By Editorial Staff
Published January 3, 2001
By Rick Cundiff, Staff Writer, Ocala Star Banner
OCALA — With abortion-rights supporters picketing outside the courthouse and abortion opponents picketing his clinic two blocks away, the federal extortion trial of Dr. James Scott Pendergraft IV began Tuesday.
Jury selection concluded Tuesday afternoon and Senior U.S. District Judge William Terrell Hodges set opening statements for 9 a.m. today.
Pendergraft and his associate, Michael Spielvogel, were indicted in Pendergraft and his associate, Michael Spielvogel, were indicted in federal court on June 13. The five-count indictment alleges that the two men conspired to extort millions of dollars from Marion County government by making false and fraudulent statements in a lawsuit Pendergraft filed in December 1998. Hodges dismissed the lawsuit a year later because Pendergraft and attorney Roy Lucas failed to pursue it.
The indictment alleges Pendergraft and Spielvogel lied in the lawsuit by saying County Commissioner Larry Cretul threatened Spielvogel and the clinic. The indictment also alleges that Pendergraft and Spielvogel threatened, through Lucas, to bankrupt the county by asking for a $100 million judgment.
Both men are charged with conspiracy to commit extortion, lying under oath and mail fraud. Spielvogel faces additional charges of offering false testimony and making false statements to FBI investigators. If convicted, Pendergraft faces up to 30 years in prison and $750,000 in fines, while Spielvogel could face up to 40 years and $1.25 million in fines.
Carrying signs reading “Stop the Injustice” and “Keep Abortion Legal,” several protesters marched outside the federal courthouse on Northwest Second Street as the trial began. At the same time, abortion foes marched outside Pendergraft’s Ocala Women’s Center at 108 N.W. Pine Ave., carrying signs that read “Abortion Kills Children” and “Ocala’s Auschwicz.”
About a dozen of Pendergraft’s supporters, nearly all from out of town, sat in the courtroom, which remained calm throughout the day. Pendergraft operates four other women’s clinics in Florida.
From an initial pool of three dozen, prosecutors and defense attorneys agreed on a dozen jurors by 3:15 p.m. Two alternate jurors came from another pool of nine people.
The jury, including alternates, has nine women and five men.
Pendergraft’s attorneys, Larry Colleton and Jacob Rose, and Spielvogel’s attorney, Daniel Brodersen, had asked Hodges for permission to question prospective jurors individually, rather than as a group, about their views on abortion. Hodges rejected the request in December
He asked the prospective jurors to raise their hands if they had strong convictions about abortion or if they had ever participated in any organization or group that took a stand on either side of the abortion issue.
Hodges then questioned individually the jurors who raised their hands about whether they would be able to render an impartial verdict.
By the time Hodges recessed the court for lunch, Pendergraft’s supporters were flying a large balloon over the Ocala Women’s Center. At a press conference there, Pendergraft’s lawyers and supporters portrayed the case as a vindictive prosecution in retaliation for his lawsuit.
“Dr. Pendergraft is a hero for continuing to provide full reproductive health care services to women in Florida, in a hostile and dangerous environment,” said Carla Josephson, president of the Orlando-area chapter of the National Organization for Women.
“It is clear that this prosecution is a new tactic being used to eliminate providers and further limit women’s access to reproductive health care.”
Representatives of the National Abortion Federation, the Center for Reproductive Law and Policy, and Medical Students for Choice, among others, read prepared statements supporting Pendergraft.
Steve Cole, spokesman for Assistant U.S. Attorneys Mark Devereaux and Judy Hunt, declined to comment on allegations that the case was politically motivated.
“The only comments that we’re going to make regarding this trial are going to be inside the courtroom,” Cole said. On the street outside the clinic, Marion County Right-To-Life President Ed Martin said the case wasn’t about abortion.
“If he tried to extort money from Ocala or Marion County, then he needs to be convicted,” Martin said. “This doesn’t have anything at all to do with abortion.”
Judge Hodges told prospective jurors that abortion wasn’t the issue in the case.
“The case itself has nothing to do one way or the other with abortions, or with withholding abortions,” he said.
After the jury was selected and sent home for the day, Hodges dealt setbacks for the defense. Pendergraft and Spielvogel’s lawyers had asked Hodges not to allow into evidence tapes of telephone conversations between Cretul and Spielvogel prior to February 1999. Hodges rejected that motion, though he said Colleton, Rose and Brodersen could raise objections during the trial.
The lawyers also tried to exclude an FBI videotape of the alleged settlement meeting at which Lucas and Pendergraft reportedly threatened to bankrupt the county. Rose said Lucas’ statements on the tape are hearsay evidence, and that Lucas, not Pendergraft, mentioned the $100 million figure.
Prosecutor Devereaux argued that Lucas had been acting as an official agent representing Pendergraft and Spielvogel and that, therefore, his comments on the tape were not hearsay. Brodersen, Spielvogel’s attorney, objected, saying there was no evidence Lucas ever represented Spielvogel.
Hodges rejected the defense motion to withhold the tape, again saying the lawyers could object to all or part of it during testimony.
In addition to Cretul, the list of potential witnesses includes Sheriff Ed Dean, Ocala Police Chief Morrey Deen, County Commissioners Steve Henning, Randy Harris and Parnell Townley, former County Commissioner Judy Johnson, several area ministers, Melbourne-based anti-abortion activist Meredith Raney, and Spielvogel’s wife.
Roy Lucas is not on the witness list. Despite international efforts to track him down, he hasn’t been seen for months, Rose said Tuesday afternoon.
“We have tried four different investigative agencies, an international association,” Rose said. “We just can’t find him.”
The trial is expected to last at least into next week.
Forerunner - Home » Florida's Murder Industry »
Your comments are welcome!
High Quality Paperback — 200 pages
A Reasonable Response to Christian Postmodernism
Includes a response to the book Christian Jihad by Colonel V. Doner
The title of this book is a misnomer. In reality, I am not trying to get anyone to shut up, but rather to provoke a discussion. This book is a warning about the philosophy of “Christian postmodernism” and the threat that it poses not only to Christian orthodoxy, but to the peace and prosperity our culture as well. The purpose is to equip the reader with some basic principles that can be used to refute their arguments.
Part 1 is a response to some of the recent writings by Frank Schaeffer, the son of the late Francis Schaeffer. This was originally written as a defense against Frank’s attacks on pro-life street activism – a movement that his father helped bring into being through his books, A Christian Manifesto, How Should We Then Live? and Whatever Happened to the Human Race? These works have impacted literally hundreds of thousands of Christian activists.
Part 2 is a response to Colonel Doner and his book, Christian Jihad: Neo-Fundamentalists and the Polarization of America. Doner was one of the key architects of the Christian Right that emerged in the 1980s, who now represents the disillusionment and defection many Christian activists experienced in the 1990s and 2000s. There is still great hope for America to be reformed according to biblical principles. As a new generation is emerging, it is important to recognize the mistakes that Christian activists have made in the past even while holding to a vision for the future.
$14.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)
High Quality Paperback — 40 pages of dynamite!
Revival, Resistance, Reformation, Revolution
An Introduction to the Doctrines of Interposition and Nullification
In 1776, a short time after the Declaration of Independence was adopted, Thomas Jefferson, John Adams and Benjamin Franklin were assigned to design an official seal for the United States of America. Their proposed motto was Rebellion to Tyrants is Obedience to God. America owes its existence to centuries of Christian political philosophy. Our nation provided a model for liberty copied by nations the world over.
By the 21st century, we need a “Puritan Storm” to sweep away the Hegelian notion that the state is “God walking on earth.” We need revival and reformation in full force to vanquish the problems that plague us as a nation — from government controlled healthcare — to abortion on demand — to same sex “marriage.” This booklet gives a primer on our founders’ Christian idea of government and examines how the doctrine of nullification was woven into the Constitution as a safeguard against federal tyranny. It concludes with the history and theology of civil resistance. A Second American Revolution is coming with the Word of God growing mightily and prevailing! (Acts 19:20).
$7.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)
Special Two-Disc Set!
After 40 years of intense study and world-wide ministry, Dr. Francis Schaeffer completed his crowning work of scholarship – to present profound truths in simple film language. Dr. Schaeffer’s brilliant analysis of the past and predictions for current trends have proven so uncannily accurate that this amazing series still feels contemporary almost three decades after its initial release. Ultimately, Schaeffer concludes that man’s only hope is a return to God’s Biblical absolute, the truth revealed in Christ through the Scriptures.
Available for the first time on DVD, this documentary spectacular also includes intimate in-depth conversations with Francis and Edith Schaeffer. With the on-disc study guide, this presentation forms a unique course of comprehensive study. While this series forms an innovative analysis of the past, this outstanding work is more than history. Each episode focuses on a significant era, yet speaks clearly to 21st-century man with answers for modern problems.
$49.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)
With “preaching to the lost” being such a basic foundation of Christianity, why do many in the church seem to be apathetic on this issue of preaching in highways and byways of towns and cities?
Is it biblical to stand in the public places of the world and proclaim the gospel, regardless if people want to hear it or not?
Does the Bible really call church pastors, leaders and evangelists to proclaim the gospel in the public square as part of obedience to the Great Commission, or is public preaching something that is outdated and not applicable for our day and age?
These any many other questions are answered in this documentary.
$19.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)
Who is the Real Jesus?
Ever since the dawn of modern rationalism, skeptics have sought to use textual criticism, archeology and historical reconstructions to uncover the “historical Jesus” — a wise teacher who said many wonderful things, but fulfilled no prophecies, performed no miracles and certainly did not rise from the dead in triumph over sin.
Over the past 100 years, however, startling discoveries in biblical archeology and scholarship have all but vanquished the faulty assumptions of these doubting modernists. Regrettably, these discoveries have often been ignored by the skeptics as well as by the popular media. As a result, the liberal view still holds sway in universities and impacts the culture and even much of the church.
The Real Jesus explodes the myths of these critics and the movies, books and television programs that have popularized their views. Presented in ten parts — perfect for individual, family and classroom study — viewers will be challenged to go deeper in their knowledge of Christ in order to be able to defend their faith and present the truth to a skeptical modern world – that the Jesus of the Gospels is the Jesus of history — “the same yesterday, today and forever” (Hebrews 13:8). He is the real Jesus.
Speakers include: George Grant, Ted Baehr, Stephen Mansfield, Raymond Ortlund, Phil Kayser, David Lutzweiler, Jay Grimstead, J.P. Holding, and Eric Holmberg.
Ten parts, over two hours of instruction!
Running Time: 130 minutes
$19.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)