By Editorial Staff
Published December 1, 1991
An experimental – and controversial – procedure for treating a crippling birth defect in the womb offered Trish and Mike Switzer the only chance that their daughter would walk like other children. But the fetal surgery posed a fatal dilemma: Their baby could die before she was born.
By Skip Hollandsworth, LIFE MAGAZINE
Photography by Max Aguilera-Hellweg
“It’s a girl,” said the technician operating the ultrasound machine, pointing at a computer screen that showed a tiny fetus wiggling inside the uterus of Trish Switzer.
“A girl?” said Trish, squeezing the hand of her husband, Army Maj. Mike Switzer. It was May 21, 1999, and Trish, expecting her first child at 34, was on an examining table at a prenatal clinic in Richmond undergoing the standard sonogram given to women around the 18th week of pregnancy. “A little girl?’ Trish asked again.
A minute passed as the technician kept studying the screen. Then another minute. Then several more. “Let me get the doctor,” said the technician softly, heading for the door.
What happened next was the nightmare dreaded by every couple expecting a child. A doctor walked into the room and said, “There are some problems.” The sonogram showed that the spine had not developed properly, leaving a small lesion on the lower half of the spinal cord. Because of the defect, fluid could not circulate properly in the fetus’s brain, resulting in a condition called hydrocephalus, a leading cause of brain damage. Already, the cerebellum, in the back part of the brain, had been squeezed down toward the neck. “No one can predict the outcome,” the doctor said, “but your child could be incontinent, paralyzed, perhaps even mentally retarded.” He paused. “I need to let you know that you have the option of genetic termination?
“Genetic termination?” asked Trish, trying to keep her voice in control.
“Yes. Terminating the pregnancy.”
It is a scene played out thousands of times a year: young couples, hoping to share their love for each other with a child, suddenly faced with a shattering new reality. The Switzers’ unborn daughter was afflicted with spina bifida, one of the most crippling of birth defects, which affects about 2,000 newborns a year in this country. (Estimates are that at least another 2,000 fetuses diagnosed with spina bifida are aborted every year.) Typically, spina bifida babies receive surgery within 48 hours after birth to close the opening on the spinal cord. But by then, most of the damage has been done. Although some spina bifida babies with lesser lesions can grow up to live relatively normal lives — walking with braces, controlling their bowels and going to regular schools — many are confined to wheelchairs, suffer from learning problems and must endure several operations during their lifetime to have shunts placed inside their brain to drain the excess spinal fluid that causes hydrocephalus.
“I suppose, like all new parents, we had imagined ourselves having the perfect child,” says Trish, who met Mike in 1996 at the Patuxent River Naval Air Station in Maryland. A civilian with bachelor’s and master’s degrees in engineering, Trish was at Patuxent training as a flight-test engineer. Mike, 35, a broad-shouldered West Point graduate, was there training to become a test pilot for experimental military aircraft. Mike had even submitted his application to NASA to become an astronaut. “We kept saying, ‘How did this happen to us?’” he recalls. “We were military types. We planned for everything. And then came this one act of, well, randomness.”
After looking at the image of the fetus in the sonogram — “this little helpless girl with a little tear in her back,” says Mike — they decided they could not go through with an abortion. They gave her a name: Sarah Marie Switzer. But they were unsure what to do next. “When I was alone, I’d whisper to her, ‘Come on, Sarah Marie, you can get better,’” says Trish. “Then I’d throw myself down on the bed and sob myself to sleep.”
A few days after the diagnosis, Trish’s mother called to say she had found a Web site set up by the Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville. Two doctors there had been attempting a daring new surgery, operating on spina bifida fetuses three to four months before the normal delivery date and sewing up the lesions while the fetuses were still in their mothers’ wombs. Although it will take years of further research before they can have conclusive results, Dr. Joseph Bruner, 46, an assistant professor of obstetrics and gynecology, and Dr. Noel Tulipan, 48, a quiet, well-regarded pediatric neurosurgeon, were claiming that the operations — at that point there had been fewer than 50 — seemed to prevent at least some of the damaging consequences of the defect. Some of the babies didn’t develop the kind of hydrocephalus that required shunts; others had more feeling in their legs than doctors originally expected; still others had no bowel problems.
The jubilant Switzers immediately E-mailed Bruner to discuss going to Nashville. But as the couple was about to discover, the surgery did not come without significant risks. In fact, the Switzers were about to embark on a journey that would test their faith not only in modern medicine but also in themselves. As Bruner gently told the Switzers in their first face- to-face meeting in June: “If you do not do the surgery, your baby will be born alive and could well well live a productive life. But if you go into contractions during surgery and deliver the baby prematurely — and there’s a chance you will — your baby could have some very serious problems and perhaps die. This is the dilemma for you: Whether the chance at a better lifestyle for your daughter is worth the risk of her death.”
When Bruner came to Vanderbilt in 1990, he was relatively unknown in the circles of academic medicine. After receiving his M.D. from the University of Nebraska, he had worked as an Army doctor at several military bases, where he specialized in analyzing sonograms of fetuses with birth defects “mainly because there was no one else around to do it.”
At Vanderbilt, Bruner spent much of his time working on the more difficult deliveries. One afternoon in 1992, in a hospital hallway, he met Tulipan, who had trained at Johns Hopkins University and had treated many spina bifida patients since coming to the medical center in 1985. Tulipan believed that if a spina bifida lesion could be repaired before birth, then at least the spinal cord would be protected from further nerve damage whenever the fetus bounced against the uterine wall. “The idea,” Tulipan recalls, “was that we could prevent enough of the secondary injuries, so that more spina bifida children would have a chance to walk.” The ambitious Bruner, who had been looking for an opportunity to try his hand at fetal surgery, suggested the two of them start working together.
For two years, the doctors stayed at the medical center late into the night, operating on the fetuses of pregnant sheep. In 1994 they received approval from the hospital’s review board to operate on human fetuses endoscopically, inserting tiny surgical instruments, along with a miniature camera and light source, through the uterine wall. They tried four such operations, but because of technical limitations — it was difficult to see through the souplike amniotic fluid in the uterus — the results were disastrous. Two fetuses died and two were delivered prematurely.
Undeterred, Bruner and Tulipan returned to the review board in 1997 with another proposal. This time they would remove the uterus through a cesarean incision, place it on the mother’s abdomen, then cut it open and remove the amniotic fluid so they could work directly on the fetus and repair the lesion. When finished, the doctors would replace the amniotic fluid, sew up the uterus, put it back in the mother’s belly and let the pregnancy continue.
As word about the new procedure spread, Bruner and Tulipan found themselves attacked by some who thought they were playing God. One man with spina bifida, who walks with the aid of braces and is engaged to a woman with spina bifida, wrote to the Vanderbilt Web site: “I wouldn’t have wanted my mother to risk my life in an effort to make me ‘perfect.’ My life has been and continues to be VERY rewarding.”
The more common response came from parents-to-be who were willing to do almost anything to keep their children from a crippling disability. Trish and Mike Switzer traveled to Nashville in June, even after learning that their insurance company would not commit to cover the $30,000 cost of the operation and hospital stay because fetal surgery was considered experimental. Nor would the insurance company agree to pay any medical costs that might arise as a result of the surgery. “We’ll go into debt,” Switzer told Bruner. “I don’t care.”
“When couples arrive here, they are deeply, deeply wounded,” says Susan Bauman, a social worker at Vanderbilt who counsels those about to undergo the new surgery. “Some have made bargains with God, promising to do such-and-such if their baby is healed. They tell me they are praying for a miracle, that their baby can be like every other baby, and I tell them that maybe the miracle is that God will give them the strength to cope with whatever comes. And then there are mothers who don’t pray for a miracle but feel they must go through the surgery — who must put their own life on the line — as a way of paying penance for not producing a healthy baby.”
Trish admits she came to Nashville “feeling that I had failed my daughter, and that maybe this was a way I could help her.” Bauman, Bruner and one of Vanderbilt’s medical ethicists met with Trish and Mike to remind them that there was no guarantee the surgery would provide any significant medical benefit to their baby. They were also reminded that the stress from the surgeries had caused all the mothers to deliver their babies a few weeks prematurely. Although none of the babies had suffered significant trauma, there was always a danger in premature delivery. To emphasize the point, a doctor gave the Switzers a sobering tour of Vanderbilt’s neonatal intensive care unit, where infants born before 30 weeks were hooked up to oxygen tubes.
Only once did their resolve seem to waver. Because Trish hoped to correct the lesion as soon as possible, in order to prevent more problems from developing, she had wanted to schedule the surgery for the 23rd week of her pregnancy. As a nurse reminded the Switzers less than an hour before Trish was wheeled into the operating room, if she delivered during surgery, it would not be possible for the doctors to keep such a young baby alive. “If there is a delivery, would you like me to wrap the baby up and let you see it?”
“What do you mean?” asked Mike.
“Well, her heart will keep beating for a while,” the nurse said, and then she paused.
Both Mike and Trish broke into tears. “It won’t happen to Sarah Marie,” Mike said, holding his wife. “It won’t happen.”
In fact, the one-hour surgery went off without a hitch. Bruner made an incision, pulled out the football-size uterus, used an ultrasound to study the baby’s position and carefully made a small cut. Then he stepped aside for Tulipan to operate on Sarah Marie’s spine. Although the operation had nearly become routine for the two doctors — Brunen predicts that within a decade the surgery will regularly be performed at hospitals around the country — there still came a moment of awestruck silence when they peered into Trish’s womb to stare at life before birth.
Brunen reached down and lifted Sarah Marie’s hand out of the uterus. “She’s going to be beautiful,” he said.
Weighing four and a half pounds, Sarah Marie Switzer was born on August 22, almost two months after her surgery. Before she was carried to intensive care, she was briefly given to her mother, who whispered, “My baby.” Sarah Marie was nine weeks premature, but to the amazement of the pediatricians, she was so healthy she was allowed to leave the hospital in early September. Over the next weeks, she was checked by a variety of specialists. Although there was no sign of pressure on the brain from excess fluid, her head was growing at an accelerated rate, indicating that she might later require a shunt. Her feet were somewhat misshapen and seemed weak, indicating that she might need braces for walking. But she was kicking her legs, a rare act for a spina bifida baby, and she seemed alert and happy.
“It’s impossible to say what the surgery did or what it didn’t do,” Trish said as she, Mike and Sarah Marie prepared to move into a new house near the Patuxent base, where they originally met and where Mike was now going to work as an instructor. “We didn’t have a miracle, no, but at least we tried. We tried to make things different.” For a moment, her voice wobbled. “I never want us to look back on our lives and think we passed up the one opportunity we had to give our daughter a chance to walk like other children, to go running, to glide down the aisle on her wedding day.
Despite the anxiety of the past several months — despite the questions that still surround Sarah Marie’s future — Trish and Mike remain imbued with hope. As a matter of fact, Mike sat Trish down in October and brought up the subject Trish figured they would not be discussing for at least several more months. Mike suggested they start thinking about when they would have another child.
For a while, Trish said nothing. Then she smiled and said, “I’d like that.”
For more information, contact Vanderbilt University Medical Center at (615) 322-5000 or visit their site at http://www.mc.vanderbilt.edu/vanderbiltmedicine/vumc_winter05/assets_winter05/fall99.pdf .
This photo became the center of a controversy when the Fox News cable channel canned talk-show host Matt Drudge. The cyber-pundit, who broke the Monica Lewinsky story, was tossed in November after refusing to tape his weekly show. Network execs had refused to allow him to show the photo, claiming Drudge planned to use it to further his anti-abortion agenda; he cried censorship and walked.
Forerunner - Home » Florida's Murder Industry »
Your comments are welcome!
“Here I stand … I can do no other!”
With these immortal words, an unknown German monk sparked a spiritual revolution that changed the world.
The dramatic classic film of Martin Luther’s life was released in theaters worldwide in the 1950s and was nominated for two Oscars. A magnificent depiction of Luther and the forces at work in the surrounding society that resulted in his historic reform efforts, this film traces Luther’s life from a guilt-burdened monk to his eventual break with the Roman Catholic Church.
Running time: 105 minutes
Special offer: Order 5 or more for $5 each.
Watch a clip from Martin Luther.
$9.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)
What is true Revival and Spiritual Awakening?
Discover the answer in this eyewitness account by Dennis Kinlaw, President of Asbury College, Wilmore, Kentucky, who recounts the story of a visitation of the Holy Spirit in 1970. This is the presentation that has continued to spark the flames of Revival in the hearts of people around the world. Contains eyewitness footage from the Revival at Asbury College in 1970 in Wilmore, Kentucky.
Certain to challenge you to greater holiness and a deeper commitment to full-scale revival. Original news and private footage has been included. If you are a student who longs to see a spiritual awakening at your school, you must see this video!
“This simple video does a wonderful job of conveying something of God’s heart and power, Everyone we have ever shown this to has received an immediate impartation of faith for revival and the power of prayer.”
— Bob and Rose Weiner, Weiner Ministries Int’l
Running Time: 40 minutes
$19.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)
Download the Free Study Guide!
God’s Law and Society powerfully presents a comprehensive worldview based upon the ethical system found in the Law of God.
Speakers include: R.J. Rushdoony, George Grant, Howard Phillips, R.C. Sproul Jr., Ken Gentry, Gary DeMar, Jay Grimstead, Steven Schlissel, Andrew Sandlin, Eric Holmberg, and more!
Sixteen Christian leaders and scholars answer some of the most common questions and misconceptions related to this volatile issue:
1. Are we under Law or under Grace?
2. Does the Old Testament Law apply today?
3. Can we legislate morality?
4. What are the biblical foundations of government?
5. Was America founded as a Christian nation?
6. What about the separation of Church and State?
7. Is neutrality a myth?
8. What about non-Christians and the Law of God?
9. Would there be “freedom” in a Christian republic?
10. What would a “Christian America” look like?
Perfect for group instruction as well as personal Bible study.
Ten parts, over four hours of instruction!
Running Time: 240 minutes
Watch over 60 on-line video interviews from God’s Law and Society.
$19.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)
Download the Free Study Guide!
Just what is Calvinism?
Does this teaching make man a deterministic robot and God the author of sin? What about free will? If the church accepts Calvinism, won’t evangelism be stifled, perhaps even extinguished? How can we balance God’s sovereignty and man’s responsibility? What are the differences between historic Calvinism and hyper-Calvinism? Why did men like Augustine, Luther, Calvin, Spurgeon, Whitefield, Edwards and a host of renowned Protestant evangelists embrace the teaching of predestination and election and deny free will theology?
This is the first video documentary that answers these and other related questions. Hosted by Eric Holmberg, this fascinating three-part, four-hour presentation is detailed enough so as to not gloss over the controversy. At the same time, it is broken up into ten “Sunday-school-sized” sections to make the rich content manageable and accessible for the average viewer.
Running Time: 257 minutes
$19.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)
Special Two-Disc Set!
After 40 years of intense study and world-wide ministry, Dr. Francis Schaeffer completed his crowning work of scholarship – to present profound truths in simple film language. Dr. Schaeffer’s brilliant analysis of the past and predictions for current trends have proven so uncannily accurate that this amazing series still feels contemporary almost three decades after its initial release. Ultimately, Schaeffer concludes that man’s only hope is a return to God’s Biblical absolute, the truth revealed in Christ through the Scriptures.
Available for the first time on DVD, this documentary spectacular also includes intimate in-depth conversations with Francis and Edith Schaeffer. With the on-disc study guide, this presentation forms a unique course of comprehensive study. While this series forms an innovative analysis of the past, this outstanding work is more than history. Each episode focuses on a significant era, yet speaks clearly to 21st-century man with answers for modern problems.
$49.95 — ORDER NOW!(We accept all major credit cards and PayPal.)