hospitals where he practices (the other institution allows the procedure only when the woman’s physical or mental health is threatened or the fetus is at risk for abnormality). “I let people know what I do, wherever I go.”
Multistate personhood push kindles abortion debate
January 20, 2012 | David Crary, AP National Writer
Dr. Christopher Estes, an obstetrician-gynecologist and abortion provider in Miami, described the influx of restrictive laws in Florida and elsewhere as dismaying.
“All these things don’t do anything to decrease women’s need for abortion,’’ he said. “It just hurts their care — particularly for the most vulnerable women.”
Estes, who teaches at the University of Miami’s medical school, said pressure from anti-abortion activists is unlikely to ease.
“They are equally ignorant and determined — it’s a bad combination,’’ he said. “They’re on a very misguided moral crusade and I don’t see it going away.’’
Patel, Rupa Dilipkumar (verified) - Tampa, Orlando
By Jay Rogers
Published March 20, 2012
Killing Places:
All Women’s Health Center of Orlando
431 Maitland Ave
Altamonte Springs, FL 32701
Tampa Woman’s Health Center
2010 East Fletcher Avenue
Tampa, FL 33612-3712
Offices:
Florida Women’s Center Altamonte
661 E Altamonte Dr # 318
Altamonte Springs, FL 32701
Home:
YOB: January 1973
Rupa Patel in the parking lot of All Women’s Health Center, Altamonte Springs, Florida. Click to enlarge.
Central East - Orlando - Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando Eastside
By Jay Rogers
Published January 2, 2012
Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando, Inc, 11500 University Blvd, Orlando, FL 32817
Killers:
Idtensohn, Susan Rodman (Planned Parenthood CEO) – Orlando
View Florida Abortion Clinics in a larger map
This location does not do surgical abortions, but abortion by pill and referrals to Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando on 726 S Tampa Ave.
Facility/Provider Type: Abortion Clinic
Administrator: KRISTEN M WAYLEN
Owner: PLANNED PARENTHOOD OF GREATER ORLANDO INC
Owner Since: 12/21/2009
Profit Status: Not-For-Profit
Licensed Beds: Not Available
AHCA Number (File Number): 13960114
AHCA Region: 07
License Number: 908
Current License Effective: 12/21/2011
License Expires: 12/20/2013
License Status: ACTIVE
Authorized Procedures : First Trimester
Florida Non Profit Corporation:
PLANNED PARENTHOOD OF GREATER ORLANDO, INC.
Registered Agent Name & Address
RODMAN IDTENSOHN, SUSAN
726 SOUTH TAMPA AVE
ORLANDO FL 32805 US
Officer/Director Detail
Name & Address
Title CD
WOLF, NANCY
726 S. TAMPA AVENUE.
ORLANDO FL 32805
Title T
ABRAMSON, SUZAN
726 S. TAMPA AVENUE
ORLANDO FL 32805
Title S
BLACKMUN, SALLY
1000 DARDEN CENTER DR.
ORLANOD FL 32837
North East - Jacksonville - Planned Parenthood of North Florida, Inc.
By Jay Rogers
Published January 2, 2012
Planned Parenthood of North Florida Inc., 3850 Beach Blvd, Jacksonville, FL 32207
Killers:
Miller Jr., Herman (verified) – Jacksonville
View Florida Abortion Clinics in a larger map
Does not provide surgical abortion services, but “morning after pill” and referrals.
Facility/Provider Type: Abortion Clinic
Administrator: ELIZABETH REGISTER
Owner: PLANNED PARENTHOOD OF NORTH FLORIDA INC
Owner Since: 3/4/1997
Profit Status: Not-For-Profit
Licensed Beds: Not Available
AHCA Number (File Number): 13960045
AHCA Region: 04
License Number: 844
Current License Effective: 2/28/2011
License Expires: 2/27/2013
License Status: ACTIVE
Authorized Procedures : First Trimester
Florida Non Profit Corporation:
PLANNED PARENTHOOD OF NORTH FLORIDA, INC.
Registered Agent Name & Address
FOX, STACI L
3850 BEACH BLVD
JACKSONVILLE FL 32207 US
Officer/Director Detail
Name & Address
Title CD
NESBIT, JANE
3850 BEACH BLVD
JACKSONVILLE FL 32207
Title CEO
FOX, STACI L
3850 BEACH BLVD
JACKSONVILLE FL 32207
Title TD
SHAMIS, JEFF
3850 BEACH BLVD
JACKSONVILLE FL 32207
Title VCD
CHAMBLIN, MINOR
3850 BEACH BLVD
JACKSONVILLE FL 32207
Title SD
DOOLITTLE, KIRSTEN
3850 BEACH BLVD
JACKSONVILLE FL 32207
North East - Jacksonville - A Woman's Choice of Jacksonville
By Jay Rogers
Published January 2, 2012
A Woman’s Choice of Jacksonville, Inc., 4131 University Blvd S # 2, Jacksonville, FL 32216-4346
Killers:
Miller Jr., Herman (verified) – Jacksonville
Miller, Lawrence Whitefield (retired, watchlist) – Jacksonville
Van Scriver, Kimberly Pauline (verified) – Jacksonville
View Florida Abortion Clinics in a larger map
Facility/Provider Type: Abortion Clinic
Administrator: CRYSTAL LARAINE VALENTINE
Owner: A WOMAN’S CHOICE OF JACKSONVILLE INC
Owner Since: 2/7/2002
Profit Status: For-Profit
Licensed Beds: Not Available
AHCA Number (File Number): 13960038
AHCA Region: 04
License Number: 795
Current License Effective: 12/5/2011
License Expires: 2/6/2012
License Status: ACTIVE
Authorized Procedures : First & Second Trimester
Florida Profit Corporation:
A WOMAN’S CHOICE OF JACKSONVILLE, INC.
Registered Agent Name & Address
MARTIN, KELLY
4131 UNIVERSITY BLVD. S., BLDG. 2
JACKSONVILLE FL 32216
Officer/Director Detail
Name & Address
Title PD
MARTIN, KELLY S
4131 UNIVERSITY BLVD. S., BLDG. 2
JACKSONVILLE FL 32216
A Killing Place Template
By Jay Rogers
Published December 31, 2011
Address
Killers:
Name of abortionists linked to pages
Google Map
AHCA information:
All abortions clinics that do outpatient surgery are required to be licensed by AHCA. Not all abortion clinics are surgical outpatient facilities. Some do referrals to surgical centers. Some do chemical abortions (that is, by pill).
Corporation Information:
Name of president/owner linked to page
WikiMap Links
Videos/descriptions
Photos/captions
Weinstein, Joan (owner) – Fort Lauderdale
By Jay Rogers
Published December 11, 2011
Killing Places:
East Cypress Women’s Center
962 E Cypress Creek Rd
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33334-4110
Home:
5341 NE 33rd Ave
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map

YOB: August 1943
Ultrasound bill just pandering to conservatives, kill it
May 18, 2010
Freedom: Is it for everyone, or only the Republicans in Tallahassee? Shame on them, once again, for attempting to interfere with a woman’s right to choose that which is appropriate for her and her alone. In attaching this abortion amendment to such an innocuous bill, they not only show their own smug bigotry but also their ignorance. A first-trimester ultrasound shows practically nothing. To force this viewing into law is just another exercise in pandering to their uber-conservative base. A woman who has made this incredibly difficult decision needs acceptance, not accusations. Hopefully, the newly independent Gov. Crist will use his veto pen to show them that women’s rights are equal to men.
- Joan Weinstein, Fort Lauderdale
Independent Art Historian?
Monday, October 25, 1993
Kultur-Kommerz-Kommunikation is a three-month lecture series organized by the Smart Museum designed to track social change in Germany and Austria in the first half of the century. Things kick off this evening at 5:30 with “Kathe Kollwitz and the Image of the Proletarian Woman in the 1931 Abortion Debate,” a paper by independent art historian Joan Weinstein. She’ll talk about how depictions of women changed with the 1929 economic collapse and how that change affected the abortion debate. Lectures continue every Monday at 5:30 through December 13 at the Cochrane-Woods Art Center, 5540 S. Greenwood (across from the museum). They’re free, with no reservations required. Call 702-0200.
Watson, Edward Ray (verified) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published December 11, 2011
Killing Places:
A Choice For Women
6660 South West 117th Avenue
Miami, FL 33183
YOB: 1957
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Jackson Memorial Hospital, Miami; Jackson North Medical Center, North Miami Beach
Bio from A Choice for Women website
Dr. Watson has been practicing medicine for over 20 years. He is board certified in obstetrics and gynecology from the American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology. He also completed a fellowship in diagnostic obstetrical- gynecological ultrasound. He has a close relationship with the University of Miami and the South Florida medical community. He has been providing terminations for his entire professional career. He is well respected and receives many doctor referrals. Dr. Watson is co-founder and Medical Director of A Choice for Women. He is also a former Medical Director for Planned Parenthood.
Accomplice: Susan Maurer, CRNA
Susan Maurer has been a certified registered nurse anesthetist for over 20 years. Prior to becoming a CRNA, she practiced as a nurse for 6 years. She has experience in anesthesia for open-heart surgery, major vascular surgeries, major cosmetic surgeries, and gynecological surgeries. She is an active member of the American Association of Nurse Anesthetists. She is co-founder of A Choice for Women.
Vergara, Natali (owner, administrator) – Hialeah, Miramar
By Jay Rogers
Published December 11, 2011
Killing Places:
A Gyn Diagnostic Center
267 East 49th Street
Hialeah, FL 33013-1854
Miramar Woman Center
6161 Miramar Parkway
Miramar, FL 33023-3939
Home:
DOB: March 1964
Dead Baby Found In Abortion Clinic, Clinic Closed
St. Petersburg Times article dated December 25, 2004:
After Siomara Senises lost her Miramar Administrative license, Vice President & Treasurer Belkis Gonzalez helped to reopen and continue managing the Miramar clinic. Natali Vergara who moved in to the address of 19100 SW 24th St, a home in Miramar owned by Frantz Bazile, is now the current legal administrator of the Miramar clinic. Gonzalez, Bazile and Senises help Vergara to manage the Miramar facility. Belkis Gonzalez also lives at the same 19100 SW 24th St address and home of Frantz Bazile, along with Natalie Vergara.
Van Scriver, Kimberly Pauline (verified) – Jacksonville
By Jay Rogers
Published December 11, 2011
Killing Places:
A Woman’s Choice of Jacksonville
4131 University Blvd S
Building 2
Jacksonville, FL 32216
Office:
A Place For Women
6817 Southpoint Pkwy # 2204
Jacksonville, FL 32216-8200

YOB: July 1965
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Memorial Hospital; St Luke’s Hospital; Florida Hospital, Jacksonville
Stockman, Cynthia D. (owner) – Fort Lauderdale
By Jay Rogers
Published December 11, 2011
Killing Places:
Aastra Women’s Center
10 Southwest 44th Avenue
Plantation, FL 33317-3758
Home:
1740 NE 9th St
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33304
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: December 1956
Aastra Women’s Center is owned by Capri Health Care, incorporated by Richard T Stockman and Cynthia D Stockman.
Stockman, Richard T. (owner) – Fort Lauderdale
By Jay Rogers
Published December 10, 2011
Killing Place:
Aastra Women’s Center
10 Southwest 44th Avenue
Plantation, FL 33317-3758
Home:
1740 NE 9th St
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33304
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: March 1959
Aastra Women’s Center is owned by Capri Health Care, incorporated by Richard T Stockman and Cynthia D Stockman.
Spence, Mark R (verified) – Hialeah
By Jay Rogers
Published December 10, 2011
Killing Place:
A Woman’s Choice
6406 Northwest 186th Street
Hialeah, FL 33015-6006
Advance Woman’s Care Center
2742 SW 8th St # 20
Miami, FL 33135-4635
Office:
Full Circle Health Care, Inc.
1190 NW 95th St # 306
Miami, FL 33150-2066
Home:
2904 NW 33rd Terrace
Lauderdale Lakes, FL 33311
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
North Shore Medical Center, Miami; Jackson North Medical Center, Miami; and Hialeah Hospital.
Sibley, Paul Leslie (verified, deceased) – Gainesville
By Jay Rogers
Published December 10, 2011
Killing Places:
All Women’s Health Center
1135 NW 23rd Ave
Gainesville, FL 32609
All Women’s Health Center of Tampa
3330 W Kennedy Blvd
Tampa, FL 33609

DOB: 7/23/1956
Died: 12/19/2009
SSN: 267-19-7365
Signed an Amicus brief in favor of partial birth abortion, NAF vs. Ashcroft with Mary Raum of Ocala who works at Woman Care (Bread and Roses) in Gainesville.
Was sued for performing an abortion on a minor without her parents’ consent.
SC04-1398 Scofield vs. Sibley, M.D. – Jurisdictional Initial Brief – filed 08/23/04
SC04-1398 Scofield vs. Sibley, M.D. – Jurisdictional Answer Brief – filed 09/01/04
Option B – Article about a girl who had an abortion at Sibley’s clinic from a University of Florida newspaper.
You can leave a “memorial message” for this killer on the following obituary page or at several other Florida newspapers.
Paul L. Sibley, M.D. died at the age of 53, on December 19, 2009. He was born and raised in Daytona Beach, Florida. He was a 22 year resident of Ocala, Florida where he resided at the time of his death. He succumbed to complications of a stroke. Paul graduated from Seabreeze High School, Daytona Beach, Florida in 1974, FSU 1978 and Meharry Medical College 1982. He completed his OB/GYN residency at University of Florida in 1986. He had been a Daytona Beach News Journal paperboy with his brothers for 8 years as a teenager and was employed at All Women’s Health Center for 21 years as a surgeon and gynecologist. Paul’s hobbies and interests included power boating, hunting and marlin fishing. He was an avid, life-long NASCAR, FSU and NFL fan and loved thrift stores but especially enjoyed spending time with friends and family, fishing and boating. Paul was a lifetime member of the AMA, the Florida Medical Association and a life-long member of the Billfish Association.
Senises, Siomara (owner) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published December 10, 2011
Killing Place:
A Woman’s Care, Inc.
68 NE 167th St, Ste A
Miami, FL 33162
A Woman’s Care, Inc. was incorporated by Siomara Senises and Maria Peguero on April 30, 1989 in the state of Florida and is currently an active corporation.
Siomara Senises represents A Woman’s Care, Inc. as their registered agent.
Maria Peguero is the founder of A Woman’s Care II, Inc. and Hialeah Woman’s Choice Clinic, Inc.
Siomara Senises was also the administrator of Best Care Woman’s Center, an abortion clinic that used three unlicensed people to perform abortions.
Clinic’s two owners arrested
Miami Herald Tues, July 19, 2005
By Mary Ellen Klas, Herald Editor
A Miami clinic lost its license and it’s owners were arrested in the second case involving the same unlicensed doctor performing abortions.
Jose Rodriguez, 52, and Magaly Gil, 56, both of Miami, were arrested and released on $5,000 bond after detectives concluded that they knew Kieron Nisbet was not licensed to practice medicine in Florida, Nisbet is alleged to have performed abortions in November at their clinic, Best Care Woman’s Center, 8380 SW Eighth Street.
Sgt Llevat of Miami-Dade unlicensed practitioner’s unit (305-477-1616) says that Gil and Rodriguez were arrested for “aiding & abetting.” When asked if administrator Siomara Senises could be charged for the same offense, Sgt Llevat said yes, “it’s in the Florida Statutes and Senises used 3 unlicensed people at her clinic also.”
Senises was never charged and is still the administrator for three abortion clinics in Florida, these two in Hialeah & another in North Miami, named , “A Woman’s Care”.
If clinic administrator, Senises was licensed as a Real Estate Broker and she hired an unlicensed abortionist, a cleaning lady, and a University of Miami student to sell Real Estate without a license, would the State of Florida allow Senises to keep her Real Estate brokers license to conduct future sales, and oversee sales people in other Real Estate offices?
The former attorney-unlicensed abortionist-Robelto Osborne was convicted of 4 felony counts of practicing medicine without a license in October of 2005.
The current abortionist-Frantz Bazile, who performed the abortion that resulted in the baby dying in the hialeah clinic, has a prior record for the same type of offense in Illinois.
Summing up the details below it basically states that this MDespicable abortionist, Frantz Bazile, had been noted for attempting to perform an abortion on a 17 Year old girl, but didn’t realize how far along she was either. He ripped spongy material (mature placenta) from the baby’s body, sutured up the profusely bleeding young mom, and rushed her off to the hospital. As the mom was drugged for pain, the baby, torn apart by the whole experience, hung for life, was delivered alive by cesarean section and later died from this “gross & negligent” quack alley abortion.
Several unlicensed abortionists found in Miami
In stories related to the use of unlicensed doctors performing abortions in Miami (Miami Herald, “Two owners arrested in abortion clinic probe,” July 19, 2005 and NBC 6 TV’s, “Man Accused Of Performing Abortions Without License,” May 5, 2005) it was revealed that Kieron Nisbet has been accused of giving anesthesia without a license to abortion patients at, A GYN Diagnostic Center abortion clinic in Miramar.
During the investigation of the clinic detectives concluded that Nisbet was not licensed to practice medicine in Florida.
Since then, two patients have come forward and claimed that Nisbet performed abortions on them at the Best Care Women Center in Miami.
The patients, who identified Nisbet in a photo line-up, said they received treatment from both Nisbet and also Yaqueline Martinez, who was arrested in March on suspicion of practicing nursing without a license.
“This person spoke to them, conducted a sonogram exam and, in one case, diagnosed a person, telling them how many weeks pregnant they were and then led them to a room where they were introduced to Mr. Nisbet as the doctor who would be performing the procedure,” Sgt. Hector Llevat of the Miami-Dade police said.
As if to cover their trail, police said, Nisbet or Martinez forged the signature of a real doctor on the patients’ files. Police arrested the clinic owners whom they claimed knew the man was operating without a valid medical license.
Police said they believe Nisbet also illegally performed abortions at a Hialeah abortion clinic, A Women’s Care II, during the same time and has fled to Trinidad to escape an arrest warrant they obtained for him.
Nisbet was investigated by the Unlicensed Practitioner Unit (UPU) and is wanted by the Miami-Dade Police Department (MDPD) for practicing medicine without a license at the Best Care Women’s Center, in Miami.
The investigation dates back to November 2004. A Miami detective said they have now received solid information that the doctor is hiding out in Trinidad with family. They believe that he is also performing abortions in Trinidad, possibly under a false name.
In 2005, The Florida Department of Health’s (DOH) Unlicensed Activity (ULA) Unit announced that their joint investigation with the Miami-Dade Police Department led to the arrest of Jose Rodriguez and Magaly Gil for aiding and abetting the unlicensed practice of medicine.
Rodriguez and Gil own Best Care Women’s Center located at 8380 SW 8 th St. in Miami. Both voluntarily relinquished the abortion clinic license for the women’s center after allegations surfaced that Rodriguez and Gil allowed unlicensed physicians to perform pregnancy termination procedures at Best Care. The pair were owners of several abortion clinics in the Miami-Dade area.
Kieron Nisbet
Sanchez Jr., Joe (deceased) – Lakeland
By Jay Rogers
Published December 9, 2011
Killing Place
Lakeland Women’s Health Center
4444 South Florida Avenue
Lakeland, FL 33813
Home:
4039 Cheverly Drive E
Lakeland, FL 33813-1208
Address is less than a half mile from 4444 S. Florida Ave (Lakeland Women’s Health Center)
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Born: January 11, 1934
Died: September 28, 2011
Joe Sanchez was an abortionist for Gary Dresden at Lakeland Women’s Health Center. He is now a believer in Jesus Christ. “For it is written, As I live, saith the Lord, every knee shall bow to me, and every tongue shall confess to God” (Romans 14:11).
Obituary
Lakeland: Dr. Joe Sanchez Jr., 77, of Lakeland, died September 28, 2011 from a stroke. Joe was born on January 11, 1934 in Tampa Florida. He was an avid Gator fan and loved corvettes. He is survived by his wife Patricia Sanchez; 4 sons David Sanchez (Bev); Michael Sanchez (Michelle); Steve Sanchez (Theresa) and Scott Sanchez; daughter Deborah Monaghen (Joe); 4 grandchildren; Robert, Spencer, Tanner, and Ashley. A memorial service will be held at a later date.
Speaks Spanish
Discipline on file.
Roth, Harvey Craig (verified) – Boca Raton
By Jay Rogers
Published December 7, 2011
Killing Places:
Planned Parenthood: Pembroke Pines Health Center
263 North University Drive
Pembroke Pines, FL 33024
A Gyn Diagnostic Center
267 East 49th Street
Hialeah, FL 33013-1854
Fort Lauderdale Women’s Center
2001 West Oakland Park Boulevard
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33311-1521
Office:
20423 State Road 7
F6-199
Boca Raton, FL 33498
Home:
9593 Parkview Avenue
Boca Raton, FL 33428-2918
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: c 1966
Planned Parenthood circuit rider. Also works for James Pendergraft in Fort Lauderdale.
Rosenthal, Vladimir (verified, owner) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published December 7, 2011
Killing Places:
Today’s Women Medical Center
3250 South Dixie Highway
Miami, FL 33133
A Eve’s Clinic and Referral Service
3900 Northwest 79th Avenue #575
Miami, FL 33166
Eve of Kendall
8603 S Dixie Highway Ste 102
Miami FL 33143
Home:
80 Palm Ave
Miami Beach, FL 33139
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Born in Chelyabinsk, Russia. Vladimir Rosenthal is the husband of Mira Rosenthal. “A Eve” maybe reference to Mira’s first name. They are Russian Jews who likely fled Soviet anti-Semitic policy. Also listed as “Vlad Van Rosenthal.”
YOB: June 1951
Speaks: Creole, Spanish, Russian
A Doctor’s Office for Women North, Inc.
A Medical Office for Women, Inc.
Doctor’s Office for Women, Inc.
Rosenthal Builders, Inc.
Rosenthal, Inc.
Rosenthal Leasing, Inc.
Vladimir Rosenthal, M.D., P.A.
Clinic employees fired for reporting abortionist
In 1990, the Miami Herald interviewed former employees of the South Florida Today’s Women’s Medical Center abortion clinic.
The employees told the newspaper that they were fired when clinic owner Vladimar Rosenthal heard that they were on the phone complaining to the National Abortion Federation (NAF) about the conditions at the clinic. Rosenthal’s clinic was reportedly a member of NAF at the time.
Employees told the Herald that Vladimir, the owner (a male doctor) and Hill, the male nurse anesthetist were often alone with the female patients. When the state inspected the clinic they found several revealing photographs of females in the possession of the male nurse at the clinic.
The Florida Medical Board passed a disciplinary action against male abortion clinic nurse Barry A. Hill, who was employed at the Today’s Woman Medical Center, a South Florida abortion clinic chain owned by abortionist Dr. Vladimar Rosenthal. On October 26, 1989 Florida’s Department of Health and Human Services inspector Diane Robie discovered two envelopes in the abortion clinic containing pictures of several women undressed with their legs apart. According to State Medical Board reports the perineal area was the focal point of the photographer. Hill, the abortion clinic’s anesthetist, claimed ownership of the photographs.
Former employees of the abortion clinic spoke to the Miami Herald where they stated they saw Hill fondling the breasts of several female patients while they were under anesthesia.
Employee, Denise Fong Choy told the Florida Department of Professional Regulations (case # 89-010853) investigators that she was hired as a counselor at the South Dixie Highway clinic. She said she was fired after one and a half years of employment after becoming very concerned about the liabilities for doing certain procedures without licensed personnel in attendance.
She called the National Abortion Federation and was overheard by someone at the clinic. She claims that when Rosenthal found out about the call, he fired her.
Neat Rodriguez was also an employee of Rosenthal’s at the Today’s Women abortion clinic. She was NOT a high school graduate and had been hired by Rosenthal to in her words, “do everything” at the clinic.
She was also overheard complaining to the National Abortion Federation about Rosenthal and she claims that is why he fired her as well.
Rosenthal, Evelina Mira (owner) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published December 7, 2011
Killing Places:
Today’s Women Medical Center
3250 South Dixie Highway
Miami, FL 33133
A Eve’s Clinic and Referral Service
3900 Northwest 79th Avenue #575
Miami, FL 33166
Eve of Kendall
8603 S Dixie Highway Ste 102
Miami FL 33143
Home:
80 Palm Ave
Miami Beach, FL 33139
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Born in Chelyabinsk, Russia. Married to Vlad Van Rosenthal (or Vladimir Rosenthal). They are Russian Jews who likely fled Soviet anti-Semitic policy. Also listed as Mira Rosental. “A Eve” maybe reference to Mira’s first name.
YOB: September 1951
Speaks: Creole, Spanish, Russian, French
A Doctor’s Office for Women North, Inc.
A Medical Office for Women, Inc.
Doctor’s Office for Women, Inc.
Rosenthal Builders, Inc.
Rosenthal, Inc.
Rosenthal Leasing, Inc.
Vladimir Rosenthal, M.D., P.A.
Rodriguez, Jose (former owner, watchlist) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published December 6, 2011
Killing Place:
Best Care Woman’s Center (closed!)
8380 SW 8th Street
Miami, FL 33144
YOB: c. 1950
Miami: The legalized back-alley abortion capital
Police arrested Best Care’s owners, Magaly Gil and Jose Rodriguez. They turned in their license for that mill, and all was forgiven. But Gil still owns and operates two other Miami area abortion mills, Millennium Women Center and Hialeah Women’s Center
Clinic’s two owners arrested
Miami Herald Tues, July 19, 2005
By Mary Ellen Klas, Herald Editor
A Miami clinic lost its license and it’s owners were arrested in the second case involving the same unlicensed doctor performing abortions.
Jose Rodriguez, 52, and Magaly Gil, 56, both of Miami, were arrested and released on $5,000 bond after detectives concluded that they knew Kieron Nisbet was not licensed to practice medicine in Florida, Nisbet is alleged to have performed abortions in November at their clinic, Best Care Woman’s Center, 8380 SW Eighth Street.
Sgt Llevat of Miami-Dade unlicensed practitioner’s unit (305-477-1616) says that Gil and Rodriguez were arrested for “aiding & abetting.” When asked if administrator Siomara Senises could be charged for the same offense, Sgt Llevat said yes, “it’s in the Florida Statutes and Senises used 3 unlicensed people at her clinic also.”
Senises was never charged and is still the administrator for three abortion clinics in Florida, these two in Hialeah & another in North Miami, named, “A Woman’s Care”.
If clinic administrator, Senises was licensed as a Real Estate Broker and she hired an unlicensed abortionist, a cleaning lady, and a University of Miami student to sell Real Estate without a license, would the State of Florida allow Senises to keep her Real Estate brokers license to conduct future sales, and oversee sales people in other Real Estate offices?
The former attorney-unlicensed abortionist-Robelto Osborne was convicted of 4 felony counts of practicing medicine without a license in October of 2005.
The current abortionist-Frantz Bazile, who performed the abortion that resulted in the baby dying in the hialeah clinic, has a prior record for the same type of offense in Illinois.
Summing up the details below it basically states that this MDespicable abortionist, Frantz Bazile, had been noted for attempting to perform an abortion on a 17 Year old girl, but didn’t realize how far along she was either. He ripped spongy material (mature placenta) from the baby’s body, sutured up the profusely bleeding young mom, and rushed her off to the hospital. As the mom was drugged for pain, the baby, torn apart by the whole experience, hung for life, was delivered alive by cesarean section and later died from this “gross & negligent” quack alley abortion.
Several unlicensed abortionists found in Miami
In stories related to the use of unlicensed doctors performing abortions in Miami (Miami Herald, “Two owners arrested in abortion clinic probe,” July 19, 2005 and NBC 6 TV’s, “Man Accused Of Performing Abortions Without License,” May 5, 2005) it was revealed that Kieron Nisbet has been accused of giving anesthesia without a license to abortion patients at, A GYN Diagnostic Center abortion clinic in Miramar.
During the investigation of the clinic detectives concluded that Nisbet was not licensed to practice medicine in Florida.
Since then, two patients have come forward and claimed that Nisbet performed abortions on them at the Best Care Women Center in Miami.
The patients, who identified Nisbet in a photo line-up, said they received treatment from both Nisbet and also Yaqueline Martinez, who was arrested in March on suspicion of practicing nursing without a license.
“This person spoke to them, conducted a sonogram exam and, in one case, diagnosed a person, telling them how many weeks pregnant they were and then led them to a room where they were introduced to Mr. Nisbet as the doctor who would be performing the procedure,” Sgt. Hector Llevat of the Miami-Dade police said.
As if to cover their trail, police said, Nisbet or Martinez forged the signature of a real doctor on the patients’ files. Police arrested the clinic owners whom they claimed knew the man was operating without a valid medical license.
Police said they believe Nisbet also illegally performed abortions at a Hialeah abortion clinic, A Women’s Care II, during the same time and has fled to Trinidad to escape an arrest warrant they obtained for him.
Nisbet was investigated by the Unlicensed Practitioner Unit (UPU) and is wanted by the Miami-Dade Police Department (MDPD) for practicing medicine without a license at the Best Care Women’s Center, in Miami.
The investigation dates back to November 2004. A Miami detective said they have now received solid information that the doctor is hiding out in Trinidad with family. They believe that he is also performing abortions in Trinidad, possibly under a false name.
In 2005, The Florida Department of Health’s (DOH) Unlicensed Activity (ULA) Unit announced that their joint investigation with the Miami-Dade Police Department led to the arrest of Jose Rodriguez and Magaly Gil for aiding and abetting the unlicensed practice of medicine.
Rodriguez and Gil own Best Care Women’s Center located at 8380 SW 8 th St. in Miami. Both voluntarily relinquished the abortion clinic license for the women’s center after allegations surfaced that Rodriguez and Gil allowed unlicensed physicians to perform pregnancy termination procedures at Best Care. The pair were owners of several abortion clinics in the Miami-Dade area.
Kieron Nisbet
Rodriguez, Frank (verified) – West Palm Beach
By Jay Rogers
Published December 6, 2011
Killing Place:
Presidential Women’s Center
100 North Pointe Parkway
West Palm Beach, FL 33407
Office:
560 Village Blvd, Suite 200
West Palm Beach, FL 33409-1963
Home:
1005 Bear Island Dr.
West Palm Beach, FL 33409
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
St Mary’s Hospital; Good Samaritan Hospital West Palm Beach

DOB: 11/26/1961
Misc.: Works part-time at Presidential Women’s Center abortion clinic in West Palm Beach, FL. Drives a White Lexus/Single/No Children/Live-in girlfriend
Accomplices: Mona Reis, owner of Presidential Women’s Center
Closed Malpractice Claims:
8/20/96 – Uterus perforation during an abortion at Presidential Women’s Center – Settled for $100,000
8/20/95 – Same case as above also filed with the insurance company of Rodriguez for an additional $20,000
10/8/92 – Birth of a child with hydrocephalus meningeal myelocele who then died. Settled for $350,000
Commemorating her baby’s abortion
by Jill Stanek
Yesterday Susan e-mailed me:
My baby was aborted on this day years ago. I am unable to think of a better way to spend today other than attempting to end the slaughter.
Susan picketed the medical office of abortionist Frank Rodriguez in Palm Beach, FL with her friend Marilyn, below.

Many moms who have aborted feel getting involved in the abortion movement would be hypocritical. Susan demonstrates the opposite is true. She is now standing in the gap for babies, which is so helpful to the cause. How many people learned yesterday that Rodriguez is a baby killer thanks to Susan and Marilyn? Doing nothing, particularly when you personally know abortion hurts children and mothers, only helps the other side.
Abortion-clinic blaze called ‘terrorism’
Police investigating but pro-lifers immediately suspected
July 07, 2005, WND
An abortion clinic that draws patients from all over Florida and beyond has closed after an Independence Day fire labeled by the group as an “act of terrorism.”
The fire late Monday night at the Presidential Women’s Center in West Palm Beach sent flames through the roof of the building. The incident was almost one year to the day after an arsonist set ablaze another women’s center in Lake Worth, Fla., which remains closed, the Palm Beach Post reported.
Investigators said it’s too early to comment on the cause of Monday’s fire, though they have found evidence of a fire accelerant at the scene.
But the clinic has come to a quick conclusion.
“It was an act of terrorism, an act of arson that did a great deal of damage,” said Lou Silber, the center’s attorney. “This is not going to close us down. We are going to open up as soon as possible and provide women medical services.”
The case has been turned over to the federal Bureau for Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, he said.
The leader of a local pro-life group says abortion protesters undoubtedly will be blamed.
“It is tragic that it happened,” said Frances Fitzgerald, president of the Palm Beach County Right to Life League. “You don’t take care of violence with more violence.”
Fitzgerald said the pro-life supports who regularly gather outside the clinic come to pray and “help women, not cause violence.”
The Post noted the clinic’s status as one of the few — and more recently the only — women’s clinic where abortions are performed in the county has fueled constant protests.
Frank Rodriguez, an OB/GYN, said patients are referred to the clinic from far and wide. “People come from out of state and out of the country to that place because they provide a lot of decent care,” he said.
The Palm Beach County Right to Life League and other groups, including local FACE Life, bring people Saturdays to counsel women on the sidewalks.
The Rev. Joe Papes, spiritual moderator for Respect Life, says the pro-lifers are not protesters.
“We don’t endorse any kind of violence,” he said. “There has never been any type of brouhaha or melee.”
Susan Pine, president of FACE Life, told the Post she sometimes stands apart from the crowd to hand out fliers or offer advice.
Pine’s group issued a news release June 23 reporting that a WomanCare abortion clinic in West Palm Beach was evicted from its building.
Pine said it was her understanding that WomanCare misrepresented itself to the property owner in order to secure the location.
“Although WomanCare is an abortion center, they made no statements to the fact that they perform abortions,” Pine said.
In response to that closure, and to another WomanCare clinic shut down in Cocoa, Fla., Pine stated: “We are thrilled that there are two less facilities in our beautiful state that are focused on the destruction of innocent human life, that exploit women in dire and unusual circumstances, and that rob men of their fatherhood.”
Renelique, Pierre Jean-Jacques (watchlist, revoked) - Hialeah
By Jay Rogers
Published December 4, 2011
Killing Places:
Advanced GYN Clinic
6464 N Miami Ave
Miami, FL 33150-4520
Alba Medical Center
4210 Palm Avenue
Hialeah, FL 33012-4454
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: New York.
This abortionist had his license revoked and is the subject of numerous news reports.
March 1946
From Haiti, also has ties to New York and Chicago. He fled to New York where his license was also suspended and later reinstated.
6860 Austin St Ste 202
Forest Hills, NY 11375
JHMC DTC Corp
13303 Jamaica Ave
Richmond Hill, NY 11418
(718) 657-7093
Discipline records are on file.
Pierre Renelique: Hialeah abortion doctor on the run!
I especially like the part in this video report where the abortionist starts running from the reporter even while he continues giving the interview. Finally, not being able to keep from incriminating himself by running his mouth even while he is literally on the run, he does the logical thing and attacks the microphone.
The irony is that this is essentially what we tried to do in the 1990s with Jay’s Killer Web Page, to expose abortionists’ evil deeds to the public. Of course, we were sued (unsuccessfully) and labelled terrorists for giving out much the same information on our website that you could find in the White and Yellow Pages. That was back in the days prior to Fox News.
MYFOXNY.COM – The case made national headlines: A botched abortion in Florida and an elaborate cover-up. The physician involved — Dr. Pierre Renelique — was banned from practicing medicine there. But nine months after Florida revoked his license, he is seeing patients in the Bronx. Fox 5’s Arnold Diaz tracked him down for an exclusive report.
WARNING: Some information in this report is graphic.
MORE INFORMATION ON DR. PIERRE JEAN JACQUES RENELIQUE:
• NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH DECISION
• FLORIDA BOARD OF MEDICINE
View MyFox Tampa Bay’s February 6, 2009, report on Dr. Renelique’s Florida license revocation hearing:
Pro-Lifers Rally Against Bronx Doctor
Bronx News Network
Tuesday, December 29, 2009
Dr. Pierre Renelique used to practice obstetrics and gynecology in Florida. That was until the Florida Board of Medicine revoked his license early this year following a botched abortion. Now he’s working at Clinton Place Medical Center in University Heights, to the horror of the local pro-life movement.
Two Saturdays ago, about 80 people, including State Sen. Ruben Diaz, Sr. and his wife, Leslie, held a prayer vigil near the center, to bring attention to Renelique’s past, and to demand action from the New York State Medical Board.
“We want to expose this clinic across the street and we want to expose the doctor,” Leslie Diaz told the crowd.
“Apparently Dr. Renelique is not good enough for Florida but he is found good enough for the women of the Bronx,” said Father Peter West of Priests for Life, a national pro-life organization.
Renelique was found guilty last February of medical malpractice, after he failed to show up for a late-term abortion in July 2006. The mother went into labor (because of drugs given to her by Renelique the day before) and unlicensed staff delivered a live baby girl, according to news reports. The baby was stuffed into a plastic bag and left to die. Police found her body a week later.
Renelique moved to New York earlier this year, and began working at Clinton Place Medical Center, at 8 Clinton Place, just west of Jerome Avenue. In November he was tracked down by Fox 5’s Arnold Diaz, for one of Diaz’s “Shame, Shame, Shame” reports. In the video clip, Diaz (no relation to the senator or his wife) is shown chasing Renelique down the street, peppering him with questions, before Renelique bats the mic out of his hand.
The vigil was organized by Advocates for Life, a Yonkers-based group, and many of the speakers spoke out against abortion and pro-choice groups, in addition to criticizing Renelique.
“A baby is a baby no matter how small it is,” said Ana Sosa, a 19-year-old local resident, and a member of In His Image, a youth group at St. Nicholas of Tolentine Church on University Avenue.
Abortion is “genocide,” said Sosa, rosary beads wrapped tightly around her wrist.
“They are murderers!” said Senator Diaz, pointing at Clinton Place Medical Center across the street, which was shut that day. (Diaz, a Bronx Democrat and Pentecostal minister who typically leans right on social issues, is an ardent pro-life supporter. In the past he’s called abortion “the American holocaust.”)
Diaz’s words aside, it’s unclear whether Renelique and his colleagues actually perform abortions. A woman who answered the phone there last week said they didn’t; Renelique himself didn’t return a call seeking comment.
Regardless, the fact that Renelique is here in the Bronx, and still practicing medicine, gave the crowd reason to pray and protest.
“Enough is enough! Enough is enough!” they shouted in unison.
Waterman II, Philip F. (verified) – Naples, Fort Myers
By Jay Rogers
Published November 29, 2011
Killing Places:
Planned Parenthood of Collier County
1425 Creech Road
Naples, FL 34103
Planned Parenthood: Fort Myers Health Center
8595 College Parkway, Suite 250
Fort Myers, FL 33919
Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando
726 S Tampa Ave
Orlando, FL 32805
Office:
Dr. Philip Waterman FACOG
650 Del Prado Blvd
Cape Coral, FL 33990
Home:
904 Robala Drive
Fort Myers, FL 33919
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: March 1948
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure:
Michigan, New York, Vermont
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Lee Memorial Hospital; Healthpark Lee Memorial Hospital, Fort Myers;
Cape Coral Hospital, Cape Coral
Philip Waterman is a circuit rider abortionist for Planned Parenthood of Collier County, Planned Parenthood of Southwest and Central Florida and Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando. Known schedule as of January 2012: Monday Naples, Thursday Fort Myers, Saturday Orlando (other days in Tampa and Sarasota).
Pro-life picket of Planned Parenthood abortionist Philip F. Waterman’s residence – 1/8/2012
The pro-life community of Naples and Fort Myers, Florida once again visited Waterman’s neighborhood on Sunday, January 8, 2012.
Jim Finegan told the story of how residential pickets began in southwest Florida.
“There are a lot of God-fearing northern snow birds wintering in Florida and we look forward to joining with these fine youths, the future leaders of the pro-life movement, in making Waterman and his neighbors uncomfortable.”
Terese Flanigan told us about recent efforts at the abortion mills and Waterman’s home including a story about Waterman trying to run her down with his Ford town car.
“I was hoping he’d hit he. Then he’d find himself in a lawsuit,” she said.
Residential awareness campaigns in abortionists’ neighborhoods have resulted in a number of them quitting their blood trade. Recent “retirees” have reportedly included Wallace W. Mclean in Naples and Vera Stefanac in Orlando.
Pro-life protest in front of abortionist Philip Waterman’s home, Ft. Myers, FL 3/21/2010
WINK News broadcast March 21, 2010. This was the first pro-life protest in front of the home of abortionist Philip Waterman of Ft. Myers, FL, who aborts at the Planned Parenthood in Naples, FL. Protests are held every 6-7 months.
See the event page
Chapter 37: Picket An Abortionist’s Neighborhood

By Jim Finnegan
Pro-Lifers picket abortionist Vinod Goyal's swanky neighborhood in Inverness, Illinois. [Photos by Dan Gura]
In Chapter 37 of Joe Scheidler’s landmark book, CLOSED: 99 Ways to Stop Abortion, pro-life activists are encouraged to picket the abortionists’ homes:
We go to the neighborhoods of abortionists…because they do not like it. They usually are not proud of being abortionists, and often they even guard from their community the fact that they are involved in abortion. If it were widely known that they are abortionists, they might be very uncomfortable in their communities, and their communities might be uncomfortable with them.
I saw this take place firsthand when we used to picket the entrance to the exclusive Inverness subdivision where abortionist Vinod Goyal lives. To say his neighbors were uncomfortable would be an understatement.

Left: Abortionist Philip Waterman at Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando
Picket To Begin In Florida
And now four of the bright yellow warning signs which we held are on their way to Florida to educate another community of the threat that lies in their midst.
Ten years ago Naples, the crown jewel of southern Florida, had a stain on its pristine white sands. Abortionist Wallace McLean had moved into the community and was financing his beautiful home, located in an exclusive complex near the ocean, by spilling the blood of pre-born babies.
Though the Naples Pro Life Council picketed his office on a regular basis, McLean continued to ply his trade with impunity.
Just One Picket
Coming from Chicago, I was aware of the effectiveness, and legality, of picketing abortionist’s homes. I also knew the unstoppable power of prayer.
We witnessed for life in front of his home just once but it was enough to plant the seeds of discomfort in McLean’s neighbors. They learned the truth about how the affable doctor made his living; he had betrayed his oath to heal, choosing instead to violently end the lives of innocent babies.
Within days the entire city learned the truth thanks to media coverage of the prayerful picket.
A few days after our picket McLean’s spokesperson called the President of the Naples Pro Life Council to say the doctor had gotten the message; he would no longer engage in the killing of the unborn.
New Naples Abortionist
Sadly, last September Planned Parenthood announced they would again be spilling the blood of the pre-born in Naples once again. They had hired Philip Waterman, “a circuit abortionist” who lives in Coral Gables, north of Fort Myers, to kill pre-born babies every Monday in Naples.

There has been a pro-life presence in front of the Planned Parenthood every day he plies his grisly trade. In addition, the diocese of Venice has a Forty Days for Life prayer vigil ongoing in Naples at this time.
Student Leads The Effort
Last Saturday, a student from Ave Maria University announced he was organizing a picket of Waterman’s house in Coral Gables. I can’t tell you how proud I am of this young man, and the adult sponsor, a lawyer, who encouraged the students to organize this effort.
I look forward to the date being set within the first few weeks of March and anticipate a large participation from the students and residents of Naples, Fort Myers, and Coral Gables. Once the details are set I will have them posted on the Pro-Life Action League’s blog.
There are a lot of God-fearing northern snow birds wintering in Florida and we look forward to joining with these fine youths, the future leaders of the pro-life movement, in making Waterman and his neighbors uncomfortable.
Please pray for the success of this effort.
Naples, Florida Planned Parenthood Patient Rushed to Hospital
By Kathleen Gilbert
NAPLES, Florida, May 26, 2010 (LifeSiteNews.com) – A possible botched-abortion victim had to be transported from a Naples abortion clinic by ambulance on Monday, as abortion clinic workers blocked the patient from view with a black tarp, reported the Naples Daily News.
The regular crowd of pro-life witnesses watched in dismay as the victim, a patient at Planned Parenthood of Collier County, was transported to an area hospital in the early afternoon hours. Photographs submitted to the local newspaper show abortion clinic workers holding up a black tarp to block view of the victim entering the ambulance.
Abortionist Philip Waterman of Cape Coral only performs abortions at the Naples clinic on Mondays.
Char Wendel, president and chief executive officer of Planned Parenthood, declined to say whether the patient was the victim of a botched abortion, telling the Daily News only that “we are a medical facility and we respond to emergencies.”
Pro-lifer Fred Goduti told the newspaper that the ambulance call was the first since the clinic began performing abortions on Sept. 14 of last year. Prior to that, the Pro-Life Action league reports that Naples had been abortion-free for over a decade, after pro-lifers pressured the abortionist Wallace McLean to quit by picketing his home.
“We were praying this would not happen,” Goduti said. “It is inevitable it would happen.”
The dissemination of the story, which was picked up by Fox News, shows a shift in how the media handles such stories, said Operation Rescue president Troy Newman. “Not that long ago, no news outlet would have touched this story,” said Newman.
Newman commented on the “sheets of shame” Planned Parenthood employees used to hide the victim from view, which he said “could not keep the truth from getting out that their organization endangers the lives of women when it takes the lives of pre-born babies.”
“For many years we have tried to get the media to cover documented cases of ambulances transporting injured women from abortion clinics. Now it is finally happening. This exposure could eventually help close this clinic, and others like it, out of concern for public safety,” he added, urging witnesses to file a complaint with the state medical board.
Ambulance at Planned Parenthood



(Photos by Fred Goduti)
A patient at Planned Parenthood of Collier County was transported by ambulance today from the clinic on Creech Road to an area hospital, according to emergency medical personnel. The ambulance arrived at 12:50 p.m. and left with a patient on board a few minutes later, while a dozen abortion opponents were protesting on the sidewalk nearby. The clinic performs abortions only on Mondays.
Ravi, Himagiri G. (verified) – Lakeland
By Jay Rogers
Published November 29, 2011
Office:
Polk Wellcare Corporation
6155 S Florida Ave
Suite #1 & 7
Lakeland, FL 33813-3323
Home Address:
2017 Windwood Lane
Lakeland, FL 33813
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Date of Birth: 3/1/1953
Indian; went to school in Jamaica.

Prabhakaran, Sujatha (verified) – St. Petersburg
By Jay Rogers
Published November 11, 2011
Killing Places:
Planned Parenthood: Sarasota Health Center
736 Central Avenue
Sarasota, FL 34236
Planned Parenthood: Winter Haven Health Center
908 Spring Lake Square
Winter Haven, FL 33881
Planned Parenthood: Tampa Health Center
8068 North 56th Street
Tampa, FL 33617
Planned Parenthood: Pinellas Health Center
8950 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street North, Suite 102
St. Petersburg, FL 33702
Planned Parenthood: Fort Myers Health Center
8595 College Parkway, Suite 250
Fort Myers, FL 33919
Planned Parenthood: Manatee Health Center
1105 53rd Avenue, Suite 201
Bradenton, FL 34203
Planned Parenthood: Lakeland Health Center
2250 E Edgewood Drive
Lakeland, FL 33803
Home: 770 S Palm Ave, Apt 901
Sarasota, FL 34236
DOB: June 1976
Sujatha (Suzie) Prabhakaran joined Planned Parenthood of Southwest and Central Florida in July 2009 as a full time director. She oversees seven Planned Parenthood centers including five licensed abortion centers. Additionally, she practices as gynecologic surgeon at the Bay Pines VA Medical Center and is an Affiliate Asst. Professor in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology at the University of South Florida. She states that her goal is to “work towards making abortion and reproductive health care not only less taboo in our society but an accepted part of health care.”
Radio Podcast: Two Local Doctors Discuss Obamacare
Blogger for Doctors For America
First Full-Time Medical Director Joins Affiliate
Choice Notes: Summer 2009, Volume 15, Issue 3, Planned Parenthood of Southwest and Central Florida
We are very pleased to announce that Dr. Sujatha (Suzie) Prabhakaran joined our team in July as Medical Director. In this capacity, Dr. Prabhakaran will direct the affiliate medical program, oversee seven fulltime health centers and implement medical protocols that are consistent with Planned Parenthood Federation of America’s medical standards. Dr. Prabhakaran grew up in Toledo, Ohio, where she was surrounded by doctors (both of her parents and several uncles are physicians). She got her undergraduate degree in biology at the University of Toledo and her medical degree from the Medical College of Ohio. She obtained a master of public health degree from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and this year completed a fellowship at the University of North Carolina, where she did research on women’s health issues. Dr. Prabhakaran is licensed to practice medicine in North Carolina and Florida. She is sitting for her Boards in November.
A rotation at a Planned Parenthood clinic during medical school helped convince Dr. Prabhakaran to become an OB/GYN and to be attracted to our affiliate as medical director. “I really admired Planned Parenthood’s approach to health care. It wasn’t just medical services; it included educational and policy concerns, as well. This, to me, is the sensible approach to reproductive health care.”
Her goals as Medical Director are to work towards making abortion and reproductive health care not only less taboo in our society but an accepted part of health care. She is also hoping to collaborate more with local universities in teaching and engaging medical students and residents to become Planned Parenthood providers, as well as working to include our affiliate in more research opportunities.
When Dr. Prabhakaran is not working, she loves to travel, explore other cultures, eat in really good restaurants and go to theatre, dance, and other cultural attractions.
Raum, Mary Elwin Pugh (verified) – Gainesville
By Jay Rogers
Published November 11, 2011
Killing Place:
Bread and Roses
(a.k.a. Gainesville Woman Care, LLC)
1233 NW 10th Ave
Gainesville, FL 32601
Offices:
Mary E. Raum
40 SW 12th
Ocala, FL 34471
Mary E. Raum
2845 Southeast 3rd Court
Ocala, FL 34471
Home: 21435 NE 103rd Ter
Fort McCoy, FL 32134
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: January 1945
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Munroe Regional Medical Center; Ocala Regional Medical Center; Surgery Center of Ocala
Mary Raum is a vocal pro-abortion activist who not only protested the ultra-sound bill, but also signed a friend of the court brief supporting Carhart vs. Ashcroft against a law banning partial birth abortion in 2004.
Abortion Bill Narrowly Clears Senate Panel
Orlando Sentinel, April 8, 2008
An Ocala gynecologist who performs abortions, Dr. Mary Raum, said the legislation was “aimed to intimidate women and to further limit access to abortion in Florida.”
Senate panel approves ultrasound abortion bill
By James A. Smith, Sr., Florida Baptist Witness, April 15, 2008
Mary Raum, an Ocala obstetrics and gynecology doctor who performs abortions, protested the bill as a “political and ideological effort to interfere in the doctor-patient relationship, mandating procedures not considered the standard of care and ultimately to legislate medicine.”
She added, “While the authors of this bill would simplistically say that viewing an ultrasound is going to change minds, they are insulting women by implying a woman considering abortion has not approached the decision with reflection, tears and even prayers. This bill is intended to punish, not protect these women.”
Poy-Wing, Celina (owner, verified) – Plantation
By Jay Rogers
Published November 9, 2011
Killing Place:
All Women’s Ob-Gyn Group
817 S University Dr # 100A
Plantation, FL 33324-3345
Home: 4821 SW 76th Ave, Davie, FL 33328
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: November 1952

Discipline records are on file. She apparently used a vacuum extraction on a woman delivering a baby that caused irreparable harm.
Factual Allegations
A. On or about July 22, 1993, the Board of Medicine of the State of Florida, Department of Business and Professional Regulation (“Florida Board of Medicine”) issued an administrative complaint in Case No. 91-05594 against the Respondent. The administrative complaint alleged that Respondent, an obstetrician/gynecologist, provided medical care to a patient identified as “Patient #l” on or about March 16, 1991. The administrative complaint further alleged that Respondent practiced medicine below the standard of care in that Respondent inappropriately applied a vacuum extractor without medical justification and for an excessive period of time, which resulted in multiple complications for Patient #1’s newborn. Further, the complaint alleged that Respondent’s medical record for Patient #1 failed to indicate a need for vacuum extraction.
Abortions, parties, and a botched liposuction
In an April 30, 2004 article, the Orlando Sentinel reported that two South Florida doctors (one’s a retired psychologist, the other is a working ob-gyn physician, they stated) own the Orlando nightclub Tropical Magic.
They revealed that one of the owners is a Broward County physician by the name of Dr. Celina Poy-Wing. Advertisements in the South Florida area reveal that Poy-Wing performs abortions up to 22 weeks at 817 South University Drive in Plantation, FL, describing her practice as, Women Caring for Women.
The article says that abortionist Poy-Wing described her club’s atmosphere this way, “We are trying to appeal to the whole community. No babies. We want men and women.”
The paper also made this observation about the club’s alcohol: “And for an older-crew club, the drink policy is awfully relaxed. For one, the place is open until 4 in the morning. Two, the place sells tiny bottles of alcohol until the 2 a.m. curfew — and then offers mixers for the next two hours. Which means there’s a run at the bottles before 2 a.m. It’s a strategy that keeps the party going until closing.”
See the article here: Getting Down . . . In An Upscale Way
In May of 2000, the Ft. Lauderdale Sun-Sentinel reported in a May 26 article, Victim wins award in botched liposuction, that a judge’s assistant was awarded a $1 million malpractice verdict against abortion doctor Celina Poy-Wing who reportedly botched her liposuction in 1998.
The article notes that a Broward County jury decided that the surgery by Dr. Celina Poy-Wing caused nerve damage, numbness, burning and discolored skin on the abdomen and hips of her patient, Nancy Williams.
Williams’s suit claimed that Poy-Wing took out too much fat and operated too close to the skin and blamed the poor care on the fact that Poy-Wing had just learned to do liposuction at a weekend seminar in spring 1997, according to the woman’s attorney.
Perper, Zvi Harry (verified) – Delray Beach
By Jay Rogers
Published November 8, 2011
Office:
Delray Pain Management
102 North Swinton Avenue
Delray Beach, FL 33444-2634
Home: xx
YOB: May 1961
Romanian
Abortionist Zvi Perper most recently worked as a dealer of pain pills for a controversial clinic in Miami that was founded by a convicted drug smuggler. He is currently under indictment on multiple counts of conspiracy and drug trafficking and facing up to 490 years in prison.
Harry Perper was the abortionist on duty at EPOC abortion center in Orlando when when Baby Rowan was born alive and left to die. Baby Rowan’s mother, described him as a very fast-moving, hyperactive type of person
Perper also perforated a woman’s uterus at Orlando Woman’s Center requiring a hysterectomy for which he was subject to disciplinary action.
Substandard Care, Incompetence or Negligence (2/12/08) issued to: Dr. Zvi Harry Perper; License # ME65525; DOH Case # 2004-02581
Nature of Complaint: The physician upon performing a termination of a patient’s pregnancy through dilation and curettage severely perforated the patient’s uterus and deposited materials including the fetus and placenta into the patient’s lower abdominal cavity. The patient was subsequently transferred to a medical center where another physician removed the fetus and placenta from the patient’s abdominal cavity and due to the severe perforation of the patient’s uterus performed a hysterectomy.
Patient Suffers from Abortion at Orlando Women’s Center
Court Upholds Suspension of Florida Late-Term Abortion Practitioner’s License
He is the son of Joshua Perper who performed the autopsy on Anna Nicole Smith.
Joshua Arie Perper
Broward County Medical Examiner
5301 SW 31st Avenue
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33312
Abortionist Zvi Harry Perper charged with racketeering and drug trafficking

Zvi Harry Perper has been charged with multiple counts of racketeering, drug trafficking and conspiracy. The charges carry a possible penalty of 490 years in prison.
Abortionist Zvi Harry Perper was the killer on duty at the EPOC Clinic in Orlando in 2005 when Baby Rowan was born alive and left to die. He was disciplined for performing a botched abortion in 2003 and has been under investigation for dispensing large amounts of pain killers through a “pill mill” in Delray Beach, a Fort Lauderdale suburb.
Perper is yet another abortionist who has worked at one of James Pendergraft’s chain of five late term abortion clinics in Florida who has been charged with a felony. The list now includes:
According to the Sun-Sentinel:
Among those charged with racketeering and drug trafficking in Wednesday’s pain clinic raids is Dr. Zvi Harry Perper, son of Broward Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Joshua Perper, who is among the leaders of the region’s ongoing battle with prescription drug abuse. Perper faces 18 counts, including racketeering, trafficking in oxycodone and conspiracy to traffic in oyxcodone, a potent pain killer.
Authorities say Dr. Zvi Harry Perper, 49, ranked 22nd in the nation among medical practitioners in ordering oxycodone, which he dispensed at the pain clinic where he worked, Delray Pain Management. Joshua Perper, Broward’s chief medical examiner since 1994, could not be reached for comment Wednesday.
For the past decade he has joined and, at times, led Broward officials in sounding the alarm against worsening prescription drug abuse and the thousands of deaths blamed on the phenomenon. Authorities blame part of the phenomenon on South Florida’s booming black market for pain pills, many of which are dispensed by pain clinics that accept only cash from clients in order to avoid state oversight.
Perper, 49, is of Romanian descent. Baby Rowan’s mom, who had her child aborted at 22 weeks and later came forward to testify about the conditions at Pendergraft’s EPOC Clinic in Orlando, described Perper as “a very fast-moving, hyperactive type of person.”
Perper had perforated a woman’s uterus at Orlando Woman’s Center in 2003 requiring a hysterectomy. He was subject to disciplinary action for “substandard care, incompetence or negligence” on February 12, 2008:
Nature of Complaint: The physician upon performing a termination of a patient’s pregnancy through dilation and curettage severely perforated the patient’s uterus and deposited materials including the fetus and placenta into the patient’s lower abdominal cavity. The patient was subsequently transferred to a medical center where another physician removed the fetus and placenta from the patient’s abdominal cavity and due to the severe perforation of the patient’s uterus performed a hysterectomy.
An article in the Broward Palm Beach News on May 14, 2010, exposed Perper’s pain pill clinic. According to the Palm Beach Post, the clinic was founded by convicted heroin and cocaine trafficker, Vincent Colangelo.
Broward County Medical Examiner Joshua Perper has warned us about the dangers of pain clinics. Last June, he was in the Miami Herald talking about the dangers of doctor shopping, where people go to numerous clinics to stockpile pills like oxycodone, Xanax, and Valium.
“It’s almost impossible to monitor different people shopping doctors,’‘ Perper told the newspaper. “A person can get hundreds or thousands of pills.” He went on to talk about the explosion in oxycodone-related deaths, which ballooned to 171 in Broward County in 2008, more than double the figure from 2005. In the Sun-Sentinel, he warned of how those using the pain clinics are consuming deadly cocktails of pills.
What Perper didn’t reveal was that his son, physician Zvi Harry Perper, is himself in the pain pill business. Harry Perper dispenses pain medication at a clinic on Swinton Avenue in Delray Beach called Delray Pain Management LLC. The clinic was founded in early 2009 by a convicted drug smuggler named Kenneth Murry. Harry Perper is listed as a manager of the clinic.
In yet another ironic twist, Joshua Perper was the coroner who did the autopsy report on Anna Nicole Smith, the Playboy model who died from an overdose of prescription medication, a bizarre case that has prompted numerous conspiracy theories.

DEA agent Keigh Barker, right, escorts abortionist Zvi Harry Perper, son of the Broward Medical Examiner Dr. Joshua A. Perper, to a awaiting police car after his Delray Pain Management clinic was raided by agents on February 23, 2010.
The LA Times has an good article and video of these “mafia doctors” who were arrested last week for running “pill mills” in south Florida. The article makes note of Perper’s other career as a child killer.
Perper began working at the pain clinic after he was fined $10,000 by the state in 2008 for a botched abortion in Orlando, according to state records.
The video shows the lavish lifestyle that Vincent Colangelo, the ring leader of the drug traffickers, lived for the past few years prior to finally being indicted last week. There is also a good shot of Harry Perper being led away in handcuffs at the end of the video. Colangelo became Perper’s boss in 2008.
Jacksonville’s First Coast News has a revealing video of “Pill Mill Vinny” exhibiting thuggish behavior when confronted by investigative reporters in May, 2010.
Jacksonville a Source for Illegal Prescription Drug Business, Clinics
By Jackelyn Barnard
JACKSONVILLE, FL – It’s hard to tell what’s inside the building. There’s no name on the door, no sign outside either. Moments later, a man comes out upset to find a reporter on a public street near that unmarked building.
“I’m gonna tell you what, man, you don’t get this thing out of my face, it will be part of your face,” he said.
The man refuses to give his name, but a First Coast News investigation has revealed that he is Vincent Colangelo, a convicted felon. Police said he is just one part of a growing problem in Florida.
When asked if he owned the building or was a doctor, Colangelo said, “It doesn’t matter who I am. I don’t need you out here harassing my patients. I’m not answering your questions… I’m gonna break this camera. I’m gonna rip this thing out of this kid’s hand in a minute. Turn the camera off.”
Bail set at $900,000 for doctor charged in pill mill sweep
Dr. Zvi Harry Perper, who is the son of Broward County Medical Examiner Joshua Perper, was arrested at the Delray Beach Pain Management at 102 N. Swinton Ave. on Feb. 23, 2011. Perper has worked at the clinic since 2009, which was started that year by Kent Murry, a convicted drug smuggler and career criminal. An attorney for Murry later said he sold the clinic to his office manager but still maintained a presence in the building. DEA records show Perper was the only doctor registered to prescribe drugs from the Delray Beach clinic.
By Michael LaForgia, Palm Beach Post Staff Writer, March 1, 2011
WEST PALM BEACH — A judge today set bail for a doctor accused of enriching himself by recklessly prescribing powerful painkillers at $900,000 and ordered him held on house arrest, among other conditions.
Dr. Zvi Harry Perper, son of Broward County Medical Examiner Joshua Perper, remained in the Palm Beach County Jail on Tuesday night, records show. Should he go free on bond, he also agreed not to practice medicine or write prescriptions while his criminal case is pending, said his attorney, Richard Lubin.
Perper was among 17 people charged last week as part of “Operation Pill Nation,” a joint effort by local, state and federal drug agents to crack down on crooked pain clinics.
He faces state charges of racketeering, conspiracy and drug trafficking related to his work for Delray Pain Management, a medical office founded in 2009 by a convicted drug smuggler who also was arrested last week.
Lubin said his client worked at a legitimate business and gave thorough medical exams to each patient.
“We have a very strong defense,” Lubin said, adding: “One of the hallmarks that law enforcement has set forth to prove that something is more of a ‘pill mll’ or illegal clinic is the number of out-of-state license plates. Here, the policy was that no one would be serviced if they were from out of state.”
Peguero, Maria (owner) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published November 8, 2011
Killing Place:
A Woman’s Care
68 NE 167th St # A
Miami, FL 33162-3401
A Woman’s Care II, Inc.
952 East 25th Street
Hialeah, FL 33013-3404
Co-founder of A Woman’s Care with Siomara Senises.
Peguero, Felicita (owner) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published November 8, 2011
Killing Place:
A Woman’s Care II, Inc.
952 East 25th Street
Hialeah, FL 33013-3404
Co-founder with Maria Peguero of A Woman’s Care II, Inc. and Hialeah Woman’s Choice Clinic, Inc.
Osborne, Robelto (revoked, watchlist) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published November 8, 2011
Killing Place:
Miramar Woman Center
6161 Miramar Parkway
Miramar, FL 33023
Office:
1190 NW 95th St
Suite 306
Miami, FL 33150
Robelto Osborne lost his license in 2004 for puncturing a mother’s uterus during an abortion, not treating it, and failing to return her calls complaining of extreme pain and bleeding. She required the removal of retained fetal parts and a hysterectomy. Records also show Osborne botched an abortion in 1996 by damaging the small intestine of an 18-year-old.
In a Miami Herald article of Tuesday, July 19th, 2005, Mary Ellen Klas wrote:
Clinic’s two owners arrested
A Miami clinic lost its license and it’s owners were arrested in the second case involving the same unlicensed doctor performing abortions. The former attorney – unlicensed abortionist – Robelto Osborne was convicted of 4 felony counts of practicing medicine without a license in October of 2005.
From the Miami Herald, 7/30/06:
One clinic in Miramar has a history of violations. Located at 6161 Miramar Pkwy., it was closed last year after three employees were charged with practicing medicine without a license.
Among them: Robelto A. Osborne, who was convicted last year of four counts of performing medicine without a license, a third-degree felony in Florida. The Florida Department of Health found he failed to treat a woman after giving her an abortion in 2000.
He gave her a shot to help the bleeding and pain she reported after the procedure, but he later did not return her calls. She ended up going to the emergency room, where doctors performed a hysterectomy, Health department officials reported.
Norris, Paul Michael (verified, promoter, instructor) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published November 7, 2011
Killing Place:
Jackson Memorial Hospital
1611 NW 12th Ave
Suite 7007
Miami, Florida 33136
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Home: 1690 S Treasure Dr
Miami Beach, FL 33141
A promoter/instructor is an abortionist who recruits or trains abortionists. They occupy a strategic position, for without the instructor, there are no new abortionists.
YOB: September 1959
Obstetrics & Gynecology
Assistant Professor of Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Miami
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
University of Miami Hospital; Jackson Memorial Hospital, Miami
Ryan Residency Training Program in Family Planning and Abortion
During the internship year, OB/GYN residents in our program spend two-three days per week over a six week period at the University of Miami Reproductive Health Services Clinic. Co-directed by Drs. Carla Lupi and Paul Norris, UMRHC provides surgical and medical abortions, uterine evacuation for failed pregnancies, and consultation on complicated contraceptive management.
Following a nationally devised curriculum, residents learn surgical procedures and pain management, counseling and communication skills, and principles of public health and evidence based medicine as related to family planning. This well-rated rotation provides first year residents valuable one-on-one didactic interaction with faculty members and full involvement in procedures and patient care.
The program has received its initial funding from the Ryan Residency Training Program in Family Planning and Abortion, a nationally available philanthropic effort designed to insure a solid education in the range of family planning services that obstetrician-gynecologists should master.
We look forward to the addition of Dr. Christopher Estes, a Family Planning Fellowship graduate from Columbia University, to our faculty. His leadership will enable the development of our own fellowship program and participation in multi-centered research. With reproductive health and family planning specifically at the international forefront of women’s health issues, a robust program is a must at our “global” university medical school.
Nisbet, Kieron (worker, watchlist) - Hialeah
By Jay Rogers
Published November 7, 2011
Killing Place:
Best Care Woman’s Center (closed)
8380 SW 8th Street
Miami, FL 33144

A series of articles in Miami newspapers in 2005 and 2006 told of unlicensed workers performing abortions.
In a Miami Herald article of Tues, July 19, 2005, Mary Ellen Klas, Herald Editor wrote:
Clinic’s two owners arrested
A Miami clinic lost its license and it’s owners were arrested in the second case involving the same unlicensed doctor performing abortions.
Jose Rodriguez, 52, and Magaly Gil, 56, both of Miami, were arrested and released on $5,000 bond after detectives concluded that they knew Kieron Nisbet was not licensed to practice medicine in Florida, Nisbet is alleged to have performed abortions in November at their clinic, Best Care Woman’s Center, 8380 SW 8h Street. Sgt Llevat of Miami-Dade unlicensed practitioner’s unit (305-477-1616) says that Gil & Rodriguez were arrested for “aiding & abetting.” When asked if administrator Siomara Senises could be charged for the same offense, Sgt Llevat said yes, “it’s in the Florida Statutes and Senises used three unlicensed people at her clinic also.”
On Thursday, January 6th, 2005, Miami Herald reporter Hannah Sampson wrote:
Another worker at the clinic, Kieron A. Nisbet, 34, of Homestead, is being sought for giving patients anesthesia while they underwent abortions even though he did not have a license.
Nauert, George Michael (verified, deceased, owner) - Palm Harbor
By Jay Rogers
Published November 6, 2011
Killing Places:
St Petersburg Woman’s Health Center
3401 66th St N
St Petersburg, FL 33710
Bread & Roses Woman’s Health Center
1560 S Highland Ave
Clearwater, FL 33756
Tampa Woman’s Health Center
2010 E Fletcher Ave
Tampa, FL 33612
Sarasota Woman’s Health Clinic (closed!)
5025 N Tamiami Trail
Sarasota, FL 34234
(See Property Transaction record below.)
Home: 795 Baldwin Rd, Palm Harbor, FL 34683
DOB: July 2, 1936
Death: April 27, 2007
George Nauert owned four abortion mills. The “Woman’s Health Center” abortion chain is now owned by his wife Jodell Lynne Nauert, a singer in a local country band.

Members of Wisconsin National Socialist Movement gesture during a Nazi rally in 2006 in Madison, Wisconsin.
“If there’s one thing I can’t stand, it’s country-western, neo-Nazi abortionists from Wisconsin.” – Jake Blues
Teen ‘Gestapo’ Gang Revealed in Milwaukee Theft
Wisconsin State Journal, Thursday, February 25, 1954
MILWAUKEE (IP) — The past existence of a brown-shirted Gestapo-like gang of wealthy teenagers has been revealed in a hearing for two youths in the theft of $4,500 from a suburban home.
MacWilliam Weldon II, 17, suburban Fox Point, pleaded guilty through his attorneys to delinquency in children’s court Tuesday.
George Michael Nauert [emphasis added], 17, suburban, Whitefish Bay, pleaded innocent to the charge. He was accused of abetting the theft, from the home, of attorney Sydney C. Charney two days after Christmas.
It was brought out in the hearing late Tuesday that a group of North Shore boys had belonged to the gang called the Royalist Nazi Regime, which patterned itself after the Nazi Gestapo.
The gang met in the Fox Point home of a 19-year-old leader, it was revealed. It later changed its name to the Cavaliers and included in it number several students who attended wealthy private schools.
North Shore police officials said the gang now has disbanded. Weldon admitted taking a safe containing money from Charney’s home. Judge John J. Kenney made an immediate finding of delinquency because Weldon will be 18 on Feb. 28 and out of the jurisdiction of children’s court.
Kenney continued Nauert’s case until Mar. 5 and said he might act on Weldon’s case at that time. Nauert was accused of furnishing the floor plan of the Charney home but said he did not know it was to be used in a theft.
NOTE: George Michael Nauert is the late husband of Jodell Lynne Nauert. He graduated from the Medical College of Wisconsin in 1965. He founded four abortion corporations in Florida, which run the “Woman’s Heath Center” abortion chain in Tampa, St. Petersburg and Clearwater, Florida. Another Nauert-owned abortion center in Sarasota closed a few years ago. Jodell now owns the three remaining mills.
Since he was born in July 1936, this story of Feb. 25th, 1954 would put George Michael Nauert in Wisconsin at the correct age of 17 when this story was published in the Wisconsin State Journal. The more I find out about this family, the stranger it gets. I especially like his excuse to the judge that he only furnished a floor plan of a rich man’s house to a group of Neo-Nazi youth, but had no idea it was to be used in a theft.

Beware of wolves in sheep’s clothing
I happen to love wolves. So do George and Jodell Nauert. In fact, they love wolves so much so that they are listed as donors to the International Wolf Center in their 2004 publication, Advancing a World for Wolves. The United States of America might be remembered in years to come as a nation where the people became so deceived that they worried more about saving wolves, manatees, baby seals and whales, but killed off their own human children by the tens of millions.
Kawana Ashley Killed Her Baby
In St. Petersburg, Florida, on March 27, 1994, Kawana Ashley fired a bullet into her womb, fatally injuring the fetus, because she could not afford an abortion.
Kawana attempted to procure an abortion at George Nauert’s St. Petersburg Women’s Health Care Clinic, Inc. She did not have the money that the clinic demanded for the procedure so she chose another option. Ashley told a friend she would “just shoot herself in the stomach”. Her friend said she did not take her seriously. At approximately 10:50 a.m. on March 27th, Ashely fired a .22 caliber pistol into the right side of her womb and fatally injured her 24 week-old fetus (Herald Tribune, 9-10-94) … Read more
Property transaction
This apparently marks the selling of the property after the closing of the Sarasota abortion mill.
9/10/2004 – George Michael Nauert and Thomas Canavan have sold the commercial property located at 5025 N. Tamiami Trail to North Trail Investments Inc. for $385,000. Barry Seidel, of American Property Group of Sarasota Inc., handled the transaction.
Related Articles
Morris, Merri Beth (verified) - Tampa, Ocala
By Jay Rogers
Published November 5, 2011
Killing Place:
Women’s Center of Hyde Park
502 South Magnolia Avenue
Tampa, FL 33606
Ocala Women’s Center
108 NW Pine Ave
Ocala, FL 34475-6619
Home:
1939 New Hampshire Ave NE
Saint Petersburg, FL 33703
(Deed is in the name of Merri Morris’ husband Craig Rule.)
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map


YOB: August 1956
Speaks: French, Spanish
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Arizona, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee.
The following looks to be from early 2009. Apparently, James Pendergraft puts out press releases to announce who the new killers are and includes their bios.
The Women’s Center of Hyde Park Expands Operations and Welcomes Dr. Merri Morris M.D.
Tampa, FL (PRWEB) – The Women’s Center of Hyde Park has announced that Merri Morris, MD has joined its staff as its newest physician. There are five Women’s Centers locations in Florida to serve its communities: The Women’s Center of Hyde Park in Tampa, Florida; Ocala Women’s Center in Ocala, Florida; Ft. Lauderdale Women’s Center, in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida; and Orlando Women’s Center and EPOC clinic, which are both located in Orlando, Florida.
The facilities offer a wide range of treatments including but not limited to the following: yearly physical exams, pap smears, prenatal care, first trimester pregnancy complications that include vaginal bleeding, abdominal cramps and bleeding, ectopic pregnancy, incomplete abortion, inevitable abortion, missed abortion, incomplete abortion, first and second trimester abortions, prenatal care, IUD and implant placements, outpatient sterilization, colposcopy, menopause, peri-menopausal care, first pelvic exams, diagnosis and treatment of vaginitis, urinary tract infections, sexually transmitted diseases, primary care treatments which include caring for patients with hypertension, arthritis, osteoporosis, diabetes, lipid abnormalities, general and travel vaccinations including flu and H1N1 (swine) vaccine, free oral prep HIV and Chlamydia screening.
Dr. Morris received her undergraduate BS degree from Arizona State University in 1978 and earned her medical degree from The University of Arizona in 1982. She did her Ob/Gyn Residency at The University of N.C. at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, N.C. in 1986. After completing her residency, she moved to Carthage, T.N. where she opened her private practice. She began devoting more time to providing abortions and family planning services at several clinics in Tennessee and South Carolina. She moved to Florida in 2007 and has now decided to focus on growing her own private practice at the Women’s Center of Hyde Park. She is currently welcoming new patients.
“To be joining such a prestigious and highly-regarded Ob/Gyn and primary care practice is truly the highlight of my medical career,” said Dr. Morris. “I feel like I am making a difference as a physician with the patients I see. I want to make the whole process easier for the women I care for. Their reputation for offering patients a personalized level of care is well-known across the State of Florida and what I want to be a part of.”
Miller, Lawrence Whitefield (retired, watchlist) - Jacksonville
By Jay Rogers
Published November 5, 2011
Killing Place:
A Woman’s Choice of Jacksonville
4131 University Boulevard South, Building. # 2
Jacksonville, FL 32216
YOB: 1937
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Georgia
License is delinquent/active.
Miller Jr., Herman (verified) - Jacksonville
By Jay Rogers
Published November 5, 2011
Killing Places:
A Woman’s Choice of Jacksonville
4131 University Boulevard South, Building # 2
Jacksonville, FL 32216
Planned Parenthood: Central Clinic
3850 Beach Blvd
Jacksonville, FL 32207
Secondary locations:
Planned Parenthood of North Florida
2370 South Third Street, #1
Jacksonville Beach, FL 32250
Planned Parenthood of North Florida
914 NW 13th St
Gainesville, FL 32605
Planned Parenthood of North Florida
The Sally Bellamy Clinic
2121 West Pensacola St
Tallahassee, FL 32304
Home: 3676 Cathedral Oaks Place South
Jacksonville, FL 32217
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: February 1947
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Georgia
Past Medical Director of Planned Parenthood of North Florida, Inc.
Discipline record:
Medical records show that on or about March 11, 2008, 15 year old patient B.M. presented at Respondent’s office, Savannah Medical Clinic, Savannah, GA, for an induced termination of her approximate 15 week twin pregnancy. Medical records further show that Respondent was unable to complete the procedure, sent the patient back to the recovery room, and then back to the OR to resume the procedure. Medical records indicate that although Respondent recognized the abortion was incomplete and perforation was possible, he sent the patient home with instructions to her family to go to the hospital ER if she complained of abdominal pain or vaginal bleeding. Medical records indicate that patient B.M. was admitted the same evening to Memorial Hospital, Savannah, GA, with severe abdominal/pelvic pain and bleeding, and underwent emergent surgery to repair three (3) perforations (5-6 cm long), complete the abortion and cystoscopy. Medical records show patient B.M. received four (4) units of blood and spent five (5) days in the hospital. (Source: Georgia Composite Medical Board, January 7th, 2010, Docket # 20100052).
McCree, Douglas Gene (verified) – Naples
By Jay Rogers
Published October 17, 2011
Killing Place:
Planned Parenthood of Collier County
1425 Creech Rd
Naples, FL 34103
Home: 144 Moorings Park Dr, Apt 205
Naples, FL 34105
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: 1933
Maurer, Susan (owner) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published October 16, 2011
Killing Place:
A Choice for Women
6660 SW 117th Ave
Miami, FL 33183-2826
Women’s Emergency Network
(Same address)
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Home:
2613 Toledo St
Coral Gables, FL 33134
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: January 1952
Bio from A Choice for Women website
Susan Maurer has been a certified registered nurse anesthetist for over 20 years. Prior to becoming a CRNA, she practiced as a nurse for 6 years. She has experience in anesthesia for open-heart surgery, major vascular surgeries, major cosmetic surgeries, and gynecological surgeries. She is an active member of the American Association of Nurse Anesthetists. She is co-founder of A Choice for Women with abortionist Edward Ray Watson.
Lupi, Carla Shyrl (verified, promoter, instructor) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published October 16, 2011
Killing Places:
Jackson Memorial Hospital
1611 NW 12th Ave
Suite 7007
Miami, Florida 33136
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Office:
1321 NW 14th Street
Suite 201
Miami, Florida 33136
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Home: 820 Valencia Ave
Miami, FL 33134
Address is shared on property tax records with Raquel M. Matas.
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
A promoter/instructor is an abortionist who recruits or trains abortionists. They occupy a strategic position, for without the instructor, there are no new abortionists.
Assistant Professor of Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology
Co-Director, Reproductive Health Services
Director, Undergraduate Medical Education
YOB: April 1958
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
University of Miami Hospital; Jackson Memorial Hospital, Miami
Languages: Spanish
Church: Coral Gables Congregational Church
Carla Lupi signed a friend of the court brief in favor or Planned Parenthood and against the federal law prohibiting partial birth abortion.
Dr. Carla Lupi, assistant clinical professor of the department of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, said, “As a physician, I am aghast that a jurist, with no professional licensure or experience in the care of women facing very complicated medical and personal decisions, should have the power to dictate my medical practice. These cases are often challenging even for the most seasoned practitioners. Doctors’ hands should not be tied by categorical legal decisions.”
Ryan Residency Training Program in Family Planning and Abortion
During the internship year, OB/GYN residents in our program spend two-three days per week over a six week period at the University of Miami Reproductive Health Services Clinic. Co-directed by Drs. Carla Lupi and Paul Norris, UMRHC provides surgical and medical abortions, uterine evacuation for failed pregnancies, and consultation on complicated contraceptive management.
Following a nationally devised curriculum, residents learn surgical procedures and pain management, counseling and communication skills, and principles of public health and evidence based medicine as related to family planning. This well-rated rotation provides first year residents valuable one-on-one didactic interaction with faculty members and full involvement in procedures and patient care.
The program has received its initial funding from the Ryan Residency Training Program in Family Planning and Abortion, a nationally available philanthropic effort designed to insure a solid education in the range of family planning services that obstetrician-gynecologists should master.
We look forward to the addition of Dr. Christopher Estes, a Family Planning Fellowship graduate from Columbia University, to our faculty. His leadership will enable the development of our own fellowship program and participation in multi-centered research. With reproductive health and family planning specifically at the international forefront of women’s health issues, a robust program is a must at our “global” university medical school.
Livingston, Robert Michael (watchlist, permanently suspended) – Vero Beach
By Jay Rogers
Published October 16, 2011
1700 Waterford Drive
Apt 209
Vero Beach, FL 32966
Robert Livingston Medical Office
3350 NW 2nd Ave # A1
Boca Raton, FL, 33431
Home: 3603 NW 5th Avenue
Boca Raton, FL, 33431
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
License status: Null and void
Robert Michael Livingston was admitted to Boca Raton Communtiy Hospital on January 20th, 2004 (two days before the Roe 21st anniversary) due to a drug overdose. He had injected himself with opiate narcotics to deal with pain. The overdose resulted in the impairment of cognitive abilities.
He currently takes methadone to deal with chronic pain. He agreed to withdraw from the medical practice. On May 19th, 2006, Livingston returned to his medical practice in violation of his contract. As a consequence, his license to practice medicine has been permanently revoked.
Abortion Fight Escalates After Fetal Matter Found
Orlando Sentinel, October 24, 1992
BOCA RATON — An anti-abortion group and a gynecologist who performs abortions are both under investigation by police trying to learn who put fetal material in a garbage bin, a police spokesman said Friday. The Palm Beach Medical Examiner’s Office determined that medical waste in the bin behind Dr. Robert Livingston’s clinic included tissues from first-trimester abortions, Boca Raton police spokesman Michael Genay said. Livingston said it was planted by anti-abortion advocates.
Here’s an article showing Livingston was performing illegal abortions prior to the time of Roe v. Wade.
In September 1972, when police raided Doctor Robert Livingston’s office [in New Jersey], confiscated materials, and arrested him for conspiracy to perform abortion, the ACLU-NJ stepped in to represent him.
Nauert, Jodell Lynne (owner) Clearwater, St. Petersburg, Tampa
By Jay Rogers
Published September 6, 2011
Killing Places:
St Petersburg Woman’s Health Center
3401 66th St N
St Petersburg, FL 33710
Bread & Roses Woman’s Health Center
1560 S Highland Ave
Clearwater, FL 33756
Tampa Woman’s Health Center
2010 E Fletcher Ave
Tampa, FL 33612
Home:
795 Baldwin Rd
Palm Harbor, FL 34683
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
Another property listed in the name of Jodell Nauert is a 5262 square foot home on a sprawling million dollar estate with two barns and a stable. It was recently listed for rent.
Home:
2925 Keystone Road
Tarpon Springs, FL 34688
YOB: November 1963

Jodell Lynne Nauert – Country Music Singer, School Board Member, Child Killer
I have to admit, when I first saw this, I thought there must be two Jodell Nauerts – the wife of the late abortionist George Michael Nauert – and the country music singer of JoDell and the Mountain Road Band. Then I found that the home of the country singer is in town of Tarpon Springs, Florida. To my amazement, it turns out they are the same person.
I still find it hard to believe, but it is true.
Here’s the story. Abortion clinic chain owner George Michael Nauert died on April 27, 2007. The last time he appears on the Woman’s Health Center corporation papers is November 2007. His former wife, Marsha Nauert, also appeared on his corporation papers from 1977 until the time of their divorce on November 14th, 1984. Jodell Nauert, a subsequent wife about 28 years younger, was listed as the only other officer at the time of George Nauert’s death.
An Operation Save America story described a picket at George Michael Nauert’s home a few years back.
… the team and supporters took a thirty minute trip to the Tarpon Springs home of abortionist, George Nauert. Traffic on the busy country road slowed as the graphic ministry of ‘Malachi’ reached out to soften hearts. A large yellow arrow with the word ABORTIONIST pointed to the immense estate purchased with the blood of thousands of innocent pre-born children. Nauert owns four abortion mills, including the Sarasota Women’s Health Center where Matthew ‘headbanger’ Kachinas continues in Nauert’s stead. (see article Violence Erupts).”
Jodell Nauert’s Corporations
Jodell Nauert is now the president of three abortion mill corporations (the Sarasota mill closed a few years back.) She’s not a medical doctor like her late husband, but simply the owner of abortuaries in North Tampa, St Pete and Clearwater.
She’s on the board of a charter school in Palm Harbor.
She is also the president of a consulting corporation.
Her Tampa mill does late term abortions.
… at the Tampa Woman’s Health Center, where abortions are performed up to 24 weeks of pregnancy, the decision was hailed as “a victory for women.”
“I think it’s great that it was shot down,” JoDell Nauert, the center’s executive director, said of Nebraska’s abortion ban. “It’s the patient and the doctor who should decide what’s best, not the Legislature, not your next-door neighbor. They don’t walk in your shoes.”
Country Singer
She is the singer with JoDell and the Mountain Road Band that performs around the Tampa Bay area.
She offers her CDs for sale or download and you can listen to another one of her songs here.
See Jodell’s MySpace page and her Facebook fan page.

Just a country girl singin’ country songs about “Livin’ in a cowboy town … Goin’ to church on Sunday … Ya’ll!”
There are lots and lots of photos of her on the Internet. Her band plays at family oriented festivals. There are photos of her singing to crowds filled with young children and signing autographs.

The Two Faces of Jodell – Country Singer by Night, Child Killing Vampire by Day! It sounds a little like the premise for a horror film!

Here she is jamming with Charlie Daniels, who is an outspoken conservative Christian. Did he know she owns three abortion mills? I doubt it.

She has also recorded a “Christmas album dedicated to Angelus House a local home and school for the handicapped.
Related Articles
Lehrer, Theodor (verified) – Fort Lauderdale
By Jay Rogers
Published August 26, 2011
Killing Place:
All Women’s Medical Center
2100 East Commercial Boulevard
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308
Home:
271 Capri Ave
Lauderdale-by-the-Sea, FL 33308
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: c. 1937
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Broward General Medical Center, Ft. Lauderdale
Imperial Point Medical Center, Ft. Lauderdale
Theodore Lehrer: Champion of Choice?
National Abortion Federation member Theodore Lehrer, owner of All Women’s Clinic in Ft. Lauderdale, was arrested, and had his medical license suspended, in 1988 over his violent treatment of his wife. Mrs. Lehrer was 37 years old and 11 weeks pregnant, according to what she told police, when Dr. Lehrer got angry because she had morning sickness and had declined his sexual advances. According to Mrs. Lehrer, the good doctor forced her into the bathroom, held her down, handcuffed her, and did an abortion on her, without anesthesia. She said he told her to hold still or he’d inject her with something to calm her down. She also reported that he raped her. She was hospitalized to complete the botched forced abortion.
Miami Herald 5-4-88, Associated Press 4/29/1988; Spokane Chronicle 4/29/1988
Rape and Forced Abortion
Fort Lauderdale – On April 27, 1988, Fort Lauderdale abortionist Theodore Lehrer, a member of the National Abortion Federation (NAF) and owner of the All Women’s Clinic was charged with sexual battery after he imprisoned and forcibly aborted his wife. According to the abortionist’s wife, he handcuffed her, dragged her into the bedroom, tied her to a table and gagged her. Then he raped her and forcibly aborted her against her will. It is significant that this abortionist and his wife had signed a prenuptial contract which stated that, in the event of divorce, the wife would get only $5,000 if she bore him no children, but would be granted alimony, property, and child support if she had children. (Miami Herald, May 5, 1988; Associated Press, April 29, 1988; Leslie Bond.
Paul Likoudis, “Abortionist Charged for Aborting Wife Against Her Will,” National Right to Life News, June 23, 1988, page 9.
Prosecutors dropped all charges against a Fort Lauderdale doctor after his former wife, the alleged victim of a rape and forced abortion, said she was too sick to testify against him. Gynecologist Theodor Lehrer was arrested after his wife told police he had handcuffed and gagged her, then raped her and forcibly aborted an 11-week-old fetus in a bathroom in their condominium.
James McCarty, “Doctor’s Rape Charge Dropped Ex-Wife Refuses to Take Stand,” Miami Herald, June 20, 1989.
Related Articles
Kelly, Patrick Joseph (verified, owner) – Jacksonville
By Jay Rogers
Published August 26, 2011
Killing Place:
Florida Women’s Center
3599 University Blvd. S
Building #1200
Jacksonville, FL 32216
DOB: September 2, 1963

Keene, William Philip (verified) – St. Petersburg, Pensacola
By Jay Rogers
Published August 25, 2011
Killing Place:
AMS of Pensacola
6115 Village Oaks Drive
Pensacola, FL 32504-698
YOB: January 1943
Woman’s Clinic Closes Abruptly
WEAR ABC 3 in Pensacola, Florida reported on August 22 2011:
A Pensacola women’s clinic has closed. AMS off of Village Oaks Drive abruptly closed its doors and left some of their clients without any notice. We’ve received a lot of calls from people who have seen this eviction notice on the front of AMS’ door. It states that the property had to be vacated immediately. The letter was served by the Escambia Sheriff’s Office on August 18th. Part of it reads “the ECSO Civil Division has taken immediate possession of the property.”
It lists AMS of Pensacola as the defendant and a Dione Pro Inc. as the plaintiff. A check of Escambia County Clerk of Court records shows Dione Pro Inc. filed an eviction notice back in July against AMS. We don’t know the reasons behind why the eviction notice was filed, but Dr. Philip Keene is the doctor who performed abortions at AMS is also listed as the president and secretary for Dione Pro Inc.

Escambia County Sheriff’s Office Notice of Possession
The WEAR 3 news report mentions William Keene constantly throughout the report and ends by suggesting the abortion mill closed due to “safety concerns.”
We don’t know if safety concerns were a factor in the shutdown. One woman told us that Dr. Keene would actually come to work in a police car and get dropped off in the back wearing a ski mask so no one could identify him.
So let’s get this straight. An abortionist wearing a ski mask issued himself an eviction notice and shut down the clinic that he owned and where he worked for not paying his own rent? Something is fishy if you ask me.
See the docket for this lawsuit of abortionist Keene vs. himself
Check out William Philip Keene’s Florida corporations:
Business connections for William P Keene include Lana Wagner and William J McGurk.
More light on the story from Pensacola
The first time I saw this, I thought it was the same incident as a similar two-year-old story even though it had a recent date. I was at first thinking of Community Healthcare Center of Pensacola from a story two years ago, the last time a Pensacola abortion mill closed.
See the November 4, 2009 WEAR 3 news report.
However, Community Healthcare Center of Pensacola reincorporated and opened a short time later in the same place under a new name, American Family Planning Pensacola
I talked to the 40 Days for Life coordinator in Pensacola, Ernie Cyr, seen in the video above. He said that Keene showed up in a hockey mask (like Jason in Friday the 13th) and not a ski mask. He also pointed out that the Sunbiz.org site shows that earlier this year Dione Pro, Inc. dropped Keene from its corporation papers. Keene was listed as president on March 3rd, 2011, but as of April 13th, 2011, it’s now just William McGurk and Lana Wagner.
So much for media accuracy.
As the segment below will show, the weak link in the chain is not the abortion clinic, which may come and go, but rather the abortionist.
Victims of Choice
Victim: Pamela Colson
Date of Death: June 26, 1994.
Place of Death: Pensacola Women’s Medical Services, Pensacola, Florida.
Abortionist: William Keene.
Sources: Panama City News Herald, June 19 and June 29, 1994; Pensacola News Journal, June 29, 1994; St. Petersburg Times, June 30, 1994; USA Today, June 30, 1994; District I, Florida, case #MLA94-266.
Source: http://abortionviolence.com/DEATHS.HTM
Anniversary: Pamela Colson’s death
Pamela Colson, age 31, was 12 weeks pregnant when friends drive her to Women’s Medical Services in Pensacola, Florida, for an abortion June 26, 1994. Pamela bled heavily during the drive home. According to her friends, Pamela became unresponsive, so they stopped at a motel. Two passers-by did CPR while Pamela’s friends called for an ambulance. Pamela was taken to a hospital where she died after an emergency hysterectomy.
Her autopsy showed: bloodstained fluid in chest and peritoneal space, and “extensive hematoma formation in the pelvic area with the peritoneum denuded from the left gutter area caudually.” The surgeon who performed an emergency hysterectomy, trying to save Pamela’s life, had removed her uterus at the site of the laceration “so that the laceration was a portion of the incision made to remove the uterus.” Her uterus showed extensive hemorrhage and blood clots. Her uterine artery was also injured. Several of Pamela’s ribs were fractured, apparently during attempts to resuscitate her; this is common in even properly performed CPR.
The cause of death was given as “‘irreversible shock from blood loss due to a perforated uterus occurring at the time of an elective abortion.” William Keene was tentatively identified as having performed the abortion. Pamela’s fatal abortion was performed at the clinic where abortionist David Gunn was shot dead. While Gunn’s death is much lamented by abortion advocates, Pamela’s death is not. In fact, the clinic had two women arrested for using the tacky gum designed to hang posters safely on walls to hang a black crepe wreath on the clinic door on the anniversary of Pamela’s death.
For more abortion deaths, visit the Cemetery of Choice.
Kachinas, Matthew Jay (verified, suspended) – Venice
By Jay Rogers
Published August 21, 2011
Killing Place:
Premiere Institute for Women’s Health
6122 South Tamiami Trail
Sarasota, FL 34231 (CLOSED!)
Office:
First Choice Pain Care Clinic
401 Commercial Court
Suite D
Venice, FL 34292
Home:
1590 Harbor Cay Lane
Longboat Key, FL 34228
YOB: c.1962
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Columbia Doctors Hospital of Sarasota
Discipline is on file:
Case document 1
Case document 2
Case document 3
Cease and Desist Order
On February of 2008, Kachinas was ordered to cease and desist doing abortions. The Florida State Licensing Department sent a letter to abortionist Kachinas that read:
Dear Dr Kachinas, The purpose of this letter is to officially advise you of the findings of a Complaint Investigation visit of your abortion clinic conduct … by Eleanor Seville RNS of this office. Compliance with the requirements was discussed with you and your representative at the facility during the exit conference following the completion of the survey…. Your facility was found not to be in compliance with Florida Statutes and the Florida Administrative Code governing the state licensing requirements.
The State of Florida’s Complaint Reads as Follows:
Upon entrance to the facility … the receptionist (name unknown) was asked if the facility is doing abortions. Her response was “yes.” Review of the licensure denial letter from Tallahassee dated clearly states the Abortion Clinic licensure was denied. The facility medical director stated the clinic has been doing first and second trimester abortions since the letter was issued Review of office records revealed abortions were conducted since the letter of denial was received. – AHCA
Matthew Kachinas is the infamous abortionist who aborted the “wrong” twin.
Dr. Matthew Kachinas Suicidal for Aborting the Wrong, Healthy Twin
The Miami Herald – April 12th, 2010
Dr. Matthew Kachinas, an abortion doctor in Sarasota, FL has lost his license for mistakenly aborting a healthy twin during a procedure targeting a deformed fetus.
After the board’s unanimous vote to revoke his license, Dr. Kachinas appeared stunned and confused. “What does that mean, revocation? I don’t understand.”
Department of Health officials told him he could appeal to the courts and suggested he consult a lawyer. But a despondent Kachinas told a reporter after the hearing that he intended to kill himself. Police took him to a hospital for evaluation.
Kachinas had blamed faulty ultrasound equipment for the 2006 mistake. He was targeting a fetus with Down syndrome and signs of a heart defect. Although never having done the procedure before, he did not want to disappoint the patient by telling her ‘no’.
Dr. Kachinas represented himself before the board and in a previous hearing, Health News Florida reported, he spent most of his time arguing two less serious allegations, admitting in the twin case he “screwed up.”
The media has reported this story as the doctor who “aborted the wrong twin.” This begs the question: Was there a “right twin” to abort? And if a baby was the “wrong twin,” why did the law and medical ethics prohibit aborting this twin? This paradox is monumental!
The well-known preacher Albert Mohler has an blog article about this:
Aborting the “Wrong” Baby?
Hear also the audio from Mohler’s radio show
By Albert Mohler
What are we to make of this? We now know that the vast majority of babies identified prenatally as carrying the genetic markers for Down syndrome are aborted. National statistics indicate that 80-90% of such babies are now aborted — meaning that we have launched a search and destroy mission on Down syndrome babies in the womb.
The situation with Dr. Kachinas reveals the horribly confused morality that marks modern America and, in far too many cases, the practice of medicine. This doctor was asked to perform what is now euphemistically called a “selective reduction.” Instead, he aborted “the wrong baby,” killing a healthy baby instead of the baby identified as carrying the markers for Down syndrome.
Consider what this means for the sanctity of human life. We are now looking at babies as consumer products. We will accept babies that meet our specified qualifications, and abort when medical tests or other factors reveal that the baby does not meet our standards. Human life is reduced to just another consumer product subject to consumer preferences and demand.
Do we recognize what this means? The abortion of Down syndrome babies is a scandal of the first degree, and this nation is growing more complacent and complicit in this scandal by the day. Beyond this, we can be certain that babies are now being targeted in the womb for reasons far beyond Down syndrome. Specialists working with autism are concerned that forthcoming genetic tests will put babies who carry markers for autism next on the list for prenatal search and destroy missions.
This news story out of Florida is a warning to the entire nation. What is the real scandal here — that this doctor was ready to kill a baby with Down syndrome, or merely that he aborted “the wrong baby?”
Two Incidents of Battery and a Death Threat
On Dec. 27, 2002, an Operation Save America press release reported, he became enraged at a protester and head-butted her. He was convicted of battery and was ordered to undergo psychiatric evaluation and anger management counseling. Eventually, he reportedly was dismissed after having worked there for 5 years. That facility closed in early 2004, a while after Kachinas left. The building was still vacant in 2009; there had been no buyers.
On Friday morning, December 27, 2002, abortionist Matthew J. Kachinas arrived at the Sarasota Womens Health Center abortion mill at 5025 North Tamiami Trail. Pro-lifer Linda McGlade, a mother of seven children, tried to preach the Gospel to him. Enraged, he exited his vehicle and walked up to within inches of Linda, then said several times “I’m going to kill you!” Then, in front of half a dozen witnesses, and with a video camera running, Kachinas drew his head back and delivered a head butt to Linda’s forehead.
Linda’s son Keith quickly went to his mother’s side to defend her. The abortionist tried to provoke Keith into a fight. He taunted him, saying, “What are you going to do about it?” The abortionist then flicked the hat off of Keith’s head and taunted and cursed him some more. When Keith did not take the bait, the abortionist jumped up and down on Keith’s hat while screaming more obscenities. He then walked into his abortion mill.
In June 2003, Kachinas was found guilty of battery. Immediately after Sarasota’s Chief County Judge Logalbo pronounced the sentence upon the abortionist, which included extensive psychiatric evaluation “due to the violence and the fact that he has people’s lives in his hands daily,” he was fingerprinted and booked in front of a packed gallery of spectators. During his trial, Kachinas lied obviously and flagrantly many times. Noting Kachinas‘ professional position and his “less than forthright” statements, Judge Logalbo issued a sentence which far exceeded the sentence asked for by the prosecution. Along with the psychiatric evaluations and completion of all recommended treatments, including an anger management program, Kachinas was placed on one year probation in addition to a $1,000 fine and court costs. Incredibly, even the abortionist’s lawyer admitted afterwards that he believed the pro-life witnesses over the testimony of his own client!
References: “Violence Erupts at Abortion Mill.” Operation Save America press release dated December 27, 2002. “Abortion Doctor, Matthew Kachinas, Guilty of Battery.”
See also: http://www.operationsaveamerica.org/streets/fl/kachinas-guilty-in-battery-case.htm.html
It appears that by 2008, Matthew J Kachinas had fallen on such financial hardship, that a code enforcement hearing on October 13th, took up the complaint that he hadn’t mowed his grass.
Case No. 08-50, Matthew J. Kachinas, 1590 Harbor Cay Lane, Longboat Key, Fl 34228
Officer Micale commented that this case involved a reoccurring violation of Section 96.01, Maintenance of Premises, weeds and grass in excess of 12 inches. Staff was requesting that the CEB issue an Order to establish grounds for a Repeat Violation. She reviewed the agenda materials with the CEB.
Dr. Matthew Kachinas, respondent, explained that he had purchased the home in 2000; however, he suffered financial difficulties and in order to find work was required to work all over the State. He knew the home was in need of maintenance. He had tried to find a landscaper to maintain the property, but the company he hired, took care of the property once and had not maintained since. He had recently hired Grant’s Gardens to maintain the property and provide additional landscaping. Mrs. Shapiro commented that the Town’s concern at this point was to maintain the mowing. Dr. Kachinas replied he could do that. Mr. Younger suggested due to the circumstances, that the administrative costs be waived for this case.
Quintana, Jose Raul (verified) – Tampa, Orlando
By Jay Rogers
Published August 20, 2011
Killing Places:
All Women’s Health Center of Orlando
431 Maitland Ave
Altamonte Springs, FL 32701
(Works for Gary Dresden’s All Women’s Health Center abortion chain also possibly in Lakeland, Tampa and North Tampa.)
Offices:
505 Oakfield Drive
Brandon, FL 33511
215 Imperial Boulevard
Lakeland, FL 33803
203 W Bloomingdale Ave
Brandon, FL 33511
(Weight loss clinic)
Home: 12620 Catamaran Place, Tampa, FL 33618-8705

Abortionist Jose Raul Quintana leaves from All Women’s Health Center in Altamonte Springs.
Graduated from the University of Nicaragua.
Disciplinary action on file in Ohio and Florida:
This practitioner has indicated that he/she has had final disciplinary action taken against him/her within the previous 10 years by a licensing agency:
The following liability actions have been reported as required under section 456.049, F. S., within the previous 10 years:
Incident Date: 2/14/2000
County: ALACHUA
Judicial Case: 01-02-CA-3224
Settlement Date: 11/13/2003
Amount: $245,000.00
Policy Amount: $1,000,000.00
Quintana removed the wrong fallopian tube during an ectopic pregnancy procedure while working at Shand’s Hospital in Gainesville. It put a woman’s life in danger and rendered her sterile.
Taken By: Ohio State Medical Board
Date: 8/11/2006
Description of Disciplinary Action: Reprimand
Under Appeal: NO
Read the Letter of Reprimand from the state medical board of Ohio. According to the report Jose Raul Quintana lied on his application for his medical license in failing to disclose the following:
Dr. Quintana was REPRIMANDED by the State Medical Board of Ohio in 2006. The same year, he moved back to Tampa, Florida and became a full-time abortionist for Gary Dresden’s All Women’s Health Centers.
Jones, Malcolm Wells (verified) – Clearwater, Tampa, Lakeland
By Jay Rogers
Published August 19, 2011
Killing Places:
Countryside Women’s ObGyn Center
28960 US Highway 19 N #110
Clearwater, FL 33761
All Women’s Health Center of Tampa
3330 West Kennedy Boulevard
Tampa, FL 33609
All Women’s Health Center of North Tampa
14498 University Cove
Tampa, FL 33613
Women’s Center of Hyde Park
502 South Magnolia Avenue
Tampa, FL 33606
Lakeland Women’s Health Center
4444 South Florida Avenue
Lakeland, FL 33813-2159
Home: 3003 W Estrella St, Tampa, FL 33629
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
DOB: July 31, 1951
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Mississippi, Alabama
Malcolm Wells Jones works for the “Women’s Health Center” abortion chain owned by Gary Dresden. He could be the subject of a fictional novel. Click to enlarge image.
Cry for the Shadows by Phil Harris
Synopsis: Do you believe in the power of prayer? If thousands of believers from around the world asked God to change one man’s heart, what do you think might happen? Rebecca Hallsey, the director of a crisis pregnancy center, meets Dr. Malcolm Jones, a long-time abortion provider. She senses there may be hope for him, and sets the prayer machinery in motion. Malcolm endures horrifying dreams and is haunted by odd children who are strangely familiar.
A teenage couple deals with the consequences of a single lapse in judgment. A college student is raped and then finds out that her worst nightmare has come true. A single, middle-aged career woman learns that a short-term solution can begin a lifetime of heartache and regret. Intense fear and uncertainty are replaced by peace and understanding. Feelings of hate and self-condemnation are transformed by the loving Grace of God. Sara, Jeff, Sheila, Martha, Malcolm, Rebecca, Father John, and Pastor Pete are all waiting inside, ready to take you on a short journey through one of life’s most basic realities.
Now the really odd thing about this is that I emailed the author and he messaged me back saying that he researched the name very carefully to make sure it was not the name of any abortionist in order to avoid lawsuits. The interesting part about that answer is that it is a Christian novel that deals with prayer as a form of spiritual warfare in the conversion of an abortion doctor. The other odd coincidence is that the name of the fictional abortion clinic where “Malcolm P. Jones” works is “Women’s Health Center.” Malcolm W. Jones works at several abortion clinics named Women’s Health Center. The abortionist in the novel drives a “silver Escalade.” The real life Malcolm Jones drives a Silver Cadillac Escalade.
What are the chances?
Now pro-life evangelists in the Tampa Bay area have begun to pray that the real-life Malcolm will too have terrifying dreams.
Malcolm Jones’ Biography
Malcolm Wells Jones was born in July 31, 1951. That makes him a Leo, which connects him astrologically with his partner Peter Paul Leonardo, whose birthday is August 1957.
Jones entered graduate school in January 1973. He studied in Jackson, Mississippi and then did his internship in Jacksonville, Florida from 1977 to 1978. He began practicing medicine in 1979. He did his residency as an Ob/Gyn in Jacksonville form 1979 to 1981.
He married Mary Margaret Wade, a graphic designer and cartoonist. They lived in the art district of St Petersburg. They lived at 115 7th Ave NE, Saint Petersburg, Florida 33701.
View Larger Map
From: Mary Margaret Wade’s Obituary
Mary Wade was born in December 30th, 1948. She died in Durham North Carolina, Sunday, June 10, 2007. She worked in graphic design and cartooning in Washington, DC, Greensboro, N.C., St. Petersburg, Fla., and Atlanta, Ga., where she also taught art at The Atlanta School. She was known in the art world as a cartoonist.
A native of Winston-Salem, North Carolina, Mary Margaret Wade received a journalism degree from the University of Georgia and a Master of Education degree from Howard University. She taught art at the independent elementary school, the Atlanta School, and worked with artists’ book press Nexus Press. Wade moved to Durham, North Carolina in 1996 and was program director for Arts for Life-Duke, a program for children suffering life-threatening illnesses at Duke University Hospital. Several of her political cartoons and drawings appeared in Southline and were published by Gordon Lish in the early 1990s. Her work was also featured in a solo show at the TULA Foundation Gallery in Atlanta, 1992. Wade served on the board of the Cape Lookout Environmental Camp and the Resource Center for Women and Ministry in the South, and was the Board President of Solterra.
Collection contains personal correspondence, photographs, writings and drawings, subject files, ephemera, and clippings. The photographs document Wade’s personal life, her art exhibits, and trips to Cuba, Alaska, and Costa Rica. The drawings and writings primarily consist of published versions and drafts of cartoons, as well as some manuscripts of writings and drawings for texts, including the artwork for Have You Ever Seen an Ugly Bride?, an unpublished book by Wade and Elizabeth Lide. The subject files include a file for the Resource Center for Women and Ministry in the South, an abortion rights petition signed by Norma McCorvey, and typescripts documenting the Kilbuck family, who were ancestors of Wade’s that were missionaries in Alaska. Acquired as part of the Sallie Bingham Center for Women’s History and Culture.
Her papers are in the special collections department at Duke University, the Mary Margaret Wade papers. She appears to have been a liberal “Christian” — the daughter of missionaries, who was involved in legalizing abortion in the early 1970s. The collection contains several boxes.
Malcolm Jones and Mary Wade were divorced in 1987. The divorce records are in Hillsborough County (Tampa).
Then there appears a listing for Malcolm W Jones at 336 20th Ave NE, Saint Petersburg, FL 33704. This address is within a few blocks the home he shared with Mary Wade. He likely moved here in the early late 1980s after his divorce. This is the “art district” of St. Petersburg, the typical homosexual community with a strong spirit of witchcraft.
Malcolm then appears with his name on an apartment on Bayshore Boulevard in Tampa for 14 years. His parents and a daughter (or niece) lived there since 1997. Another man named Peter Paul Leonardo has also been listed at this address.
Malcolm Jones and Pete Leonardo own a 2,291 sq ft home at 3003 West Estrella Street Tampa, FL 33629. They have owned the home since 1999.
Malcolm Jones and Pete Leonardo also own a Madeira Beach condo, 12935 Gulf Lane, Apt 301, Saint Petersburg, FL 33708. They have owned this property since 2005.
Here are two recent photos of Malcolm Jones and Pete Leonardo at a Simon-Ticket Mercedes-Benz of Tampa in June of 2011.

CAPTION: Congratulations to my good customers and great friends Pete & Malcolm. Malcolm took delivery of the first new body style 2012 SLK350 sold at Mercedes-Benz of Tampa. Delivery on June 4th, 2011.

CAPTION: What’s this? Back so soon? Not to be left out Pete took delivery of the first new bodystyle 2012 CLS550 sold at Mercedes-Benz of Tampa. Thanks again Pete and Malcolm – see you soon.
Guerrero (Dye), Candace M. (owner) – Fort Pierce
By Jay Rogers
Published August 18, 2011
Killing Place:
A Woman’s World Medical Center
503 S. 12th St.
Fort Pierce, Florida 34950
Home:
2264 SW Halissee St.
Port St. Lucie, FL 34953

Candace Dye, director of A Woman’s World abortion clinic in Ft. Pierce.
A Woman’s World is the only abortion clinic in St. Lucie county and has received numerous violations from the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration.
Mrs. Guerrero, who often still uses her maiden name and other aliases on official records (see below), born 10/15/1956, was married to Arnold Guerrero 12/31/1996.
Aliases: Candace M. Dye, Candance L. Dye, Candace L. Dye, Candace Levenette Dye, Candace M. Guerrero
“12th and Delaware”:
A Woman’s World Medical Center along with Pregnancy Care Medical Center, was featured in the recent HBO documentary 12th and Delaware.
A Woman’s World Medical Center was also the location where more than 300 pro-life citizens on the Treasure Coast gather for the first annual Treasure Coast March for Life held January 22, 2011.
Behind the Door: What Really Goes on Inside an Abortion Clinic
By Anne C. Lotierzo
It’s 2012. She’s been in business since 1991. And she still can’t get it right.
Candace Dye, owner and administrator of “A Woman’s World Medical Center” – the Treasure Coast’s only operating abortion clinic, was recently visited by an inspector from Florida’s Agency for Health Care Administration. The visit marked the fourth year in a row that deficiencies were noted in the clinic’s operation, and yet, the clinic remains in business.
Ambulance Takes Woman from Fort Pierce Abortion Clinic
By Bryan Longworth, February 7th, 2011
Saturday morning, February 5, 2011, an ambulance was called to A Woman’s World Medical Center, in Fort Pierce, Florida to take one of the clients to the Lawnwood Hospital Emergency Room. Medical personnel held a sheet over the mom as she was placed in the ambulance. It is not known what happened or the condition of the patients (mom and baby).
Jim Thoma, who witnessed the paramedics cart the mother into the ambulance, commented, “It’s important for people to see how dangerous abortions are for the woman, especially at A Woman’s World where they have been consistently sited for being in violation of health codes when inspected. Please pray for the mother and that this will help shut A Woman’s World down!”
Family Research Council Reviews 12th and Delaware
A number of media outlets have written about a documentary on an abortion clinic and a pregnancy resource center (PRC) in Ft. Pierce, Florida, “12th and Delaware.”
Featured on HBO on August 2nd, 2010, the movie was hailed by groups such as NARAL Pro Choice America, who encouraged its followers to organize 12th and Delaware viewing parties. Although the movie is strongly advocated by abortion-rights groups, Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady, the producers – who also produced the movie Jesus Camp – make the (hard-to-believe) claim that the documentary is neutral and unbiased.
In truth, the movie appears to be another attempt to antagonize and attack the positive and life-affirming work of PRCs. The producers have a strong anti-life agenda and were not honest, nor transparent about their plans with the participants from the Pregnancy Care Center in Ft. Pierce. Reportedly Anne Lotierzo, Executive Director of the PRC that was filmed, was not shown an accurate version of the documentary as was promised, nor was she told that the abortion clinic across the street would also be filmed for the documentary. See Human Life International’s press release for more information
Care Net, a group representing over 1000 life-affirming PRCs issued a release on the movie, including the following quote: “if you watch the film, we challenge you to take notes and do your own research. Visit your local pregnancy center and find out about their work for yourself. Perhaps you’ve been a client of a pregnancy center yourself – what did you experience? We encourage you to share your story and let the truth be told.”
For the real story behind the heroic work of PRCs, visit A Passion to Serve, A Vision for Life.
Graber, Benjamin (verified) – Coral Springs
By Jay Rogers
Published August 18, 2011
Killing Place:
Women’s Awareness of Coral Springs*
2929 N University Drive, Suite 202
Coral Springs, FL 33065-5047
Home:
231 174th St, Apt 1116
North Miami Beach, FL
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: May 1948
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Coral Springs Medical Center, Coral Springs
Imperial Point Medical Center, Fort Lauderdale
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: New York, Texas, New Jersey
Florida Abortionist Ben Graber has a radio show, “The Dr. Ben Graber Gynecology Hour” on 850 WFTL AM Radio Sunday’s at 1 PM.
Broward County Commissioner Ben Graber
by George Bennett | January 21st, 2010
According to reports, Democratic congressional hopeful and abortionist, Ben Graber, faced state Sen. Ted Deutch in a [losing] bid for special Feb. 2 primary for the former seat of former U.S. Rep. Robert Wexler, says he’ll remove figures from his campaign Web site and Facebook page that suggest there’s an Associated Press “poll” that shows him getting 54 percent of the vote. The AP says Graber came across purely fictitious numbers that AP sent to its newspaper, radio and TV clients this week as a pre-election test to make sure their computer systems are prepared to handle returns.

Who is Broward County Florida Democrat Ben Graber?
Ben Graber is an abortionist who in 1988, examined a 10-year-old girl whose father brought her in pregnant.
Graber performed an abortion on the child and returned her to the father who was later accused of raping her.
Despite mandatory reporting laws in the state of Florida, Graber did not inform the state of the possibility of incest at the time of the abortion, according to news reports.
Officials were never notified of the suspicion of abuse by Graber but found out only when hospital ER physicians examined the sister of the 10-year-old that Graber aborted who was taken to the emergency room for medical care.
By the time child protective services reached the children (ages: 12, 10, 8 and 7) and news reports indicated that the father had allegedly molested most of them.
This was two-years after the father brought the pregnant 10-year-old to Graber, for the abortion.
Joanne Richter, executive director of the Broward County Sexual Assault Treatment Center stated to the press that Graber should have been aware of the possibility of sexual abuse and called authorities.
Graber never faced any charges for failing to report the sexual abuse of this child. Some believe that his connections as a Florida State House Representative at the time played a role in the decision to not prosecute.
Years later, when abortionist Benjamin Graber decided to close one of his Graber Gynecological Affiliates medical offices in Pompano Beach, Florida where he performed abortions, he sought out another doctor to sub-lease the office, because he was still under a lease contract with the owners.
Graber arranged to sublease the office to another abortionist by the name of Vladimar Rosenthal who owned the Today’s Women’s Medical Centers (abortion clinics) in South Florida.
The Miami Herald had earlier reported that several former employees of Rosenthal went to the Herald complaining that that the conditions at Rosenthal’s clinics were not good for patients. The employees showed the paper records that Rosenthal was paying them commission to sell anesthesia at the door. The state inspected Rosenthal’s abortion clinic and found several obscene pictures of unconscious women with their legs apart belonging to Rosenthal’s male nurse.
Employees said they were fired when Rosenthal was told that they had complained about the conditions at the clinic to the National Abortion Federation.
Despite the fact that the above allegations were reported in South Florida newspapers, and on record with the State Department of Professional Regulations, Graber chose Rosenthal to sublease his office. In a letter explaining to the owner of the building why Graber chose to sublease the facility to Rosenthal, Graber described Rosenthal as, “an excellent tenant who has been successfully in practice for a number of years.”
Gonzalez, Belkis (owner) – Hialeah
By Jay Rogers
Published August 18, 2011
Killing Place:
A Gyn Diagnostic Center
267 East 49th Street
Hialeah, FL 33013-1854
Belkis Gonzalez is the owner of an abortion clinic in Hialeah who pled guilty to performing abortions without a medical license. She is on probation, but cannot work in the medical field. Her daughter, Natali Vergara, now runs her chain of clinics.

One of the mug shots from Belkis Gonzalez’ several arrests.
Baby Trashed After Botched Abortion
MIAMI – A Hialeah abortion clinic owner’s lawyer this afternoon said his client will plead not guilty to accusations she delivered a live baby during a botched procedure and then threw the infant away.
“We will vigorously fight these charges,” said Alberto Milian, a Coral Gables lawyer representing Belkis Gonzalez, 43, of Miramar.
Gonzalez was arrested Tuesday and charged with practicing medicine without a license and tampering with evidence, both felonies, said Ed Griffith, a spokesman for the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s office. If found guilty, Gonzalez would face at least a year in prison and up to 15 years. The teenage mother, Sycloria Williams, has filed a lawsuit alleging that Gonzalez knocked the infant off the chair where she had given birth, and then scooped the baby, placenta and afterbirth into a red plastic biohazard bag, and threw it out.
The clinic’s doctor, Dr. Pierre Jean-Jacque Renelique, had been scheduled to perform the procedure, but Williams went into labor after being given drugs to dilate her cervix and waiting for hours for Renelique to arrive, the suit said. The doctor has said he had been on his way to the Hialeah clinic when he was called to treat another patient who was bleeding. Last month, the Board of Medicine revoked Renelique’s license for committing medical malpractice, delegating responsibility to unlicensed personnel and failing to keep an accurate medical record. Williams was 23 weeks pregnant when the incident happened in 2006.
The Department of Health account continues as follows: Just before noon she began to feel ill. The clinic contacted Renelique. Two hours later, he still hadn’t shown up. Williams went into labor and delivered the baby.
“She came face to face with a human being,” Pennekamp said. “And that changed everything.”
At 23 weeks, an otherwise healthy fetus would have a slim but legitimate chance of survival. Quadruplets born at 23 weeks last year at The Nebraska Medical Center survived. An autopsy determined Williams’ baby — she named her Shanice — had filled her lungs with air, meaning she had been born alive, according to the Department of Health. The cause of death was listed as extreme prematurity. The case has riled the anti-abortion community, which contends the clinic’s actions constitute murder.
“The baby was just treated as a piece of garbage,” said Tom Brejcha, president of The Thomas More Society, a law firm that is also representing Williams. “People all over the country are just aghast.”
Even those who support abortion rights are concerned about the allegations.
Gil, Magaly (owner) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published August 18, 2011
Killing Places:
Best Care Woman’s Center (closed!)
8380 SW 8th Street
Miami, FL 33144
Millennium Women Center
9370 SW 72nd St # A104
Miami, FL 33173-5470
Hialeah Women’s Center
952 East 25th Street
Hialeah, FL 33013-3404
Home:
8124 SW 199th Terrace
Miami, FL 33189
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
YOB: November 1948
Certified nurse and x-ray machine operator
Clinic’s two owners arrested
Miami Herald Tues, July 19, 2005
By Mary Ellen Klas, Herald Editor
Magaly Gil was the owner of a Miami abortion clinic that was closed after it lost its license and it’s owners were arrested in the second case involving the same unlicensed doctor performing abortions.
Jose Rodriguez, 52, and Magaly Gil, 56, both of Miami, were arrested and released on $5,000 bond after detectives concluded that they knew Kieron Nisbet was not licensed to practice medicine in Florida, Nisbet is alleged to have performed abortions in November at their clinic, Best Care Woman’s Center, 8380 SW Eighth Street.” Sgt. Llevat of Miami-Dade unlicensed practitioner’s unit (305) 477-1616 says that Gil and Rodriguez were arrested for “aiding and abetting.” When asked if administrator Siomara Senises could be charged for the same offense, Sgt. Llevat said, “It’s in the Florida Statutes and Senises used three unlicensed people at her clinic also.”
Friefeld, Richard Stuart (verified) – North Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published July 15, 2011
Killing Places:
Blue Coral Women’s Care
7360 Coral Way #16
Miami, FL 33155-1482
Eve of Kendall
8603 South Dixie Highway
Miami, FL 33143-7807
Office:
Obstetrics & Gynecology Associates
16601 Northeast 19th Avenue
North Miami Bch, FL 33162-3149
Home:
110 Dockside Circle
Weston, FL 33327
YOB: c. 1945
Richard S Friefeld MD is a private company categorized under Abortion Information and Services and located in Miami, Florida established in 1999.
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions:
Palmetto General Hospital, Hialeah
Miramar Memorial Hospital, Miramar
Dr. Richard Stuart Friefeld is affiliated with 9 hospitals, including Aventura Hospital and Medical Center.
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: New York, North Carolina
Jewish; speaks Italian and Spanish
Fanarjian, Nicole Joy (verified) – Sarasota
By Jay Rogers
Published July 15, 2011
Killing Places:
Planned Parenthood: Sarasota Health Center
736 Central Avenue
Sarasota, FL 34236
YOB: July 1968
Newest Skill for Future Ob-Gyns: Abortion Training
By Linda Villarosa
Published: June 11, 2002
Like just about every fourth-year medical student, Nicole Fanarjian recently made the rounds of hospitals in search of a residency program that would train her for her specialty: obstetrics-gynecology. This spring, she visited 13 programs, and in nearly every interview, she asked this direct, but sometimes eyebrow-raising question: ‘“Do you provide residents with abortion training?”
“I am planning to be an ob-gyn, and I intend to provide the full range of reproductive services, including abortion,” said Ms. Fanarjian, 33, who will begin her residency at the University of South Florida in Tampa next month. “I want to be exposed to the procedure, because I strongly believe that if you go into this specialty, you should feel comfortable providing abortions.”
Elneser, Rafael M (verified) - Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published July 14, 2011
Killing Places:
Top-Gyn Ladies Center
4391 West Flagler Street
Coral Gables, FL 33134-1554
Blue Coral Women’s Care
7360 Coral Way #16
Miami, FL 33155-1482
Millennium Women Center
9370 SW 72nd St # A104
Miami, FL 33173-5470
Home:
YOB: c. 1939 (Entered School of Medicine of Valencia, Valencia, Spain in 1960)
From Spain
Discipline on file.
Miami: The legalized back-alley abortion capital
Hialeah’s A Gyn Diagnostic Center is one of three Miami area abortion mills owned and operated by Belkis Gonzales and Siomara Senises.
Their Miramar mill was shut down last year after police caught three of their employees committing abortions without licenses. They were janitor Adieren Rojas, abortionist Robelto Osborne and University of Miami medical student Kieron Nisbet.
Osborne lost his license in 2004 for puncturing a mother’s uterus during an abortion, not treating it, and failing to return her calls complaining of extreme pain and bleeding. She required the removal of retained fetal parts and a hysterectomy. Records also show Osborne botched an abortion in 1996 by damaging the small intestine of an 18-year-old.
Nisbet functioned in the mill as an anesthesiologist. With a warrant out for his arrest, Nisbet continued anesthetizing as well as aborting at nearby Best Care Women’s Center in Miami. When police closed in, he fled the country and is believed to now be hiding in his native Trinidad.
Police arrested Best Care’s owners, Magaly Gil and Jose Rodriguez. They turned in their license for that mill, and all was forgiven. But Gil still owns and operates two other Miami area abortion mills, Millennium Women Center and Hialeah Women’s Center.
Egherman, William Phillip (deceased) - Gainesville
By Jay Rogers
Published July 14, 2011
Killing Places:
Aware Woman Center for Choice
1564 Dixie Way
Melbourne, FL 32935
Orlando Women’s Center
1103 Lucerne Terrace
Orlando, FL 32806-1016
Home:
4830 Northwest 43rd Street
Gainesville, FL 32606
DOB: October 3, 1953
Death April 3, 2010
This practitioner has indicated the following additional state licensure: Ohio, Indiana.
Here are the 911 calls resulting from Egherman’s work in Melbourne, Florida.
The image of Egherman at the end of this video was posted on what became known as Jay’s Killer Web Page in 1997. This website soon grew into a listing of every killer who had ever worked at Aware Woman Center for Choice in Melbourne, Florida and later spawned this listing of all known abortionists in the state of Florida.
A Brief History
Abortionist William P. Egherman started butchering unborn children at Aware Woman in Melbourne, Florida in January of 1997. In the 17 months between March 29, 1997 and September 4, 1998, 5 women were sent or taken to the emergency room by abortionist Egherman. No disciplinary actions have been taken.
This story starts on March 18, 1997, less than 3 months after abortionist Egherman started working at Aware Woman when we got a message on our answering machine from a young mother who had suffered a botched abortion at Aware Woman the previous January. She was responding to one of many letters that we sent to Aware Woman patients offering help with problems after abortion.
On March 29, 1997 the first ambulance showed up at Aware Woman. The Aware Woman worker who made the 911 call asked for the ambulance to come with “no lights and no sirens.” It seems Aware Woman is more concerned about their own image than about the safety of their patients. This mother, Jane Roe II, suffered a perforated uterus and intestine. She spent a week in the hospital and was out of work for 6 weeks.
On July 4, 1997, (yes, they were butchering on Independance Day) the second ambulance showed up at Aware Woman. This mother was loaded into the ambulance with IV’s already in place. We have no further information on this mother.
On December 12, 1997, the third ambulance showed up at Aware Woman more than 45 minutes after abortionist Egherman had left for the day. A black mother in her mid thirties was taken away.
On January 31, 1998, about 7 pm, after dark, abortionist Egherman loaded the fourth patient into his own car and took her to the emergency room himself. He stayed less than 30 minutes and left her there. We know who this mother is but she is not willing to file a complaint against abortionist Egherman. This happens way too often and allows these butchers to continue their butchery. People who observed the events did file complaints about improper medical procedures but nothing was done about it.
On September 4, 1998, an ambulance showed up to take the fifth patient to the emergency room. This time, Aware Woman’s owner, Patricia Windle showed up at the emergency room with her lawyer, Roy Lucas, to make sure no one found out the mother’s identity to offer her real help.
That’s it – five emergency room visits in 17 months. How many more before somebody does something about it.
William Philip Egherman shockingly has left a trail of injured women. He has been exposed to the public through this video series. So much for wanting to keep abortion “safe, legal and rare”!
We later discovered that Egherman, now working at Orlando Women’s Center, was the man who performed an abortion on Kelly Clinger, who years later was powerfully converted to Christ and has written about her experience. She has since become a sought after pro-life speaker and musician.
Note: William Egherman died on April 3, 2010.
Related Articles
Dresden, Scott Charles (verified) – Delray Beach
By Jay Rogers
Published July 12, 2011
This is the son of Gary Dresden. The following address is likely a PO Box.
1730 South Federal Highway
Suite #317
Delray Beach, FL 33483
YOB: c. 1965
This practitioner currently holds staff privileges at the following hospital/medical/health institutions: Edward White Hospital, 2323 9th Avenue North St. Petersburg, FL 33713, (727) 323-1111
Son of All Women’s Health Center abortion chain owner, Gary Dresden.
Dresden, Gary (verified, owner) – Clearwater, Tampa
By Jay Rogers
Published July 12, 2011
Killing Places:
All Women’s Health Center of Jacksonville
4331 University Blvd South
Jacksonville, FL 32216
All Women’s Health Center of Gainesville
1135 NW 23rd Avenue, Ste N
Gainesville, FL 32609
All Women’s Health Center of Orlando
431 Maitland Avenue
Altamonte Springs, FL 32701
Lakeland Women’s Health Center
4444 South Florida Avenue
Lakeland, FL 33813
All Women’s Health Center of North Tampa
14498 University Cove
Tampa, FL 33613
All Women’s Health Center of Tampa
3330 West Kennedy Boulevard
Tampa, FL 33609
Countryside Women’s ObGyn Center
28960 US Highway 19 N #110
Clearwater, FL 33761
All Women’s Health Center
4131 Central Avenue
Saint Petersburg, FL 33713
All Women’s Health Center of Sarasota
2700 South Tamiami Trail, Suite 5
Sarasota, FL 34239
Women’s Health Center of Ft. Myers
3900 Broadway
Fort Myers, FL 33901
Main office:
2106 Drew Street #103
Clearwater, FL 33765
Home:
2755 Bullard Drive
Clearwater, FL 33762
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map

Gary Dresden’s 9,497 square foot home.

Gary Dresden, YOB: April 1941
Confessions of a Gynecologist
Book by Gary Dresden
Amazon.com Review – Apparently the editor at the publishing house was asleep the day this manuscript was printed and bound. This is one of the poorest examples of writing I have ever read in published form. As if that wasn’t bad enough, it reads like some spoiled egomaniac’s view of life. Everything good was of his making and every witty remark was attributed to him, whereas all that was negative, ill-conceived or stupid was generated by everyone else around him. His sexual prowess and ability to dazzle the reader with his brilliance was all the author seemed to want to convey. I was bored silly. There are too many great, or even entertaining books, out there to waste time on trash like this. I learned nothing of the medical field that was helpful.
December
Gary Dresden is the film producer and writer of a semi-autobiographical story about the relationship between a son and a father who is dying of cancer.
The Victim
Gary Dresden’s other movie was The Victim, a story about a man who is raped by a woman.
The Victim: Synopsis
Two girls, Naomi and Dawn, meet two football players, Brett and Jason, while on vacation. On one fateful night, Naomi is raped Brett. In a different room, simultaneously, Dawn forces herself on Jason who is married and an unwilling partner. Questions arise of whether or not women should be held accountable of their actions if they are not raping someone ‘physically’.
Forms: Short
Genres: Drama, Crime
Cast & Crew
Production
Gary Dresden (Director (1st Project), Producer)
Writing
Gary Dresden (Writer)
Cast
Keri Lurtz (Lead Actor), Lincoln Potwin (Lead Actor)
Camera
Matt Miller (Cinematographer/DP)
Post Production
Keri Lurtz (Editor, Sound Editor, Digital Effects)
Related Articles
DeHaan, Quentin C (verified) – Clearwater, Tampa
By Jay Rogers
Published July 12, 2011
Killing Places:
Bread and Roses Woman’s Health Center
1560 South Highland Avenue
Clearwater, FL 33756
Tampa Woman’s Health Center
2010 E Fletcher Ave.
Tampa, FL 33612-3712
St Petersburg Woman’s Health Center
3401 66th Street North,
St. Petersburg, FL 33710-1540
Home:
20615 County Line Rd
Lutz, FL 33558
View Florida Abortionists in a larger map
DOB: January 1924
Quentin DeHaan, age 88, leaves Bread and Roses abortion mill in Clearwater, Florida. (Click to enlarge)
Davy, Kristin (owner) - Gainesville
By Jay Rogers
Published July 12, 2011
Killing Place:
Bread & Roses Women’s Health
1560 South Highland Avenue
Clearwater, FL 33756-2372
Home:
More Than One Million Floridians Urge Gov. Crist to VETO HB 1143
LinkedIn.com
Director at Bread and Roses
Director at GWConsultancy
Director at GWC, LLC
Bread and Roses statement of deficiencies form
Cohan, Carol (promoter) – Miami
By Jay Rogers
Published July 11, 2011
Office:
Women’s Emergency Network, Inc. (WEN)
7400 SW 88th Street, Suite 307B
Miami, FL 33156
The pro bono executive director of Women’s Emergency Network (WEN), an abortion fund in Miami, Florida. She manages all facets of the organization including client care, coordination with clinics, volunteer force, and all administrative and fundraising activities.
Under her leadership, WEN’s operating budget increased from $60,000 per year to $250,000 per year and WEN’s client capacity increased from 170 to over 900. She has built a coalition of reproductive rights advocates and organizations to prevent passage of 2004 parental notification law, and when that law was passed, organized the first attorney assistance for minor girls seeking judicial waivers, a project which developed into the Florida Path Project providing pro-bono assistance for girls seeking judicial bypass throughout the State of Florida.
She also spearheaded a coalition to improve access to emergency contraception for low-income women, developing a multi-media awareness campaign, including a dedicated website www.ecnow.org, which was adopted by 17 communities nationwide. She has been an inspiration to board members of abortion funds throughout Florida and the United States.
In conjunction with her leadership of WEN, Carol sits on the board of the National Network of Abortion Funds, where she co-chaired the Emergency Contraception Task Force. She is also a member of the Ethics Committee of the Health Council of South Florida, the Florida Healthy Teens Coalition, and the Florida Prevention First Coalition.
In addition, she served on Congresswoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz’s Health Care Working Group, the Steering Committee of the Low Income Access Program of the National Institute for Reproductive Health, the Florida State Coalition for Women’s Health, and the planning committee of the Florida Abortion Conversation Project. She is a 2007 recipient of the National Council of Jewish Women’s Woman of Valor award.
Why We List Abortionists
By Jay Rogers
Published July 10, 2011
Since 1996, The Forerunner has been listing abortionists on-line in order to expose their “fruitless deeds of darkness” (Ephesians 5:11). We publicly identify abortionists, abortion clinic owners and promoters. The practice of placing the names of abortionists on this website has a two-fold purpose:
1. To ask for your prayers for the conversion of those listed.
2. To expose OB-GYN abortionists to all their patients, especially to those who don’t know that they perform abortions.
We hope that Christians will genuinely reach out to these individuals in a spirit of love with a message of redemption through Jesus Christ. The purpose is never to harrass, threaten or intimidate. We have written articles and position papers condemning any sort of violent threats or intimidation toward anyone involved in abortion.
Why We List Abortionists (1998)
A friend of mine found an email I received back in 1998 and the response I wrote. What amazes me is that I recently picked up the vision again for the Florida Murder Industry website and I still sound a lot like I did back in 1998.
As far as I know, a group of us in Melbourne, Florida were the first pro-life activists to create a website listing abortionists’ information that we culled from various public sources. At the time, it was newsworthy and was mentioned in at least one major feminist magazine, Madamoiselle, and in the local press. Here is someone claiming to be a journalist asking for quotes for an article of some type. – JCR
——-Original Message——- From: Jay Rogers [mailto:jrogers@iu.net] Sent: Monday, November 02, 1998 11:58 AM To: Marian Jones Subject: Re: Web site
Dear Mr. Rogers:
I am a journalist doing a story about violence at abortion clinics, and the response of people on both sides of the debate in the wake of the latest violence. I am writing to ask you about your web site, specifically why you have the names and home phone numbers of abortionists on the site. — Also, was wondering what you think about the abortion-clinic violence.
Sincerely, Marian Jones mjones@newscorp.com
——————————————————————
Dear Marian,
I condemn all abortion clinic violence. I do not wish harm to come to any abortion doctor, patient or unborn child.
I own a house across the street from a well-known abortion clinic in Melbourne, Florida, Aware Woman Center for Choice. From there I am involved in various Christian media endeavors as well as helping to establish a pro-life crisis pregnancy outreach.
For years, I have been concerned about the number of women injured by this particular clinic. The doctors recruited by the clinic are known as “butchers” in the abortion industry. A few years ago, one woman, Maureen Tyke, died after an abortion at Aware Woman. In the last two years, at least four women have been taken to the hospital in ambulances with injuries. Two were believed to have had perforated uteruses. On woman called the local pro-life group to say that she had delived her premature baby in a toilet after supposedly having had an abortion at Aware Woman.
Sadly, these stories are common. Abortion may be legal, but it is not safe.
The local pro-life group in Melbourne has been effective in getting many abortionists to quit coming to Melbourne. This is done by peaceful, legal, loving confrontation. We have gone to abortionist’s neighborhoods to picket at their houses. Two years ago, an abortion doctor in Jacksonville, Florida quit coming to Melbourne because we exposed the fact that he was an abortionist to his family, friends, neighbors, colleagues, and other patients.
This doctor was replaced by a full-time abortionist who we knew from various sources was flying down from Cincinnatti each week to perform abortions in Melbourne. The web site, “Melbourne’s Abortion Industry” was created two years ago as a way to identify him. This doctor has had a bad record with injuries of women. We had only a photo and physical description of the doctor. As a web site administrator, I had the idea of placing the photo on a web page and asking pro-lifers around the country if they knew who he was. We included a short physical description. We ascertained his identity within one week.
After identifying the doctor, we then set out to document the instances of life-threatening, illegal, unethical and unprofessional practices by the abortion clinic. These are legion. We included 911 emergency calls to the local hospital after women had been injured at Aware Woman;video files of ambulances arriving at the clinic; and testimonies of women who were injured at Aware Woman.
We also publish testimonies of women who chose life instead of abortion.
We believe that if women know the dangers of abortion to their physical, mental, emotional and spiritual well-being, some will seek alternatives. The web site does not encourage violence towards anyone. We want to protect women and unborn children.
We want unethical abortionists to be exposed to the public, to their family, neighbors, friends, and especailly their patients. Most obstetrician- gynecologists have pro-life patients who abhor abortion. We want to let them know their doctor also performs abortions for money.
In the past few years, many abortionists and clinic workers have become Christians and have quit. Dr. Bernard Nathanson and Norma McCorvey (Jane Roe of Roe v. Wade) are two famous examples. They both testify that being confronted lovingly by pro-lifers led to their conversion. We hope that more abortionists will repent of the sin of abortion and become Christians.
Those who do not repent in their hearts must still be persuaded to stop doing abortions for a living. We try to make it easy for them to stop by exposing the fact that they are abortionists to their patients who are pro-life. Faced with the prospect of losing their pro-life patients, many abortionists quit doing abortions.
We give them a clear choice. Either they will stop coming to Melbourne to do abortions or they will have to become full-time abortionists. Faced with these two options, we believe that most will quit coming to Melbourne.
We publish the names, addresses, and phone numbers of abortionists, because we want them to be ashamed of exposure. We want Christians who live in their area to peacefully and lovingly confront them. Many abortionists are ashamed of what they do. They will quit if they are exposed to the public. We have removed this more personal information of abortionists who have quit coming to Melbourne.
With the information super-highway expanding at a phenomenal rate, this type of web site will soon become common. Soon there will be information about every abortionist in America posted on the world wide web. Faced with this exposure, young OB-GYN interns coming out of medical school will have to decide if they want to face public scrutiny. Abortion may be legal, but many people believe that it is an evil, abhorrent practice. It is still a moral wrong in God’s sight and is synonymous with child murder — one of the most execrable villainies known to man.
We do not want any person to be harmed. At the web site, we have prominently published a biblical rationale against those who act as “vigilantees” and shoot abortionists calling it “justifiable homicide.” This act is as abhorrent as abortion. We hope that these murderers will be tried and punished for their crime.
However, given the fact that abortion is the killing of unborn children, we take this seriously too. We don’t let unstable and violent vigilantees influence our peaceful protest against abortion. Nor do we let the abortion industry paint us as violent or hateful. We peacefully resist abortion while trying to demonstrate the love of Jesus Christ to those who would repent and believe in Him.
- Jay Rogers, Web site host Melbourne’s Abortion Industry
See how the web site looked back in 1998.
Behind The Scenes
By Jay Rogers
Published July 10, 2011
The following are links to articles explaining step-by-step how we gathered some of the information included here. The lists cover only Florida, but we hope that others will apply these principles to mapping the abortion industry in their own states and regions.














